Back to Arizona Unemployment

Fatima Al-Mansour

Do excessive earnings weeks reduce total unemployment benefit balance in Arizona DES?

So I'm six weeks into my UI claim and just realized something that's been stressing me out. Two of those weeks I earned more than my weekly benefit amount from some freelance gigs, and Arizona DES flagged them as 'excessive earnings' weeks. I reported everything honestly on my weekly certifications, got zero payment those weeks obviously, but now I'm seeing my benefit year balance and it looks like those weeks might have counted against my total anyway. My original maximum benefit amount was set at around $5,800 and I'm trying to figure out if those two weeks where I made too much actually chewed into that balance even though I got nothing. Anyone dealt with this? The CACTUS portal doesn't really explain it clearly and I can't find a straight answer anywhere.

$240 was the number that shocked me when I first ran the math on my own claim. Each week in your benefit year, Arizona DES essentially 'uses up' one of your 26 available weeks regardless of whether you got paid anything. So if you had two excessive earnings weeks where you certified but got $0, those weeks still count as two of your 26 weeks gone from your benefit year. Your total dollar balance doesn't shrink by your WBA amount for those weeks since you weren't paid, but you lose the time slot. Effectively your maximum potential payout goes down because you have fewer weeks left to collect even though the dollar balance looks the same.

0 coins

Wait, so the dollar balance stays the same but I just have fewer weeks to use it? Does that mean if I never have another excessive earnings week I can still collect the full remaining dollar amount?

0 coins

Exactly right. The dollar figure stays put, the weeks are what get consumed. So your remaining weeks will be fewer but whatever dollar balance is left is still accessible across those remaining weeks.

0 coins

This is how I finally understood it too - think of it like a hotel with 26 room nights booked. Zero-pay nights still check off a night whether you sleep there or not.

0 coins

Technically there's a distinction worth knowing - Arizona DES calls them 'non-compensable weeks' when earnings exceed your WBA plus any partial benefit threshold. Those weeks get counted toward your benefit year duration but zero dollars get charged off your maximum benefit amount. So your MBA is preserved dollar-for-dollar, you just burned a calendar week.

0 coins

Good to know, that's slightly reassuring. So my $5,800 balance is still fully intact even after those two weeks?

0 coins

Should be, yes. Log into CACTUS and look at your 'Benefit Payment History' - it'll show $0.00 for those excessive earnings weeks and your running balance won't have moved.

0 coins

Confirmed this is accurate. Had three excessive earnings weeks last year and my dollar balance didn't budge. Lost three weeks off my 26 though which stung at the end of my benefit year.

0 coins

Claimyr got me through to an actual Arizona DES rep in under 20 minutes when I had almost this exact question about how earnings weeks were affecting my account. The agent pulled up my claim on the spot and walked me through exactly what counted against my dollar balance vs. what just ate a calendar week. Worth trying if you want a real answer fast - claimyr.com and there's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/vwA1GGuV83Y

0 coins

Appreciate that, I've been trying to call DES for days. Does it actually get you past the busy signal?

0 coins

Got through without sitting on hold forever. The agent I reached was able to see every week on my claim and explain the excessive earnings coding right there.

0 coins

Saving this link. I gave up calling DES after 4 days of busy signals and just guessed at my situation. Probably should have checked sooner.

0 coins

26 weeks is your maximum duration in Arizona but here's the part people miss - excessive earnings weeks are 'used' weeks in terms of your benefit year clock, not your dollar bank. Arizona DES uses a system where your benefit year is 52 calendar weeks long from the date you filed, but you only get 26 payable weeks within that year. Miss some to excessive earnings and those slots are just gone.

0 coins

Right, and my benefit year started in early January so I'm on a clock here. If I have more high-earning freelance weeks coming up, I should probably think about this strategically?

0 coins

Definitely. If you know you'll have several consecutive high-earning weeks, some people consider whether it makes sense to maintain the claim at all during that stretch vs. just filing a new one later - though that has its own complications.

0 coins

Filing a new claim during a high-earning stretch is complicated because you'd need to meet new base period requirements. Not always possible.

0 coins

True, good point. Usually better to keep the existing claim active and just accept the lost weeks.

0 coins

Something nobody mentioned yet - partial weeks are different from excessive earnings weeks and they DO reduce your dollar balance. If you earn something but it's under your WBA, Arizona DES uses the earnings disregard formula ($30 plus 30% of remaining WBA) and pays you a reduced amount. That reduced payment comes right off your MBA. Only the full excessive earnings weeks, where you get $0, leave your dollar balance untouched.

0 coins

Oh that's a genuinely important distinction. So partial benefit weeks cost me money from my balance but excessive weeks only cost me time?

0 coins

Exactly. A week where you earn, say, $400 against a $240 WBA might net you $60-70 in benefits after the disregard math, and that $60-70 comes off your MBA. A week where you earn $600 against a $240 WBA gets you nothing, costs you nothing from the dollar bank.

0 coins

This is the thing that confused me for weeks on my claim. Had to use Claimyr to get someone on the phone who would actually explain the partial payment formula to me because the DES website explanation made zero sense. The agent did the math live on my claim.

0 coins

BEEN DEALING WITH THIS EXACT THING. Three weeks of freelance killed three of my weeks and I didn't even realize until I was at week 20 and started panicking. The portal just shows the balance and doesn't scream at you that you're losing calendar weeks!! Why is this not explained anywhere obvious on the site??

0 coins

That's exactly my fear - finding out too late. Did you end up losing benefits at the end because of those weeks?

0 coins

Yes. Hit my 26-week mark two weeks before my benefit year ended and had $400 still sitting in my balance that I literally couldn't collect because I'd used up all 26 weeks. That money just disappeared.

0 coins

That is genuinely infuriating. The system should warn you when excessive earnings weeks are coming off your week count.

0 coins

There should be a banner or something. Instead you're just supposed to know.

0 coins

One thing to verify - when you look at your CACTUS account under claim details, there should be a field showing 'Weeks Remaining' separate from 'Balance Remaining.' Check both numbers. If your excessive earnings weeks processed correctly, your Weeks Remaining should be lower by those two weeks but your Balance Remaining should be unchanged from before those weeks.

0 coins

Just checked - weeks remaining shows 18 (started with 26, used 6 normal weeks and 2 excessive earnings weeks) and balance looks right. So it's working as described here.

0 coins

Good, that confirms the excessive earnings weeks coded correctly and your dollar balance is protected. 18 weeks left is still a decent runway.

0 coins

Always worth verifying this after any zero-pay week. I had one code incorrectly as a 'failed to certify' week which actually DID affect my balance and took two phone calls to fix.

0 coins

Something I learned the hard way - once your benefit year ends, any remaining dollar balance just expires. So those excessive earnings weeks matter more toward the end of your benefit year than at the beginning. If you've got $1,200 left and only 2 weeks remaining but had 4 excessive earnings weeks earlier, you might not have enough weeks to collect that money.

0 coins

That's what happened to the person above. Is there any way to request an extension or carry over unused balance?

0 coins

No carryover in Arizona. When the benefit year ends, that's it. You'd need to file a new claim and have a new base period with enough wages to qualify. The expired balance doesn't transfer.

0 coins

Had $780 expire on me at the end of my benefit year. Devastating. Arizona DES would not budge on it.

0 coins

Just want to add that the excessive earnings threshold isn't just your WBA. Arizona calculates it differently than most people assume. Your WBA plus any dependents allowance, if you have one, factors into the calculation. So someone with a $240 WBA and $25 dependents allowance has a slightly higher threshold before hitting excessive earnings.

0 coins

Good point - I don't have dependents so it's simpler for me, but that's worth knowing. Where do you find that threshold number on the CACTUS site?

0 coins

Under 'Claim Details' your weekly benefit amount and any allowances are listed. Add them together and that's your effective threshold. Earn more than that in a week and you're in excessive earnings territory.

0 coins

Does that dependents allowance also count toward the earnings disregard calculation or just the threshold?

0 coins

Just the threshold as far as I understand. The disregard formula of $30 plus 30% stays based on WBA alone. Though honestly I'd double check that with DES directly because it gets complicated.

0 coins

My situation was confusing because I had gig work that varied week to week. Some weeks excessive earnings, some weeks partial, some weeks nothing. Tracking what came off my balance vs. just my week count was a nightmare. Eventually I built a spreadsheet matching each week's gross earnings to what DES paid out and what came off my balance.

0 coins

Spreadsheet is a good idea. Did your math at the end match what CACTUS showed?

0 coins

Pretty close. Off by like $12 which I think was a rounding difference in the disregard calculation. The bigger picture numbers matched well.

0 coins

I did something similar but just used the CACTUS payment history export. Made it easier than manual entry.

0 coins

Used Claimyr last month specifically to ask about excessive earnings weeks and whether I was going to run out of weeks before my benefit year ended. The DES agent pulled up my week-by-week breakdown and told me exactly how many usable weeks I had left. Took way less time than I expected compared to calling directly - claimyr.com if anyone needs it.

0 coins

Might actually do this. Did they explain the difference between dollar balance and week count in terms of what you can actually collect?

0 coins

Yes, the agent walked through it clearly. She said exactly what others here said - dollar balance is preserved on excessive earnings weeks, only the week slot is consumed. Hearing it confirmed by an actual DES agent was reassuring.

0 coins

Worth it just for the confirmation piece. I've been told things by people online and then had DES agents say something slightly different.

0 coins

For anyone reading this later trying to understand the actual mechanics - Arizona uses a Maximum Benefit Amount calculated as the lower of either 26 times your WBA or about 46% of your base period wages. That MBA is your dollar ceiling. Excessive earnings weeks don't chip away at that dollar ceiling, but they do eat your 26-week duration limit. Both the MBA and the 26 weeks act as caps and whichever you hit first ends your benefits.

0 coins

So I could theoretically exhaust my 26 weeks while still having dollar balance left, or exhaust the dollar balance before hitting 26 weeks?

0 coins

Yes to both scenarios. If your WBA is $240 and your MBA is $5,800, 26 weeks at $240 is $6,240 which exceeds your MBA - so you'd hit the dollar cap around week 24 anyway. Someone with a higher WBA relative to their MBA might hit 26 weeks first. It depends on your individual claim amounts.

0 coins

This is actually the clearest explanation of the two-cap system I've seen written out. Bookmarking this thread.

0 coins

wait so if you get $0 on a week because you made too much, that week still gets checked off your 26?? i always thought only paid weeks counted

0 coins

Certified-and-processed weeks count toward your duration whether you got paid or not. The act of certifying and having DES determine $0 payable uses the week slot.

0 coins

omg that changes everything for me. i had like 4 of those weeks and thought i still had my full 26 available

0 coins

Yeah it trips a lot of people up. Worth logging into CACTUS right now and checking your actual remaining weeks count.

0 coins

The phrasing on the CACTUS portal is confusing because it says 'Weeks of Benefits Used' and some people think that means only paid weeks. It actually means all processed weeks, including zero-pay ones. Arizona DES really should label it 'Weeks Processed' or something clearer.

0 coins

Agreed, the portal language is part of why I had to come here to ask. 'Benefits Used' implies money was paid.

0 coins

Exactly. When you think 'used' you think money out the door. But DES uses it to mean the week slot was used even if the payout was $0.

0 coins

Filed for two months before I figured this out. The terminology on the site is genuinely bad.

0 coins

Another wrinkle - if you request a waiver or have an overpayment from a previous benefit year, that can interact weirdly with your current MBA. Completely separate from the excessive earnings issue but worth knowing if your CACTUS balance looks off for other reasons.

0 coins

No overpayment issues thankfully. Good to know though for future reference.

0 coins

Good. Overpayment offsets are a whole other headache. Glad that's not your situation.

0 coins

Had an overpayment offset from 2023 that randomly started reducing my current claim payments. Took forever to get DES to explain what was happening.

0 coins

One more thing worth confirming - excessive earnings weeks do NOT reset or extend your benefit year. Some people think that since you got no money, DES will give you those weeks back somehow. It doesn't work that way. Your benefit year end date is fixed from the day you filed, and no zero-pay weeks change that date.

0 coins

That's what I figured but good to have it confirmed. So my benefit year end date stays the same no matter what.

0 coins

Correct. Filed January 10th means your benefit year runs through January 9th the following year, period. What happens inside that year with excessive earnings or partial weeks doesn't change the endpoint.

0 coins

Used Claimyr after getting endlessly busy signals trying to call DES about whether my excessive earnings weeks were coded right. The agent I got confirmed my week count and balance and also caught that one of my weeks had been coded as a 'non-certify' instead of 'excessive earnings' which was going to cause a problem. Got it corrected on the spot. Site is claimyr.com - honestly saved me a lot of back and forth.

0 coins

That coding error thing is exactly what I'm worried about. Good to know an agent can spot and fix it in one call.

0 coins

The agent said those miscoding errors happen when high-earning weeks are reported with certain types of income - gig work especially. Worth having an agent verify the coding is right if you have freelance income like OP.

0 coins

Had a miscoding on my account for two months before I noticed. Took three calls to get it fixed. Having someone catch it early is so much better.

0 coins

Came across Claimyr from a different forum thread about DES contact issues and tried it after weeks of failed calls. Got someone who could actually see my claim details and explain my excessive earnings coding. If you're still not getting clear answers from CACTUS, that's worth trying.

0 coins

Thanks, I've got a better picture now from this thread but might still call to verify the actual coding on my account.

0 coins

That's the main reason I'd recommend it - not just to understand the rules, which you can get here, but to verify your specific account is set up correctly.

0 coins

Just want to add closure for people finding this thread - OP's situation where MBA stays intact but weeks get consumed is the correct behavior and is working as Arizona DES intends it to work. The design is actually semi-claimant-friendly in that your dollar ceiling is protected, you just lose time. Much better than if excessive earnings weeks docked both time AND money.

0 coins

Agreed, and I feel a lot better about my situation now. Those two weeks cost me time but my $5,800 balance is fully intact. Thanks everyone.

0 coins

Good outcome. Keep tracking both numbers - weeks remaining and dollar balance - separately as you go forward.

0 coins

Worth doing a quick audit every 4-5 weeks just to catch any coding errors early before they become harder to fix.

0 coins

Arizona Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure