Back to Arizona Unemployment

Yuki Yamamoto

Confused about unemployment tax rates for business 2018 - how does Arizona DES handle this?

So I've been going through some old payroll records trying to reconcile an audit situation with my small landscaping company and I keep running into questions about how the unemployment tax side of things works. Specifically the question that's haunting me is around the period of unemployment tax rates for business 2018 - we had some turnover that year and I'm not even sure if we were assigned the right rate by Arizona DES at the time. We had three employees separate from us between March and October 2018 and two of them filed unemployment claims. Fast forward to now and I'm getting some notices that reference our account history from that period and I genuinely don't know if what we paid was accurate. My accountant retired and the person who took over our books has no idea either. Has anyone dealt with going back and reviewing old UI tax rate assignments with Arizona DES? Is there even a way to request documentation from that far back?

Wait, 2018 records? That's a long reach back. Arizona DES does keep employer account histories but pulling records from that far back usually means you're dealing with their older system data. The rate assignments from 2018 were based on your reserve ratio at the end of the prior fiscal year - basically how much you'd paid in versus how much had been drawn out against your account. If two employees filed and were approved that year, those benefit charges would have hit your account and potentially bumped your rate for the following year, not 2018 itself. Are the notices you're getting now referencing a specific rate period or just your general account?

0 coins

They reference our 'experience rating period' and mention 2018 as a base year for some calculation. I honestly don't even know what I'm looking at. The notices came certified mail and I've been afraid to call because I don't know enough to have an intelligent conversation with anyone.

0 coins

Experience rating is exactly the formula the previous commenter is describing. Your 2018 UI tax rate would have been set based on your layoff history and taxable wage base from prior years. If you had turnover in 2018, the charges from those claims would have affected your 2019 and 2020 rates more than 2018 itself. The notice might be a re-audit of that calculation period.

0 coins

That actually helps clarify things a bit. So the charges from 2018 separations would roll forward rather than immediately changing my rate that same year?

0 coins

Okay first off - have you actually been able to get anyone at Arizona DES on the phone? Because I went through something weirdly similar with my employer account last year and the phone situation was a nightmare. I eventually used Claimyr - it basically works the hold queue for you so you end up actually talking to a live Arizona DES agent instead of spending your morning listening to hold music. Site is claimyr.com and there's a demo video at https://youtu.be/vwA1GGuV83Y - honestly the only reason I got my employer account questions answered was because I finally got through to someone who could pull up the actual records.

0 coins

Hadn't heard of that before - I've been dreading the phone call but I do need to actually talk to someone who can see our account. I'll check that out.

0 coins

Same, the hold times for employer accounts are brutal. Arizona DES has two different queues too - one for claimants and one for employers - so make sure you're calling the right number or you'll wait forever and get transferred anyway.

0 coins

Does that work for employer line or just the regular claimant line? I've got a business account question too and wasn't sure.

0 coins

$47 - that was what surprised me when I finally dug into our 2018 UI tax situation. We were paying $47 more per employee per quarter than we should have been because Arizona DES had our NAICS industry code wrong in their system, which put us in a higher rate table. The way the rate tables work: Arizona DES groups employers by industry and assigns a range of possible rates within that group based on your experience. If your code is wrong you could be in the wrong bracket entirely. Worth verifying that your industry classification was correct for 2018.

0 coins

Pulled up our old quarterly reports just now and I see a code listed but I honestly have no idea if it's right for landscaping. How do you even verify what it should have been?

0 coins

NAICS codes are on the census bureau website - you just look up your business type and it gives you the standard code. For landscaping it would typically be in the 561700 range. If what's on your Arizona DES documents doesn't match, that's something worth raising with them.

0 coins

This is a real thing that happens more than people realize. I've seen small businesses overpaying for years because nobody caught an industry code error. Arizona DES isn't going to flag it for you - you have to catch it yourself.

0 coins

Can I jump in with a slightly different angle? I'm a bookkeeper who handles several small Arizona businesses and the 2018 rate period is actually interesting because that was before some of the trust fund adjustments that came later. The Arizona UI tax rate for 2018 had a standard new employer rate and then an experience-rated range. New employers in most industries were at something like 2.0% for the first couple years, then you get experience-rated after you've been in the system long enough. How long had your business been operating before 2018? That affects whether you were even on experience rating yet.

0 coins

We started in 2014 so we would have been past the new employer rate by then. I think we were experience-rated but I'm not 100% sure what rate we were actually assigned.

0 coins

Four years in means you were definitely experience-rated by 2018. Arizona DES sends annual rate notices - usually in December or January - telling you your rate for the coming year. If you have any old paper files from early 2018, there should be a notice showing your assigned rate for that calendar year. If you don't have that, your accountant's old files might have it.

0 coins

Those annual rate notices are SO easy to miss if you're a small business owner doing everything yourself. I literally found mine in a pile of mail I hadn't opened for two months once.

0 coins

This whole thread is making me realize I have no idea what rate we've been paying either and I've had my business for six years now. Is there a way to look this up online without calling? Like on the Arizona DES employer portal?

0 coins

Yes - Arizona DES has an employer portal where you can see your account history, rate notices, and contribution statements. It's separate from the CACTUS system claimants use. If you haven't set up your employer account online, that's worth doing. You can usually see rate history going back several years.

0 coins

Just went and checked my portal login and I can see my current rate but the history only goes back to 2020. Is there a way to see older data or do you have to request it?

0 coins

Anything pre-2020 on the employer side usually requires a formal records request or just asking an Arizona DES agent to pull it up while you're on the phone. The online history got truncated when they updated the system.

0 coins

Honestly I feel like the whole experience rating system is designed to be confusing on purpose. I had a situation where one employee quit voluntarily - which should NOT charge my account - but Arizona DES initially approved her claim anyway. It took me filing a protest and waiting three months to get the charge reversed. If you had any voluntary quits in 2018 among those three separations, those should not have been charged to your account.

0 coins

Two of the three were layoffs - slow season - but one was definitely a resignation. I never protested anything because I didn't know I could. Is that something I can still raise now?

0 coins

After this long? Probably not for the original charge, but it's worth asking Arizona DES directly. Sometimes there are formal review processes and sometimes they tell you the window closed. Either way you'd need documentation that the separation was voluntary - ideally the resignation letter or termination paperwork.

0 coins

This is why you have to respond to EVERY separation notice Arizona DES sends. So many small business owners ignore them and end up with charges they shouldn't have.

0 coins

Wait I'm confused about something - are UI tax rates the same as the unemployment insurance that gets taken out of employee paychecks? My business does both and I always thought they were connected but someone told me they're separate things.

0 coins

They're totally different. UI taxes (what this thread is about) are paid entirely by the employer - it's a tax on your payroll that funds the unemployment system. Nothing comes out of your employees' checks for this. What might be coming out of their checks is state income tax withholding or federal stuff, but not UI.

0 coins

Oh wow okay. So my employees' wages affect my tax rate but they don't pay into it themselves?

0 coins

Exactly right. The more employees you lay off who collect benefits, the higher your future experience rate can go - because those benefits got charged against your account. But it all comes from the employer side.

0 coins

$8,000 was the taxable wage base for Arizona UI back around that period if I'm remembering right - meaning you only paid the UI tax rate on the first $8,000 of each employee's wages per year. So if you had three employees making decent money, you'd hit that ceiling pretty fast and stop accruing the tax for the rest of the year. Worth double-checking what the actual 2018 taxable wage base was because I might be slightly off on the number.

0 coins

That's in the right ballpark. Arizona's taxable wage base has gone up over the years - for 2018 I believe it was $7,000 actually, though the exact figure would be in the official rate notice. The point about hitting the ceiling early is valid for anyone with full-time employees making more than entry-level wages.

0 coins

Found an old QuickBooks report and it shows we stopped accruing FUTA and SUTA around mid-year for two of our employees. That tracks with what you're saying about hitting a ceiling.

0 coins

FUTA and SUTA are different taxes by the way - FUTA is federal, SUTA is state (Arizona's). But yes, they both have wage base ceilings and you'd typically hit them around the same time for any employee making a reasonable wage.

0 coins

Had a similar employer account question a few months ago and I want to second what someone said earlier about actually getting a human on the phone. I tried Claimyr after weeks of not getting through and ended up speaking with an Arizona DES employer specialist who pulled up my full account history right there on the call. She was able to tell me exactly what my rate had been and why. For something like reconciling a 2018 audit question, you really need that level of access to your specific account - no website or forum is going to give you what an agent with your file can.

0 coins

This is pushing me to actually make the call. Did the agent seem knowledgeable about the older account periods or did they have to escalate?

0 coins

She pulled everything up without escalating. She mentioned that the older records are in a different part of their system but agents can access it - it just takes a minute longer to load apparently.

0 coins

Good to know there are actual specialists for the employer side. I always assumed it was just the same general line and you'd get whoever answered.

0 coins

1.5% was the minimum experience rate for most Arizona employers in 2018 and around 5.4% was near the top end of the scale if I recall correctly. The spread between those two numbers is massive when you're talking about annual payroll costs. A small business with $200,000 in taxable wages would pay $3,000 at the low end or $10,800 at the high end. If you were incorrectly placed at a higher rate, that's real money.

0 coins

Okay that range is alarming. We had maybe $160,000 in total payroll that year and I have no idea where on that spectrum we fell. This is exactly why I need to actually see documentation.

0 coins

And those rate differences compound over multiple years because your rate for 2019 was based partly on 2018 charges, and so on. An error in one year can ripple forward.

0 coins

Exactly. That's why audits that touch historical periods can be significant - you're not just looking at one year, you're looking at the downstream effects too.

0 coins

Something nobody's mentioned yet - if the audit notice you received is from Arizona DES itself rather than an external audit, they might already have flagged a discrepancy. Arizona DES audits employer accounts periodically and if they're sending you certified mail about a 2018 period, they might have identified something they want to discuss. That's different from you discovering an error on your own. Do you know who sent the certified mail?

0 coins

Looked at the envelope again - it's from the Arizona Department of Economic Security. So yes, it's from them. The letter references a 'contribution rate review' and asks me to contact them within 30 days.

0 coins

30 days means you have a deadline and you need to respond within that window. Don't let that date pass without at minimum sending written acknowledgment that you received it and are gathering documentation.

0 coins

This is now more urgent than a general question about historical rates. If Arizona DES sent that, there's something specific they've identified and a 30-day response window means you need to act. Get a professional if you don't have one yet.

0 coins

Can I ask - did you keep any of your quarterly contribution reports from 2018? In Arizona those are the UI-6 forms (or the online equivalent). Those forms show your wage totals, the tax rate applied, and what you actually paid each quarter. If you have all four from 2018 you can basically reconstruct the whole picture without waiting for Arizona DES to pull anything.

0 coins

Went through the old filing cabinet and found two of the four quarters. The other two I think my old accountant filed electronically and I never got paper copies.

0 coins

Two quarters is better than nothing. You can at least verify the rate they were using on those quarters and check whether it's consistent. If the rate changes between Q1 and Q3 that could indicate an adjustment was made mid-year.

0 coins

Electronic records should still be on the Arizona DES employer portal even if your accountant filed them. Might be worth logging in and checking the submission history from 2018 if the portal goes back that far.

0 coins

The 30-day deadline part jumped out at me. That's not a lot of time if you're starting from scratch on this. What's the worst that happens if you miss it?

0 coins

Missing a response deadline on an Arizona DES contribution rate review can result in them making a determination without your input - basically they assess whatever they think you owe without hearing your side. That could mean a larger liability than if you'd responded. It's really important to meet that window.

0 coins

That's scary honestly. Even just calling and saying 'I got this, I'm working on it' would be better than nothing?

0 coins

Yes, reaching out before the deadline - even to say you need more time - is almost always better than silence. Some agents will note your account that you're in process of responding.

0 coins

Just want to flag something for anyone else reading this thread who has a small business - responding to Arizona DES separation notices within 10 days of when an employee files is critical. So many people skip that step and it ends up affecting their rate for the next couple years. The 2018 situation in this thread might have been avoidable if the voluntary quit separation had been protested at the time.

0 coins

10 days goes by SO fast when you're running a business. I missed a protest window once because I thought I had two weeks and by the time I got my documents together the deadline had passed.

0 coins

Arizona DES mails the notice when a claim is filed, not when it's approved. So the clock starts ticking immediately even before you know if the claim will even be paid.

0 coins

This is probably the most important thing in this whole thread for any employer reading it. The protest window is short and once it's gone it's really hard to reverse a charge.

0 coins

Tried to call Arizona DES employer line three times last week about my own rate question and kept hitting the busy signal loop. Used Claimyr on my fourth try and actually got to talk to someone in the employer unit. Wild how much easier that was. OP - with a 30-day clock ticking this might be worth trying just to make sure you don't burn days on failed call attempts.

0 coins

30-day deadline plus a known phone situation is not a great combination. I'm going to try tonight.

0 coins

Does the employer unit use the same number or is it a different line from the claimant number?

0 coins

Different number. Arizona DES has a dedicated employer line separate from the claimant line. It's on the DES website under the employer section. You'll want to make sure you're calling that one specifically for contribution rate questions.

0 coins

Used Claimyr myself when I had an employer account issue last spring. Got connected with an Arizona DES agent who actually seemed to specialize in the tax and contribution side rather than the claims side - apparently they route employer calls differently. If you go that route just have your employer account number ready and know what years you're asking about.

0 coins

Good tip about having the account number ready. I found it on one of the quarterly forms I dug up. What else should I have in front of me when I call?

0 coins

Have the dates of employment for each of the three workers who left in 2018, whatever rate you think you were paying, and the certified letter reference number if the letter has one. That way the agent can pull the right records immediately.

0 coins

Also write down your questions in advance before the call. I always go blank when I finally get someone on the phone and then remember my questions after I hang up.

0 coins

There's also the question of what happens if the audit finds an underpayment versus an overpayment. If Arizona DES determines you underpaid, there's interest and potentially penalties on top of the base amount. If they determine you overpaid, you can usually get a credit applied to future contributions. The resolution process is very different depending on which direction it goes.

0 coins

I've been assuming it's going to be bad news but actually I'm not sure which way this goes. The two approved claims would push my rate up, but if the industry code was wrong it could have inflated things beyond that. It's genuinely unclear.

0 coins

That's actually a reason to call rather than dread the outcome. It might be more neutral or even favorable than you're fearing. Arizona DES agents can walk you through the numbers once they have your account pulled up.

0 coins

Came back to say - in my situation the industry code fix actually resulted in a credit. We'd been overpaying for two years. So yes, the resolution isn't always painful.

0 coins

Is anyone else mildly horrified that this person has had a 30-day response deadline sitting in their mailbox while trying to figure out what it means? No judgment at all because I would absolutely do the same thing, but just - yikes. OP please call tomorrow morning first thing.

0 coins

Trust me I am very aware. I opened the letter like four days ago and have been in a spiral since. I'm calling first thing tomorrow with the account number and my documents and hopefully getting some answers.

0 coins

Good luck - seriously. Come back and update this thread when you know what's going on. I think a lot of people would find it helpful to hear how the conversation with Arizona DES went.

0 coins

Rooting for you. The uncertainty is almost always worse than whatever the actual answer turns out to be.

0 coins

Arizona Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure