Back to Arizona Unemployment

Omar Farouk

Can you collect a pension and unemployment insurance at the same time in Arizona?

So I just got laid off from my job at a logistics company where I'd been working for 11 years. I'm 61 years old and I do receive a pension from a previous employer - a union job I left back in 2018. The pension pays me about $890 a month. I filed for unemployment through Arizona DES last week and now I'm second-guessing myself because I don't know if getting that pension money disqualifies me or reduces what I can get from UI. I reported my pension when I filled out my initial claim but the system just accepted everything and moved on. Nobody flagged anything or sent me a message about it. My weekly benefit amount shows as calculated but I have no idea if DES actually factored in my pension or if this is going to come back to bite me later as some kind of overpayment situation. Has anyone actually dealt with this? Does Arizona DES reduce your weekly unemployment benefit because of a pension you're getting? Or are they completely separate? I really don't want to get hit with an overpayment notice six months from now because I didn't understand the rules going in.

I went through almost exactly this situation about eight months ago - drawing a pension from an old municipal job while trying to file for UI after a layoff. Getting any straight answers from Arizona DES by phone was basically impossible, I'd sit on hold for two hours and either get disconnected or give up. What finally worked for me was using Claimyr - you basically let it do the waiting so you end up talking to an actual live Arizona DES agent. The site is claimyr.com and there's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/vwA1GGuV83Y. That agent was the one who explained the pension offset rules to me in plain language and cleared up my whole situation.

0 coins

Had no clue there was anything that could help cut through the hold time nightmare at Arizona DES. I've literally been dialing at 7:58am and still waiting over an hour just to get dropped. Bookmarking that link.

0 coins

Same here, the hold times have been brutal lately. Did the agent you spoke with say anything about how they calculate whether your pension counts against your UI?

0 coins

Yeah she walked me through the whole thing. It basically depends on who funded the pension - if your former employer contributed to it, there can be a dollar-for-dollar reduction on your weekly UI amount. If you funded it entirely yourself, it may not affect your benefits at all. She pulled up my account right there and told me exactly how much my pension was reducing my weekly amount.

0 coins

The pension offset question is actually one I researched pretty heavily when I was in a similar spot. Here's how I'd approach it if I were you - first thing I'd do is figure out exactly who was putting money into your pension. Was it just you through payroll deductions, or was your old employer also contributing? That answer determines almost everything about how Arizona DES treats it. The way DES handles it is roughly this: pensions funded by an employer you're ALSO claiming UI from, or a base period employer, can reduce your weekly benefit dollar for dollar. Pensions you funded entirely yourself through your own contributions generally don't get counted against you. The tricky middle ground is partially employer-funded pensions from jobs not in your base period - those can go either way depending on the specifics.

0 coins

This is really helpful. My old union job - the pension is from that employer, so they were contributing to it. But I haven't worked there since 2018. Does the base period thing matter here? My layoff was from a totally different company.

0 coins

That's the key question. Arizona DES looks at a base period of roughly the first four of your last five completed calendar quarters. If your union pension employer isn't in that window - and if you left in 2018 they almost certainly aren't - there's a decent chance the pension offset doesn't apply or is minimal. But I'd really verify this directly with DES because the rules have enough exceptions that your situation might not follow the standard path.

0 coins

wait so if he pays out of pocket for his own pension like a 401k type thing that he funded himself does that count differently than a union pension? asking for myself too

0 coins

JUST went through this whole ordeal and I am still annoyed about it honestly. Arizona DES website gives you basically zero useful information about pension offsets, it's buried somewhere in their policy manual that normal people are never going to find. I reported my pension exactly like you did and the system just kept moving and I thought I was fine. Three months later I get a letter saying my weekly amount was being recalculated because of the pension income. They didn't take away my benefits entirely but my weekly check dropped by like $340. I wish someone had warned me upfront.

0 coins

Oh no, that's exactly what I'm afraid of. Did they make you pay back the difference for those three months before they caught it?

0 coins

They sent me an overpayment notice for the difference, yes. It was not a fun amount of money. I did appeal it on the grounds that I had reported the pension when I filed and the system accepted it without flagging anything, but the appeals process took forever and I ended up having to set up a repayment plan. Report your pension proactively and get it in writing from DES what your adjusted benefit should be - don't wait for them to figure it out later.

0 coins

that is so messed up that the system just accepts everything and then hits you months later. how is someone supposed to know what they owe when DES doesn't flag it at the time

0 coins

Something worth knowing before you panic too much - not every pension automatically reduces your UI benefits in Arizona. The offset rules under Arizona Revised Statutes have some specific conditions that have to be met. I'd look at it this way: think about whether your pension is coming from one of your base period employers. Base period in Arizona is typically the first four of your last five completed calendar quarters before you filed. If the employer paying your pension isn't in that window, the full pension offset may not apply. Also there's a nuance about partial vs full funding. If your pension is a defined benefit plan that your old employer funded and you had zero contributions to it, the offset rules are pretty clear. If you were contributing to it alongside the employer, only the employer's proportional share might be counted against your UI. Worth getting this clarified before you file your first weekly claim.

0 coins

I had always thought any retirement income at all just automatically disqualified you from unemployment and that wasn't true at all from what I'm reading here. Never knew there were these distinctions.

0 coins

Yeah it's one of the most misunderstood parts of the whole UI system. Social Security income also has different treatment than pension income, and IRA withdrawals you initiate yourself are generally treated differently again. The rules aren't simple but they're not 'all retirement income = disqualified' either.

0 coins

This actually makes me feel a little better. My pension is definitely from a job I left in 2018 so they should not be in my base period at all. But I want to confirm that with someone at DES directly before I just assume I'm fine.

0 coins

Exactly right - confirm it in writing if you can. Even a note in your CACTUS portal account that shows DES acknowledged the pension would be useful if anything gets disputed later.

0 coins

my dad was in almost this exact situation last year, retired from the city but got a part time job and then that part time place shut down. he was getting his city pension the whole time. Arizona DES told him over the phone that since the city wasn't one of his recent employers they used to calculate the benefit, the pension didn't reduce his UI at all. he collected full UI for about 5 months. so it does work out sometimes depending on the specifics

0 coins

That's genuinely encouraging to hear. Did your dad have any trouble getting through to DES to get that answer? I've been trying to reach them and just hitting the hold wall every time.

0 coins

oh yeah it took him like three attempts over different days before he got someone. he said he called right when they opened on a Tuesday and that was the time it finally worked. not a perfect system lol

0 coins

Tuesday and Wednesday mornings right at opening have been slightly better in my experience too. Still not guaranteed but better than trying on a Monday or the day after any holiday.

0 coins

Something nobody's mentioned yet - the pension offset question is separate from the issue of whether you're 'able and available' to work. Even if your pension doesn't reduce your weekly benefit amount, you still have to meet all the regular Arizona DES eligibility requirements. That means being able to work, being available to accept full-time work, and completing your four job search activities every week. I know that sounds obvious but I've seen people get tripped up thinking pension income is the main issue when really it's the job search log that gets them disqualified.

0 coins

No, I fully intend to keep looking for work. I'm 61 not 81, I want to stay employed. The pension is just supplemental income from my old union years. So that part shouldn't be an issue.

0 coins

Then you're in good shape on that front. Just make sure your job search activities are actually documented - Arizona DES has been auditing those logs more carefully and they want real company names, real application methods, real contact info. Not just 'applied online to unknown company.

0 coins

the job search stuff is real, they flagged me once for not having enough detail in my log and I had to go in and explain myself. document everything

0 coins

I want to flag something that might actually affect your situation specifically. You said you've been at the logistics company for 11 years - did they offer any kind of retirement or pension benefit there? If the company you just got laid off from also had a pension plan and they were contributing on your behalf, that could be the pension that triggers the offset, not your old union pension. Just worth double-checking whether you have two pension sources and which employer is associated with each.

0 coins

Oh that's a good point I hadn't thought about. The logistics company did have a 401k match but I handled all the withdrawals and rollovers myself - I don't think there's an ongoing pension payment from them. But you're right that I should be clear about what counts as a pension versus a 401k I control.

0 coins

Yeah that's an important distinction - a 401k that you manage and decide when to draw from is treated differently than an employer-funded defined benefit pension that just pays you monthly whether you want it to or not. The latter is what DES is most focused on with the offset rules.

0 coins

This is a really good catch. A lot of people conflate pension and 401k and they're very different from Arizona DES's perspective. If the OP is only getting monthly payments from the old union job defined benefit plan, that's the one to focus on.

0 coins

Wanted to add my experience since I went through the pension plus UI situation about a year ago. After spending way too many mornings redialing Arizona DES and getting nowhere, someone in a different forum thread mentioned Claimyr. I tried it and wound up speaking with an Arizona DES agent that same afternoon. She pulled up my claim, looked at how I'd reported my pension, and told me exactly what adjustment if any was going to be made. Saved me weeks of wondering. If getting through by phone has been a problem for you, claimyr.com is worth a look.

0 coins

How long did it take before you were actually talking to someone at DES? I keep seeing this mentioned and I'm curious how the timing works out.

0 coins

For me it was the same day I tried it. I had tried on my own for three straight days before that so it felt pretty significant.

0 coins

I'm going to try this. I have a different pension question for DES that I've been trying to get answered for two weeks and the phone situation is just unworkable.

0 coins

ok so wait im confused now. is a pension the same as social security? because i thought social security was separate from UI but pensions are from employers so maybe they count different? just trying to understand for myself bc i might be in this situation next year when i turn 62

0 coins

They're definitely treated differently. Social Security retirement benefits and UI can generally be collected at the same time in Arizona without an automatic offset - they're federal retirement benefits you paid into your whole working life. Employer pensions are what DES has the offset rules for, and even then it depends on whether that employer is in your base period and how the pension was funded.

0 coins

oh okay that makes way more sense. so like if i start taking social security at 62 and then lose my job i can still file for UI? good to know

0 coins

Correct, though you'd still need to meet the other eligibility requirements - available for work, actively job searching, and so on. The Social Security income doesn't automatically knock you out of UI consideration in Arizona.

0 coins

The adjudication aspect of this is something people sleep on. When you report income like a pension during your initial filing, Arizona DES can flag your claim for adjudication to verify how that income affects your benefit amount. If your claim is in adjudication, your payments might be on hold while they sort it out. Did your claim show any adjudication status or is it just showing a calculated weekly benefit with no flags?

0 coins

It's showing calculated weekly benefit amount with no adjudication flag that I can see. I reported the pension but the system didn't seem to put anything on hold.

0 coins

That's probably fine then. If it had flagged for adjudication you'd likely see something in your CACTUS portal indicating the claim needed further review. The fact that it processed through normally might mean DES already factored in the pension, or it might mean they haven't gotten to it yet. Calling to confirm is still the right move.

0 coins

This is true - adjudication for income-related things can pop up after a few weeks even if the initial claim went through fine. I had a claim that processed normally and then went into adjudication two weeks later when DES cross-referenced some income info.

0 coins

Coming in late but just want to say I had a pension offset question that dragged on for weeks because I kept failing to reach Arizona DES by phone. Ended up using Claimyr after my sister mentioned it and I finally got to talk to someone at DES directly. Turned out my situation was actually fine and the pension wasn't going to reduce my benefits because of how old the employer relationship was. Would've known that weeks earlier if I hadn't spent so long stuck in the phone queue.

0 coins

The timeline of how old the employer relationship is seems to keep coming up as the key factor. Good to hear it worked out for you.

0 coins

Yeah the age of the pension relative to your base period seems to be what DES cares about most. The agent explained it really clearly once I got her on the line.

0 coins

okay this whole thread has actually been really educational. i never knew any of this about how pensions interact with UI

0 coins

Something practical - when you do get through to Arizona DES, ask them specifically to document in your account that they've reviewed the pension and the determination of how it affects your benefits. You want that on record. I had an agent give me verbal confirmation that my pension wasn't going to affect my UI and then three months later a different process flagged it and started an overpayment review. Had to reference back to notes I'd taken during my call. If it's in your CACTUS account portal notes, that's much harder for them to dispute later. Also claimyr.com helped me get through to DES to have that conversation in the first place - that's actually how I got the agent who documented everything.

0 coins

Writing down everything from the call is something I definitely should do. What do you ask them to put in the account exactly?

0 coins

Ask them to note that you disclosed the pension, the name of the employer it's from, the monthly amount, and their determination of whether it affects your weekly UI benefit and by how much. The more specific the better.

0 coins

This is really smart advice. The overpayment situation I ran into earlier might have been avoidable if I'd had something documented showing I reported the pension upfront and DES acknowledged it. Lesson learned the hard way.

0 coins

screenshotting everything in your CACTUS account is also a good habit regardless - portal interfaces change and things can disappear

0 coins

I work adjacent to HR and benefits administration so I see this question come up fairly often. The short version of the pension-and-UI rules in Arizona, in plain terms: if your pension comes from an employer who's in the recent window DES uses to calculate your benefit, they're going to look at how the pension was funded and probably reduce your UI by some amount. If the pension is from an employer you worked for a long time ago and they're not in that calculation window, you're much more likely to come out unaffected. The fact that your pension is from a job you left in 2018 is actually working in your favor here.

0 coins

That framing makes the whole thing a lot clearer. 2018 employer, 2025 layoff - there's a big gap there. I'm feeling more optimistic that this might be a non-issue but I'll still confirm with DES.

0 coins

Confirming directly is always the right call. The gap between employers is in your favor but DES has their own calculation methods and you want their actual determination, not just an educated guess from a forum.

0 coins

I appreciate that HR perspective - most of us filing UI claims have no idea how any of this connects to pension rules until we're already in the middle of it

0 coins

Has anyone had the experience where they got two different answers from two different Arizona DES agents about the pension offset question? I called twice because I wasn't sure about the first answer I got and they contradicted each other completely. One said my pension would reduce my UI dollar for dollar, the other said it wouldn't affect it at all. I didn't know which one to believe.

0 coins

Getting conflicting information from different DES agents is unfortunately pretty common. When that happens the best path is to request that they escalate to a supervisor or specifically note in your account which determination they're making. The inconsistency is real and frustrating but a documented supervisor-level determination carries more weight.

0 coins

I ended up just going with the more conservative answer and treating my benefit as if it would be reduced, then it turned out it wasn't. Stressful way to handle it but at least I wasn't overpaid.

0 coins

The 'assume the less favorable scenario' approach is actually pretty sensible when you're getting conflicting answers. Much easier to have more money in your account than you expected than to owe it back.

0 coins

One thing I'll add from my own experience - when you file your weekly claims, there's a question about income received during that week. Your pension payment needs to be reported in the week you receive it, not just disclosed during the initial filing. Some people don't realize the weekly claim questionnaire also captures ongoing income and they only report it once at the start. Arizona DES compares what you report weekly against other income records so this matters for staying compliant.

0 coins

Wait, do I have to report my pension every single week on the weekly claim? I reported it once during the initial filing but I didn't know I had to keep reporting it every week.

0 coins

You need to report income received in that specific week. If your pension payment hits your account during a claim week, yes, that needs to be disclosed on that week's claim. It's the same as if you worked a few hours - any money coming in during that week gets reported.

0 coins

This is really important information actually. I think a lot of overpayment situations happen because people report something once at the start and don't realize DES wants it accounted for on every weekly claim too.

0 coins

The weekly claim form asks 'did you receive any income this week' and pension payments count. Report it every week it comes in. Better to report and have it calculated correctly than to miss it and get flagged later.

0 coins

I realize this might be a dumb question but how does Arizona DES even find out about your pension if you don't tell them? Like is there some system where they cross-check with pension administrators?

0 coins

Not a dumb question at all. DES does cross-reference income records through various data-sharing agreements. Employer-funded pensions especially from large organizations, government agencies, and union pension funds often show up in state income records. They also do random audits. The 'just don't mention it and hope for the best' approach carries real risk of an overpayment determination plus potential fraud findings.

0 coins

yeah no I wasn't suggesting that lol, I just wondered how sophisticated their tracking is. sounds like they have some real systems behind it.

0 coins

They've gotten significantly better at income cross-matching in recent years. The safest assumption is they will eventually find out about any income source, so proactive reporting is always the better choice.

0 coins

going back to the original question - my uncle collected a small pension AND his full UI benefit at the same time in Arizona and nobody ever said anything to him. he thinks it was because the pension was from out of state from a job he had in another state decades ago. does anyone know if out of state pension sources are treated differently

0 coins

The state where the pension originated from is less relevant than which employer funded it and whether that employer falls into your base period calculation. An out-of-state employer that's also out of your base period window is effectively in the same position as an old in-state employer - probably not triggering the offset. But if someone happens to have an out-of-state employer in their recent base period, the pension from that employer could still be a factor.

0 coins

that makes sense actually. the state of the pension doesn't matter as much as how recent the employer was. thanks for clarifying

0 coins

Something practical for OP as you go through this - print out or screenshot your initial claim submission showing you disclosed the pension. Keep any letters or portal messages from DES about your claim. And when you do your weekly claims, keep your own records showing what you reported each week including the pension income. If an overpayment question ever comes up, having your own documentation showing consistent reporting is what helps you in an appeal.

0 coins

Keeping my own records is something I should have already been doing from day one. Starting now. I've also finally gotten some useful context from this thread to know what questions to actually ask when I reach a DES agent.

0 coins

The specific questions to ask: 1. Is my pension employer in my base period? 2. What was the determination on how my pension affects my weekly benefit? 3. Can you note in my account that I disclosed this pension and what the determination is? Those three questions should get you everything you need.

0 coins

This is the most useful practical comment in this whole thread honestly. Knowing exactly what to ask instead of just saying 'uh so about my pension...' is the difference between a productive call and a wasted one.

0 coins

Just want to loop back and confirm for anyone else finding this thread - I did eventually get through to Arizona DES and sorted out my pension situation. The agent confirmed my pension employer from several years back was not in my base period, so there was no offset on my weekly benefit. I collected regular UI for the full period I was eligible while still receiving my pension payments. The key really was getting clarification directly from an agent rather than trying to guess from general information online.

0 coins

This is a good update to see. That's essentially the scenario I'm hoping applies to me - old enough employer, not in the base period, no offset. Still going to confirm directly but this gives me more confidence the system isn't going to automatically count it against me.

0 coins

You're in a similar enough situation that I'd expect a similar result, but definitely get the official word. The confirmation from an agent took about 10 minutes once I actually had someone on the line. It was all the time getting to that point that was the challenge.

0 coins

This is a helpful resolution to see. These kinds of threads are genuinely useful when they have both the information AND confirmation from someone who went through it.

0 coins

Arizona Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure