Back to Arizona Unemployment

Isabella Brown

Arizona DES pandemic unemployment portal - anyone else getting errors trying to access old claim info?

So I'm in a weird situation and not sure if anyone else has dealt with this. Back when the pandemic hit I had filed through what I think was a separate portal from the regular Arizona DES system - it had a different login and everything. Fast forward to now, 2025, and I got a letter saying there's an overpayment determination tied to that old claim. The letter references a claim number I barely recognize and tells me to log into a portal that either doesn't exist anymore or has been merged into the main uibenefits.az.gov site. Every time I try to find my old claim data it just throws an error or redirects me to file a brand new claim. I need to see the payment history and weekly certifications I submitted back then because the overpayment amount they're claiming - around $4,200 - doesn't match what I remember receiving at all. My current CACTUS portal account doesn't show anything from that period, just my more recent 2023 claim. I've tried submitting a message through the portal contact form three times over the past two weeks with zero response. Called the DES number and sat on hold until it disconnected me twice. I genuinely don't know how to access documentation I need to dispute this overpayment and the appeal window is only 30 days from the date on the letter. Has anyone successfully pulled old claim records or gotten DES to actually help with something like this?

Week two of my own overpayment fight here so this hits close to home. The old pandemic-era portal data was supposedly migrated into the main system but honestly it was a mess. What I found is you have to call DES directly and specifically ask them to pull up claim records from the legacy system - the CACTUS portal interface just doesn't surface that old data for most people. The agent I finally reached was able to see my full payment history going back to 2020 on their end even though I couldn't see it myself online.

0 coins

That's actually really helpful to know the data exists on their end. My whole problem is getting someone on the phone - I've been disconnected twice after long holds. Did you have any tricks for actually reaching a live agent?

0 coins

Same issue on my end. The portal just doesn't show pre-2022 claim data at all from what I can tell. It's like the migration only brought forward partial records.

0 coins

The letter I got last month mentioned a 'records request' process you can initiate in writing if you can't access the old portal. Might be worth trying that in parallel while you work the phone angle, especially if the appeal clock is running.

0 coins

My adjudication notice from last spring sent me down this exact rabbit hole. I spent probably six hours total on hold over three days trying to reach someone at DES to get old records. The phone situation there is genuinely brutal - high call volume every single time, doesn't matter what hour you try.

0 coins

Six hours is wild. And you still got through eventually? I'm starting to wonder if I'm just going to run out the clock on my appeal window trying to reach someone.

0 coins

The hold times seem worst on Mondays and right after holidays in my experience. Tuesday or Wednesday mid-morning has worked better for me personally but it's still not great.

0 coins

Fourteen days into waiting on a response from DES myself when I found out about Claimyr - basically it queues up the hold for you so you end up actually on the phone with a live DES agent instead of burning hours yourself. Tried it when I needed to sort out a records issue similar to yours and it worked, got to talk to someone that same day. Site is claimyr.com and there's a demo video at https://youtu.be/vwA1GGuV83Y if you want to see how it goes before trying it.

0 coins

Okay this is the first thing that sounds like it might actually solve my problem before my appeal deadline. Going to look at that video tonight.

0 coins

Been seeing Claimyr mentioned a few times lately. Good to know it actually works for the DES phone situation specifically.

0 coins

The DES phone system is such a nightmare that honestly any solution is worth trying at this point. Glad something exists for this.

0 coins

Right after I got my overpayment notice I went straight to the DES appeals page and found something important - you can request a records review as part of your appeal filing itself. You don't necessarily need to have all your documentation in hand before you file. File the appeal first to protect your 30-day window, then gather the records. The appeal form has a section where you can note that you're requesting claim history documentation as part of the dispute.

0 coins

Wait, I didn't realize I could file the appeal without having everything together first. That actually takes a lot of pressure off. So I should file now and then continue hunting down the actual payment records?

0 coins

This is the right move. I had to do exactly this last year. Filed the appeal to stop the clock, then spent the next few weeks pulling together the documentation. The hearing examiner actually gave me extra time to submit supporting records once the appeal was open.

0 coins

The letter itself should have a fax number or mailing address for appeal submissions. Don't rely on the portal for this if you're running tight on time - mail or fax creates a paper trail with a date stamp.

0 coins

The overpayment notice I dealt with was for a different reason but the records problem is familiar. What ended up working for me was going in person to an ARIZONA@WORK office - they have DES staff who can sometimes pull up claim records right there and they were able to print out my old weekly certification history. Not every location can do this but it's worth calling ahead and asking.

0 coins

I hadn't even thought about going in person. There's an ARIZONA@WORK location maybe 20 minutes from me. Might be faster than waiting for the phone situation to work out.

0 coins

The in-person option is underrated. I had a document issue resolved in one visit that had been going nowhere for weeks through the phone and portal.

0 coins

This depends heavily on your location though. Some offices are much better staffed and equipped than others.

0 coins

Just make sure you bring the actual letter with the claim number and your ID. Had a family member go in without the letter and they couldn't look anything up.

0 coins

Something that tripped me up during my claim dispute - the overpayment letter amount includes interest that accrues from the determination date, so the $4,200 figure could be higher by the time you actually pay if the dispute drags. Not trying to panic you but just something to know going in. If you have solid documentation that the amount is wrong, getting the appeal filed quickly really does matter.

0 coins

Okay that's genuinely alarming to hear about interest. Filing that appeal is now my number one priority today.

0 coins

Had the same thing happen where I didn't realize the amount was climbing. Used Claimyr to get through to DES and the agent was able to explain exactly what the breakdown was - turns out part of what I thought was the overpayment was actually the interest calculation added on top.

0 coins

The interest situation is brutal. It's one of the worst parts of how they handle these because the delays are almost never your fault but you're the one absorbing the extra charges.

0 coins

My appeal hearing got scheduled for about six weeks after I filed, which gave me time to collect everything. One thing I'll add is that your weekly certification records should be accessible through a formal records request even if the portal won't show them - there's a specific DES form for requesting your own claim file. I think it's referenced somewhere on the DES main website under appeals or hearings. Having that official record was what actually won my case because it showed exactly what I'd certified and what had been paid.

0 coins

The idea of having an official claim file document that shows my certifications is exactly what I need. I'll look for that form on the DES site today.

0 coins

The formal records request process is slower than getting someone on the phone but it creates an official document you can submit as evidence, which is probably more useful for a hearing anyway.

0 coins

Worth noting you should request this in writing and keep a copy. If you email the request, screenshot the sent email. If you mail it, send it certified.

0 coins

Step three of my own appeal process when I ran into the same portal dead end for old pandemic claim data. Ended up using Claimyr to reach DES - spoke with an agent who actually walked me through what the legacy system showed on my account while I was on the phone with her. She confirmed the payment amounts that had been issued and that matched what I had in my own records, which made the discrepancy in the overpayment letter obvious. Definitely worth reaching DES by phone if you're trying to compare their records to yours.

0 coins

Having an agent read off what the system shows while you're on the call sounds ideal - I can compare it in real time against whatever I have saved from back then. Really need to actually reach someone before my deadline.

0 coins

The old legacy data being visible to agents even when it doesn't show in the portal is good to know. That's really the core issue a lot of people have with these older claim disputes.

0 coins

This confirms what someone else said earlier that the data exists, it's just the portal not surfacing it. So getting to an agent is the actual key step here.

0 coins

The confusing thing with the pandemic portal vs the regular portal is that some people had two completely separate claim numbers - one for regular UI and one filed through the other system. If you have two separate numbers, the overpayment might be referencing whichever one you're not looking at. Worth double checking if you have any old confirmation emails from your original filing.

0 coins

Oh that's something I hadn't considered. I'm going to dig through my old emails tonight because I honestly might have multiple claim numbers from that period and might be looking at the wrong one entirely.

0 coins

This happened to my cousin - completely separate claim numbers and she was applying the payment history from one to the dispute on the other. Took forever to untangle.

0 coins

Old confirmation emails are gold in these situations. If you filed online you should have gotten at least a submission confirmation - that email should have your claim number right in it.

0 coins

Just want to say the 30 day appeal window is strict - I missed mine by four days on a previous determination and they would not make an exception, I had to go through a whole separate process to try to get it reopened. Please prioritize getting that appeal filed even if you don't have everything together yet.

0 coins

This is the clearest warning I've gotten and I'm taking it seriously. Appeal is getting filed today.

0 coins

The late appeal process exists but it requires showing good cause for why you missed the deadline and they don't just hand those out. Much easier to file on time even with an incomplete record.

0 coins

Can confirm missed deadlines are a nightmare to fix. File first, build your case after.

0 coins

Eighth week of dealing with a DES determination issue over here. One thing nobody mentioned yet - if you can't get the portal to show your old claim, try logging out and logging back in then going directly to the correspondence section rather than the main dashboard. Some of the older letters and notices are stored there separately and might give you at least some record of what was paid.

0 coins

The correspondence section - I've been going to the main dashboard every time. Going to try navigating directly there and see if anything from the older period shows up.

0 coins

Good catch. The correspondence section definitely stores things the main dashboard view doesn't display. I found old decision notices there that weren't visible anywhere else.

0 coins

The number on the letter finally got me somewhere after I stopped trying the main DES number. If the letter cites a specific unit or department handling the overpayment determination, sometimes there's a direct line listed in the fine print. I'd read through the letter really carefully - mine had a small section at the bottom that referenced the overpayment unit with a different contact path than the main DES line. Used Claimyr to get through on that specific number and finally had a productive conversation about my case.

0 coins

Reading the bottom of the letter more carefully is something I should have done from day one. I've been fixated on the main number.

0 coins

The specific unit contact info buried in the fine print is real - I found the same thing. The overpayment or collections unit is separate from general claims and sometimes easier to reach.

0 coins

This is a solid tip. The main DES line routes you everywhere and nowhere. A specific unit number, if it's on the letter, is much more direct.

0 coins

Had an overpayment determination reversed last year and the thing that made the difference at my hearing was a printed screenshot of my bank account deposits from that period. Even if you can't pull the DES records directly, your bank statements would show exactly what amounts hit your account and when. That's independently verifiable and the hearing examiner treated it as solid evidence.

0 coins

Bank statements - yes. I actually have those and I know what deposits hit during that period. That could be the foundation of my case even if I can't get DES to produce their own records before the hearing.

0 coins

Bank statements combined with any emails you got from DES at the time of payments would be really strong. Payment notification emails often have the specific benefit amount in them.

0 coins

This is underrated evidence. Easy to get, can't really be disputed, and shows exactly what you actually received vs what they claim.

0 coins

Not to pile on but just want to flag - the job search requirements don't apply retroactively to old claims so if DES is trying to cite job search issues as the basis for the overpayment from that period, that's worth pushing back on specifically. The rules were different during that time and they can't apply current standards backward.

0 coins

My overpayment letter doesn't cite job search as the reason - it's more of an earnings or availability issue they flagged. But good to know that point for the hearing in case it comes up.

0 coins

The retroactive application of current standards is something that actually does come up and you're right to flag it. The rules in effect at the time of the claim are what apply.

0 coins

Three weeks ago I got a similar letter and the first thing I did was call a legal aid organization that handles unemployment cases. They were able to look at my letter and tell me right away whether the determination seemed solid or had weaknesses. Some of them do free consultations specifically for UI overpayment appeals and they know the DES processes well.

0 coins

I didn't even know legal aid handled unemployment cases. That's another avenue I should explore given the amount they're claiming.

0 coins

Community Legal Services in Arizona specifically has people who handle DES overpayment cases. Worth looking them up if you're in their service area.

0 coins

Legal aid is a genuinely good call for anything over a few thousand dollars because the appeals process has specific procedural rules and knowing them going in matters a lot.

0 coins

About five days before my own appeal hearing I realized I had no idea what format the actual hearing would take. It's a phone hearing with a hearing examiner - not in person, not intimidating like a courtroom. You can have someone with you, you can have notes in front of you, you can reference documents while you're on the call. Knowing that ahead of time made me way less anxious about the whole thing.

0 coins

Oh this is actually really reassuring. I had visions of having to show up somewhere formal. A phone hearing with notes in front of me feels much more manageable.

0 coins

The hearing examiner is usually pretty straightforward about giving you a chance to explain your side. It's not aggressive cross-examination or anything like that.

0 coins

You can also request a postponement of the hearing date once if you need more time to gather records, as long as you've already filed the appeal and your request is in before the scheduled hearing.

0 coins

Knowing it's a phone hearing is huge. I prepared way more than I needed to for mine because I expected something more formal.

0 coins

Random thing that helped me - going through my old text messages from that period. I had texts where I'd mentioned to family members what I'd received in a given week, which lined up perfectly with my bank deposits. It sounds informal but anything that corroborates your records is useful.

0 coins

Text messages are a creative source I wouldn't have thought of. I know I sent messages to my partner about payments coming in. Screenshots of those might actually be useful supplemental documentation.

0 coins

Any contemporaneous record from that time period helps establish what the actual situation was. Text messages, emails to family, notes - all fair game to bring up.

0 coins

The whole pandemic portal situation was a mess that Arizona DES still hasn't fully cleaned up in terms of accessible records. I went through an overpayment dispute last year and the agent I finally reached actually apologized about the records access issue and acknowledged it was a known problem with how the old portal data migrated. That doesn't help you practically but at least you know you're not doing something wrong - the system just genuinely doesn't surface that data properly.

0 coins

Honestly just knowing it's a known system problem and not something I'm missing on my end is a small relief. Still need to get it resolved but at least I'm not crazy.

0 coins

The apology from an agent doesn't fix anything but it does confirm it's worth pushing hard on because it's a system failure, not a claimant error.

0 coins

The good news is hearing examiners seem to understand the records access issues from that period and are more sympathetic to documentation gaps when the gap is clearly on DES's end.

0 coins

Coming back to update everyone since this thread was so helpful. Filed my appeal this morning - didn't have all my records but followed the advice here and filed to protect the deadline. Included a note that I'm requesting my claim file as part of the appeal. Also dug through my old emails and found two separate confirmation emails from that period with different claim reference numbers - turns out I might have been looking at the wrong claim entirely this whole time, which could explain the discrepancy. Reaching out to DES now to verify which claim the overpayment relates to before my hearing. Really grateful for all the specific advice here, especially the bank statements idea and filing the appeal first regardless.

0 coins

The two claim numbers thing is exactly what I suspected when you first described it. Good catch on digging through the emails.

0 coins

Filing to protect the deadline first is always the right call. Everything else can be built out from there.

0 coins

Glad this worked out. Keep all those old confirmation emails somewhere safe - they're going to be useful throughout the appeal process.

0 coins

Updates like this are why these threads are worth having. Good luck with the hearing, sounds like you have a solid case to make.

0 coins

Arizona Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure