Back to Arizona Unemployment

Felicity Bud

Are dental premiums exempt from unemployment in Arizona DES calculations?

So I got laid off from my job at a dental office about six weeks ago and I'm trying to wrap my head around how Arizona DES calculated my weekly benefit amount. When I look at my pay stubs from the base period, my employer was deducting dental insurance premiums from each check - around $47 per pay period. I'm now wondering whether those deductions affect how DES figures out my wages for unemployment purposes. Like, does DES look at my gross wages before the dental premium comes out, or do they look at what I actually took home after those deductions? I've searched everywhere online and can't find a straight answer. My benefit amount seems lower than what I expected based on my salary, and I'm trying to figure out if the dental premium deductions are part of why. Has anyone dealt with this when filing their Arizona unemployment claim?

Claimyr got me talking to an actual Arizona DES agent within the same morning I tried it - you just go to claimyr.com and they handle all the hold time for you. There's even a demo video at https://youtu.be/vwA1GGuV83Y so you can see what it's about before signing up. I'd honestly try it because getting a live agent to walk through your wage calculations with you is the fastest way to sort out whether those dental premium deductions changed your benefit amount.

0 coins

Wait, is this something you have to pay for? Not sure I want to spend money when I'm already not getting full benefits.

0 coins

Worth it for the time you save, honestly - I was spending entire mornings on hold with Arizona DES before. Ended up talking to an agent who actually pulled up my wage records right there on the call.

0 coins

Interesting. I might look into this, I've been trying to get through to DES for two weeks now about a totally separate issue with my job search log requirements.

0 coins

Hmm, does anyone actually know the rule on this? I went through something similar last year with health insurance premiums and I never got a clear answer either.

0 coins

Not sure it works quite the same way as you might think - my situation involved medical premiums and what I found was that DES uses gross wages before most pre-tax deductions are stripped out, but the specific treatment can vary depending on how the premium is set up.

0 coins

That's what I keep running into - vague answers. My gross salary was around $52,000 annually but my benefits seem based on something lower than that, which is why I started looking at what might be getting subtracted.

0 coins

i had the exact same confusion when i first filed lol took me forever to even understand what base period meant let alone the premium stuff

0 coins

Okay so here's what I actually learned going through my own claim - my employer took out dental AND vision premiums pre-tax and when DES calculated my wages they used the W-2 box 1 amount which already had those deductions removed. So in my case the premiums were effectively reducing the wage figure DES saw. Whether that's technically "exempt" I don't know but the practical effect was my benefit base was lower.

0 coins

Hmm, though I want to double-check one thing - did your W-2 box 1 specifically show less because of the dental premium, or was that bundled with other deductions like 401k?

0 coins

Honestly it was bundled together - dental, medical, vision, and my 403b contributions all reduced box 1. I couldn't tell you which one accounted for how much.

0 coins

This is actually the key distinction though. Arizona DES uses your reportable wages which is basically what shows up as taxable wage income. Pre-tax premiums under a Section 125 cafeteria plan absolutely reduce that figure.

0 coins

wait so if someone has really expensive dental premiums taken pre-tax their unemployment could be noticeably lower? that seems kind of unfair

0 coins

Section 125 plans are where this gets interesting - went through an audit of my own claim last spring and this came up. The way my HR rep explained it after the fact is that when premiums are deducted under a qualifying cafeteria plan, they never really counted as taxable wages in the first place, so DES never sees them as wages at all. It's not that DES exempts them - it's that they were never in the wage calculation to begin with.

0 coins

Okay this actually makes a lot of sense to me now - so it's not like DES is taking my full salary and then subtracting the premiums, they just never saw the full salary figure to begin with?

0 coins

Exactly. Your employer reports wages to DES quarterly and those reports are based on taxable wages. Pre-tax benefit deductions come out before that reporting happens.

0 coins

Though I'd be a little careful assuming every employer handles this the same way - I've seen small employers mess up their wage reporting and it caused problems for the employee's unemployment calculation later.

0 coins

My sister ran into this and honestly couldn't get a straight answer through the CACTUS portal or any of the online resources. She ended up using Claimyr to get through to a live agent at Arizona DES who actually looked up her wage records while they were on the phone. That cleared up the whole dental premium question for her in like 20 minutes.

0 coins

Twenty minutes sounds way better than the three days I've spent trying to figure this out myself. Did she have to have specific documents ready when she talked to the agent?

0 coins

She had her pay stubs and her W-2 handy just in case, but the agent could see the wage information DES already had on file from her employer so she mostly just needed to ask the right questions.

0 coins

This is good to know - I've been scared to call DES because I've heard horror stories about being on hold for hours and then getting disconnected.

0 coins

Can I ask something that might be a dumb question - does it matter whether the dental plan is through the employer or whether the employee is paying the full premium themselves? Like I'm thinking about someone who might have dental through a spouse's plan or something.

0 coins

Not a dumb question at all - the key is whether the premium goes through your employer's payroll deduction under a qualifying plan. If you're paying dental premiums outside of payroll like on your own, those aren't reflected in wages at all either way, so DES wage calculations wouldn't involve them.

0 coins

Oh that actually makes sense. So basically DES is working off whatever wage number your employer submitted and that number already reflects however the employer set up deductions.

0 coins

Pretty much. And that's also why it's so important that your employer reported your wages correctly to DES in the first place, because you're kind of relying on them to have done that accurately.

0 coins

FWIW I literally just went through this exact confusion with my dental premium situation two months ago. Filed my claim, expected a certain weekly amount based on what I thought my salary was, got something lower, panicked, and spent like a week thinking something was wrong. Turned out my employer's Section 125 deductions had already reduced what DES received as my wage data. Nothing was wrong, that's just how it works.

0 coins

Did it end up being a significant difference in your weekly benefit amount, or more like a few dollars?

0 coins

In my case the dental was only like $38 a paycheck so the effect on weekly benefits was pretty minor - maybe $8-10 less per week than I expected. But I know some people with more comprehensive plans paying way more than that.

0 coins

Eight to ten dollars a week adds up though!! Over a few months of unemployment that's real money

0 coins

Something nobody has mentioned yet - what about dental premiums that are NOT pre-tax? I had a weird situation where my employer offered dental but it wasn't part of a formal cafeteria plan so it came out of my check as an after-tax deduction. Would that change anything?

0 coins

Yes that changes things completely. After-tax premium deductions don't reduce your taxable wages, so they wouldn't affect your DES wage base at all. Your employer would have still reported your full gross wages minus only pre-tax items.

0 coins

So I would have actually been getting unemployment calculated on a higher wage number than someone in the same salary bracket who had pre-tax dental? That's kind of backwards.

0 coins

Yep, the tax treatment of your benefits can actually work against you here. Pre-tax benefits save you income tax while employed but create a lower unemployment wage base if you lose your job.

0 coins

Jumping in here because I work in HR and handle exactly this stuff - the quarterly wage reports employers send to Arizona DES are indeed based on taxable wages. Pre-tax dental, medical, FSA contributions, dependent care accounts - all of those reduce the reported wage figure. Post-tax deductions like after-tax dental or Roth 401k contributions do not reduce it. So whether dental premiums are "exempt" depends entirely on how your plan is set up.

0 coins

This is probably the clearest explanation I've gotten so far - so my first step should be figuring out whether my employer's dental plan is pre-tax or post-tax?

0 coins

Exactly. Check your pay stub - there should be a section showing pre-tax deductions versus post-tax deductions. If dental shows up in the pre-tax section, it reduced your DES wage base. Most employer-sponsored dental plans are pre-tax but not all.

0 coins

i never even looked at which section of my pay stub things were in, just saw the total taken out. need to actually read mine now

0 coins

Does it say specifically on the stub or do you have to ask HR? Mine just says "dental" with an amount

0 coins

Okay I'm confused about something - I thought DES calculated benefits based on your highest earning quarter, not your whole base period wages. So wouldn't the dental premium thing only matter for that one quarter?

0 coins

Close but not quite - Arizona DES actually looks at your two highest earning quarters in the base period and uses that to calculate your weekly benefit amount. The dental premium deductions would affect all quarters equally if the premium was consistent, so it's not just one quarter that matters.

0 coins

Oh I had that wrong then. So if my dental deduction was the same every paycheck throughout the year, it's consistently reducing all my reported wages across the board.

0 coins

Right. And DES uses the wage data from employers, so whatever your employer reported each quarter is what DES bases your benefit on.

0 coins

I want to say something that might be controversial here but I think some people stress too much about this dental premium question. The difference in your weekly benefit amount is usually pretty small compared to what people expect. Unless you're paying like $200+ a month in dental premiums, we're probably talking about a $15-20 difference in your weekly benefit at most. Might not be worth spending hours trying to dispute it.

0 coins

Ehh, I'd push back on this a little bit - even if it's $15 a week that's $60 a month, and when you're on unemployment $60 matters a lot more than it did when you had a paycheck.

0 coins

Fair point, I didn't think about it that way. I guess I was coming from a place of having been through unemployment and finding that fighting over small amounts wasn't worth the energy for me personally.

0 coins

Honestly for me it's less about the money and more about understanding whether my benefit amount is correct at all. I want to make sure the whole calculation is right, not just the dental part.

0 coins

I tried Claimyr a few weeks ago when I had a different DES question - ended up speaking with an actual Arizona DES agent that same afternoon which genuinely surprised me. If you go to claimyr.com there's information there about how it works. I'd use it again for something like a wage calculation question because the agent was able to look at my actual account while we talked.

0 coins

How long did it actually take from when you signed up to when you were on the phone with someone?

0 coins

For me it was the same day but I don't know if that's always the case. The demo at https://youtu.be/vwA1GGuV83Y gives you a better sense of the process.

0 coins

This would have been so useful last month when I was trying to figure out my adjudication status and couldn't get anyone on the phone for like two weeks

0 coins

Can someone clarify - when we're talking about "base period" wages does DES use the most recent 12 months or is it a weird calendar thing? I never totally understood this part and it matters for how the dental premium deduction affects things over time

0 coins

It's actually not the most recent 12 months - typically your base period ends a couple of quarters before you file. So if you file a claim in 2025, your base period is usually the first four of the last five completed calendar quarters. Some people are surprised that very recent wages might not be counted.

0 coins

That's so confusing. So wages I earned a few months ago before filing might not even be in my base period?

0 coins

Yep and that trips a lot of people up. There's also an alternate base period you can request if the standard base period doesn't work in your favor.

0 coins

Does anyone know if you can actually get documentation from DES showing the exact wage figures they received from your employer? I feel like that's what OP actually needs - not just a general explanation of how it works but the specific numbers DES is using for their claim.

0 coins

Yes - you can request your wage records through the CACTUS portal or by contacting DES directly. Your Monetary Determination letter should also show the wage figures by quarter that were used to calculate your benefit amount.

0 coins

Oh I didn't realize that was in the Monetary Determination letter. I got one of those and kind of just looked at the final weekly amount without reading all the detail.

0 coins

I actually do have my Monetary Determination somewhere - going to dig it out tonight and check what wage figures they used by quarter. That should tell me whether the dental premiums are affecting things.

0 coins

This thread is so helpful, I've been wondering the same thing. Quick question from me - what if someone doesn't even know what their employer reported to DES? Like is there any way to see that without having to contact DES directly?

0 coins

Your W-2 form is the starting point - box 1 shows your federal taxable wages which is basically what DES would work from. If you compare box 1 to your actual gross salary and the difference is way more than just your dental premium, there might be other deductions reducing your wage base too.

0 coins

Oh comparing W-2 box 1 to gross salary is actually a really smart way to figure out what was deducted pre-tax in total. Never thought to do that.

0 coins

doing this right now for my own situation lol

0 coins

Interesting timing on this thread - I just talked to Arizona DES last week about my own wage calculation question using Claimyr and the agent explained exactly this whole pre-tax versus post-tax situation. Really cleared things up. No idea I could have my entire wage history explained to me in like one phone call.

0 coins

Did the agent seem knowledgeable about this specific stuff or did you feel like you knew more than they did? I've had experiences calling DES where the person couldn't answer detailed questions.

0 coins

This particular agent was actually really solid on wage calculation questions. I think it depends who you get, honestly.

0 coins

That's always the gamble with any government agency phone line - some agents really know their stuff and some are just reading from a script

0 coins

Going back to something earlier in this thread - even if the dental premium situation is working as designed and not an error, can you still appeal your benefit amount if you think it's too low for some other reason?

0 coins

You can appeal your Monetary Determination within 15 days of the date on the letter. The appeal process lets you contest the wage figures DES used. If the issue is just that your employer correctly reported pre-tax wages and those were lower due to dental premiums, that's not really an appealable error though - that's the system working correctly.

0 coins

So an appeal would only help if DES actually made a calculation mistake or if the employer reported wrong wages, not just if the person wishes their wages had been higher?

0 coins

That's right. The appeal is for errors in the determination, not for reconsidering how the tax code treats different deductions.

0 coins

One more thing worth mentioning - if you think your employer might have reported your wages incorrectly to DES, that's worth looking into separately from the dental premium question. Employer wage reporting errors do happen and they can significantly affect your benefit amount. DES has a process for investigating that.

0 coins

How would I even know if that happened though? Is there a way to request what my employer actually reported versus what I think they should have reported?

0 coins

DES can tell you what wage amounts they received from your employer by quarter. Then you'd compare that to your actual pay stubs or W-2. If there's a major discrepancy beyond what pre-tax deductions would explain, that could indicate a reporting error.

0 coins

This happened to a coworker of mine - employer submitted wrong wages and it took a couple months to fix but DES did eventually correct it and adjusted his benefit amount retroactively.

0 coins

Just want to say reading this whole thread I finally understand something that confused me for weeks. I thought DES was taking my full salary and then choosing to exclude the dental premium from their calculation. But actually the wage number DES gets from my employer is already the reduced number. Completely different framing and it makes so much more sense now.

0 coins

That's exactly the right way to understand it. DES isn't making a choice about your dental premium - they're just receiving the taxable wage data that your employer is required to report.

0 coins

Makes me wish someone had explained it this simply from the beginning instead of all the vague answers on the DES website.

0 coins

Update for anyone following: I dug out my Monetary Determination letter and compared the quarterly wage figures to my pay stubs. The numbers DES has are consistent with my W-2 box 1 amount, which is about $2,100 less than my actual gross salary for the year. My dental premium over that same period would account for roughly $1,100 of that difference, with my 401k contribution making up most of the rest. So it seems like everything is working as described in this thread - my benefit amount is lower than I expected because the wage DES sees was already reduced by those pre-tax deductions. Not happy about it but at least I understand it now. Thanks everyone.

0 coins

Glad you sorted it out. For what it's worth, the pre-tax deductions do save you money on income taxes while you're employed - it's just that the trade-off affects your unemployment wage base if you end up filing a claim.

0 coins

Same thing I found out with my own claim. Annoying but at least it's not an error that needs to be fixed.

0 coins

Good resolution! Wish my own wage question had been this clear-cut to figure out.

0 coins

Arizona Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure