Student loan vs. Parent PLUS loan interest rates - which makes more financial sense?
I've been playing around with different loan options for the 2025-2026 year, and I'm honestly confused about what makes the most financial sense. My daughter was offered both direct student loans and I'm eligible for Parent PLUS loans. I've heard that student loans have better interest rates (like 2% lower?), but the Parent PLUS would give us a higher borrowing limit. I'm worried about the Parent PLUS affecting my credit score since I'm planning to refinance my house next year. If she takes out the loan in her name but I help her pay it off anyway, does that make more sense financially? Has anyone compared both options and can share their experience? Are there any hidden drawbacks to either approach that I should know about?
17 comments
Join the conversation
Mason Davis
You're absolutely right about the interest rate difference! For the 2025-2026 academic year, federal Direct Subsidized and Unsubsidized loans for undergraduate students have a 5.28% interest rate, while Parent PLUS loans are currently at 7.38%. That's a significant difference over the life of the loan. If you're able to help your daughter pay her student loans, that's often the better financial choice. Also important to note: Direct Student loans don't require credit checks, while Parent PLUS loans do. Since you're planning to refinance soon, that's definitely something to consider. Student loans also have more flexible repayment options after graduation, including income-driven plans if your daughter faces any employment challenges.
0 coins
Sophia Miller
•Thank you for confirming those rates! The 2.1% difference would add up substantially over time. Do you know if me making payments on her student loan would have any tax implications I should worry about? And would those payments be considered gifts for tax purposes?
0 coins
Mia Rodriguez
we went thru this last yr. took BOTH lol. kid maxed out student loans ($7500 for freshmen i think?) and we did parent plus for rest. thats what most ppl do tbh
0 coins
Sophia Miller
•That's interesting - I hadn't considered doing both. How much did the Parent PLUS impact your credit score, if you don't mind me asking? That's my biggest concern with the refinance coming up.
0 coins
Jacob Lewis
I work in a financial aid office, and this is a common question. The Parent PLUS loan will appear on your credit report, which could affect your debt-to-income ratio when refinancing your home. However, just having the loan doesn't necessarily hurt your credit score if you make payments on time. One strategy many families use: Have your student take out the maximum federal Direct loans first ($5,500-$7,500 depending on year in school and dependency status). Then use Parent PLUS loans to cover any remaining gaps. This minimizes your credit impact while accessing needed funds. Also consider: Parent PLUS loans have an origination fee of about 4.2%, while Direct Student loans have a lower fee around 1.1%. That's another cost factor beyond just interest rates.
0 coins
Sophia Miller
•The origination fee difference is something I hadn't even considered! So if I'm understanding correctly, the smart approach is probably to max out her student loans first, then only use Parent PLUS for whatever remaining amount we absolutely need? That would minimize both the interest rate impact and the origination fees.
0 coins
Amelia Martinez
I've been through this whole process with both my kids and I can tell you the student loan is DEFINITELY the better option! Parent PLUS not only has higher interest but they start accruing immediately while your kid is in school. At least with subsidized student loans, interest doesn't accrue while they're enrolled. The other thing nobody tells you - Parent PLUS loans are YOUR debt forever. You can't transfer them to your child later, even if you had a verbal agreement that they'd pay you back. My daughter promised she'd help with payments after graduation but guess what happened when she could only find a part-time job? I'm still paying alone 3 years later!
0 coins
Ethan Clark
•Omg this happened to my sister too!! She took out like $40k in Parent PLUS and her son never paid a penny back despite promising he would. Now she's stuck with the payments until she retires.
0 coins
Mila Walker
dont parent plus loans have some tax advantages tho? i thought you could deduct the interest on those but not if you just pay your kids loans? someone told me that but im not sure if its true
0 coins
Jacob Lewis
•Actually, both types of loans potentially allow for tax deductions on the interest paid. For Parent PLUS loans, the parent who legally took out the loan can deduct up to $2,500 in interest payments per year (subject to income limits). If you're helping pay your child's student loans that are in their name, technically they would get the tax deduction, not you - since the loan is in their name. However, if they're your dependent, this might still benefit your overall family tax situation. I'd recommend consulting a tax professional for your specific circumstances.
0 coins
Logan Scott
Has anyone else been COMPLETELY FRUSTRATED trying to get through to FSA to ask these exact questions?? I've been calling for THREE DAYS trying to get clear answers about loan options, and I either get disconnected or wait on hold for hours!! The website info is so generic and doesn't address my specific situation. I'm at my wit's end trying to make these decisions by the deadline!
0 coins
Mason Davis
•I had the same problem last month! Someone recommended a service called Claimyr.com that helps you skip the FAFSA phone queue. It worked really well - I got through to an agent in about 15 minutes instead of waiting for hours. They have a video showing how it works here: https://youtu.be/TbC8dZQWYNQ The agent I spoke with was actually really helpful in explaining the differences between loan types and how they'd affect my specific situation. Definitely better than trying to piece together information from the website.
0 coins
Sophia Miller
Based on all your responses, I think we'll definitely max out the Direct Student loans first, and only use Parent PLUS as a last resort if we absolutely need to. The interest rate difference and origination fees make a compelling case. I'm going to talk to our tax person about the potential tax implications too, just to make sure we're optimizing everything. Thank you all for the helpful advice!
0 coins
Amelia Martinez
•Smart choice! One more thing to consider - make sure your daughter understands what she's taking on with these loans. I wish I'd had my kids more involved in the financial literacy aspect from the beginning. Even though you plan to help with payments, having them understand the responsibility helps if circumstances change and they need to take over payments completely.
0 coins
Mia Rodriguez
btw has anyome noticed the SAI calcs r totally different this yr? our expected contribution went up like 5k from last yr with basically same income??
0 coins
Jacob Lewis
•Yes, the Student Aid Index (SAI) calculation did change for the 2025-2026 FAFSA. They modified several factors, including how they assess income protection allowances and asset calculations. Some families are seeing significant differences. If you think there's an error, you can request a professional judgment review from your school's financial aid office - especially if your financial situation has changed since you filed taxes.
0 coins
LilMama23
As someone who just went through this decision process last year, I want to echo what others have said about maxing out Direct Student loans first. The math really is compelling - that 2%+ interest rate difference adds up to thousands over a 10-year repayment period. One thing I didn't see mentioned yet: if your daughter qualifies for subsidized loans (based on financial need), those are even better since the government pays the interest while she's in school. My son got $3,500 in subsidized and $2,000 unsubsidized for his freshman year. Also, regarding your refinance concerns - the Parent PLUS inquiry will likely cause a temporary small dip in your credit score, but if you're not planning to refinance for several months, that should recover. However, the ongoing monthly payment obligation will definitely factor into your debt-to-income ratio, which lenders scrutinize heavily for mortgage refinancing. We ended up doing exactly what you're considering - daughter took max student loans, we help with payments, and avoided Parent PLUS entirely. So far it's worked out well financially and she's building her credit history with on-time payments.
0 coins