< Back to FAFSA

Luis Johnson

Got financial aid package for twins but still $26K short - no Parent Plus loan eligibility

Just received the financial aid packages for my twins who are starting college this fall, and I'm honestly in shock. Between the two of them, we're still $26,000 short AFTER grants, scholarships, and their federal student loans! We applied for Parent Plus loans but were denied due to our credit history (had some medical bills go to collections last year). The financial aid office just said "explore private loan options" but with our credit score, that's not realistic. We make too much for full need-based aid ($89,000 household) but not enough to just write checks for college. Our SAI came back at $14,600 which is way more than we can actually contribute. Has anyone been in this situation? What options do we have when there's such a huge gap? I'm starting to panic because deposits are due in 3 weeks.

Ellie Kim

•

same boat here with my son. ended up having him take a gap year and reapply to cheaper schools + more scholarships. sucks but college is just ridiculous now

0 coins

Luis Johnson

•

A gap year is something we've discussed but they've been so excited about these specific programs. Did your son end up at a good school after the gap year?

0 coins

Fiona Sand

•

There are several options you might consider: 1. Appeal the financial aid package - contact the financial aid office directly and explain your situation with the medical bills that affected your credit. Many schools have a special circumstances appeal process. 2. Look into Parent PLUS Loan endorsers - you can get an endorser (similar to a co-signer) who agrees to pay the loan if you don't. Grandparents or other relatives sometimes help with this. 3. Consider having your children attend community college for core classes and transfer to save on the first two years. 4. Ask about payment plans - many schools offer monthly payment plans that might make the costs more manageable without loans. 5. Have your students look for part-time work through Federal Work-Study or off-campus jobs to contribute more.

0 coins

Luis Johnson

•

Thank you, this is really helpful. I didn't know about the endorser option for Parent PLUS loans - my sister might be willing to help with that. We tried appealing already but they basically just confirmed our SAI calculation was correct. I'll try again specifically mentioning the medical bills situation.

0 coins

Just want to add that if you were denied for Parent PLUS loans, your children become eligible for additional unsubsidized federal student loans - usually $4,000 more per year for freshmen/sophomores. Make sure the financial aid office has factored this in. It won't cover everything but might help close the gap somewhat.

0 coins

WELCOME TO THE SCAM that is american higher education!!! $89k is NOT enough to pay for college anymore and they KNOW IT but they keep raising tuition anyway. the whole sai system is a JOKE. my daughter had to drop out after first semester because we couldn't make the math work either. its criminal what theyre doing to middle class families!!!!

0 coins

Finnegan Gunn

•

While I understand your frustration, there ARE solutions. We were in a similar position (denied Parent PLUS, gap of about $18K). We appealed with detailed documentation of our financial situation and got an additional $7K in institutional grants. For the rest, we used a combination of the additional unsubsidized loans (that students can get when parents are denied PLUS loans) and a private loan with my brother as cosigner. It wasn't easy but we made it work without dropping out.

0 coins

Luis Johnson

•

I'm sorry your daughter had to drop out - that's exactly what I'm afraid of. Did she end up going back to a different school later?

0 coins

Miguel Harvey

•

When I got denied for Parent Plus loans last year for my son, I spent weeks trying to get through to someone at FSA to discuss appeal options. Kept getting disconnected or waiting for hours. I finally used Claimyr.com to get through to an agent in about 8 minutes - they have this service where they wait on hold for you and call when an agent answers. Saved me so much stress. There's a demo video at https://youtu.be/TbC8dZQWYNQ that shows how it works. The agent explained some additional options for Parent PLUS denials that weren't on the website.

0 coins

Ellie Kim

•

does that actually work? i spent literally 4 hrs on hold with fafsa last month and ended up hanging up

0 coins

Miguel Harvey

•

Yeah it really does. I was skeptical too but it saved me so much time. The agent helped me understand the endorser process for the PLUS loan which ended up being our solution.

0 coins

Ashley Simian

•

have u checked if your kids qualify for more aid based on parent plus denial? when i got denied for plus loans my daughter got like $4k more in unsubisdized loans automatically. not enough to cover everything but helped some

0 coins

Luis Johnson

•

I didn't know this was automatic! The financial aid office never mentioned this. I'll call them tomorrow specifically about this. Thanks for the tip.

0 coins

Financial aid professional here. When parents are denied for PLUS loans, I always recommend these steps: 1. First, ensure your children receive the additional unsubsidized loan amounts they're entitled to ($4,000/year for freshmen and sophomores, $5,000/year for juniors and seniors) 2. File a special circumstances appeal specifically addressing the medical bills that led to the collections. Provide documentation showing these were unavoidable expenses. 3. Ask the financial aid office about institutional payment plans - many schools offer 10-12 month plans that can make the remaining balance more manageable. 4. Look into whether either school offers institutional loans (different from federal loans) which often have more flexible credit requirements. 5. Consider whether one child might defer for a year to stagger the college expenses. Also, remember that the SAI isn't necessarily what schools expect you to pay out-of-pocket in a single year. Many families use a combination of current income, savings, and borrowing spread over time.

0 coins

Luis Johnson

•

Thank you so much for this detailed advice. I didn't know about institutional loans - I'll definitely ask about that option. We've been so focused on federal aid that we haven't fully explored what the schools themselves might offer. I have a meeting with the financial aid office tomorrow and will bring up all these points.

0 coins

Finnegan Gunn

•

We were in almost exactly your situation with twins three years ago! What helped us was appealing directly to each school's financial aid office with a letter explaining our specific circumstances (in our case, caring for an elderly parent alongside college costs). One school increased their institutional grant by $5,000 per student. We also looked at the CSS Profile schools which sometimes have more institutional aid for middle-income families than FAFSA-only schools. For the remaining gap, we ended up having grandparents serve as endorsers for the Parent PLUS loans. It's worth exploring if you have family members with good credit who might help. Without that, we would have had to choose less expensive schools.

0 coins

Luis Johnson

•

This gives me hope! I didn't even think about asking grandparents to be endorsers. My in-laws might be willing to help with that. I'm also going to try appealing again with more specific documentation about our financial situation. Did you find that providing actual documents (bills, etc.) helped with your appeal?

0 coins

Finnegan Gunn

•

Yes! Documentation made all the difference. We included copies of caregiver expenses, medical bills, and a detailed monthly budget showing why we couldn't meet the expected contribution. Be extremely specific about your situation with the medical bills - dates, amounts, why they went to collections, and how this affected your overall financial picture.

0 coins

anybody notice how the FAFSA is SUPPOSEDLY easier now but somehow gives LESS aid than before?? my nephew got $3400 LESS this year with the "simplified" fafsa and their financial situation is EXACTLY THE SAME!!

0 coins

The new FAFSA formula (now using SAI instead of EFC) does calculate family contribution differently. Some middle-income families are seeing less aid, while others are seeing more. It depends on your specific financial details like number of dependents in college, types of income and assets, etc. Your nephew should definitely appeal if there was such a significant change without corresponding changes in financial circumstances.

0 coins

Luis Johnson

•

Update: I want to thank everyone for their advice. I called both financial aid offices this morning and learned that my twins ARE eligible for additional unsubsidized loans because of our Parent PLUS denial. That will cover about $8,000 of our gap. I've also scheduled appointments to discuss institutional payment plans and possible additional grants based on our medical bill situation. My sister has agreed to look into being an endorser for a smaller Parent PLUS loan to cover the remaining amount. I'm still stressed but feeling like we have a path forward now.

0 coins

FAFSA AI

Expert Assistant
Secure

Powered by Claimyr AI

T
I
+
20,095 users helped today