< Back to FAFSA

Liam Duke

FAFSA using outdated income - how to report job/income change?

Just completed my 2025-2026 FAFSA application and realized it's using our 2023 tax info, but my situation has completely changed since then. I was making around $74,000 at my previous job, but I've been at a new company since February where I'm only making $52,000. This is a HUGE difference that would definitely affect my daughter's aid package! Is there a section somewhere on the FAFSA where I can explain this income change? Or do I need to wait until after submission to request some kind of adjustment? The differences in our household income would make a significant impact on what we can actually afford for college. Anyone gone through something similar?

Manny Lark

•

You need to contact the financial aid office at each school your applying to and ask for a 'professional judgment' or 'income appeal'. FAFSA doesnt have a spot for this info

0 coins

Liam Duke

•

Thank you! Is this something I should do right after submitting the FAFSA or should I wait until we get the aid package?

0 coins

Rita Jacobs

•

What you're looking for is called a "Special Circumstances Review" or "Professional Judgment Appeal." This isn't handled through the FAFSA itself, but directly with each college's financial aid office. The FAFSA is required to use 2023 tax data for the 2025-2026 application - there's no way around that in the initial filing. After your FAFSA is processed and you receive your SAI (Student Aid Index), you'll need to contact each school where your daughter is applying and explain the situation. They'll have specific forms for you to document the income change. You'll likely need: - Last pay stubs from old job - Current pay stubs from new job - Letter explaining the change - Possibly a letter from your employer confirming the new salary Don't wait until after receiving aid packages - start this process as soon as your FAFSA is processed and you have your SAI number.

0 coins

Liam Duke

•

This is incredibly helpful! I was worried we'd be stuck with the higher income calculation. I'll gather all those documents and be ready to submit them once we get the SAI score. Is there typically a deadline for submitting these appeals?

0 coins

Khalid Howes

•

my cousin had the same thing happen last yr when she lost her job!! the financial aid ppl can fix it but u have to CALL them they wont do anything if u just email!!

0 coins

Liam Duke

•

Ugh, that's what I was afraid of. Getting through to anyone on the phone these days is practically impossible. Did your cousin have to call each school separately?

0 coins

Ben Cooper

•

You've run into one of the most frustrating aspects of the FAFSA - it uses outdated income information! I went through this exact situation last year. Let me assure you, this is a common situation that financial aid offices deal with regularly. What you need is called a "Professional Judgment Review" (sometimes called an "Income Appeal" or "Special Circumstances Appeal"). Here's what worked for me: 1. Submit your FAFSA using the required 2023 income information 2. Immediately contact each college's financial aid office (don't wait for packages) 3. Ask specifically for their "Professional Judgment" forms for income reduction 4. Be prepared with documentation showing both your previous and current income Each school handles this differently - some have formal forms, others want a letter. But ALL schools have procedures for this situation. The key is starting early and being persistent with follow-up. In my case, my income dropped from $82K to $61K, and we got an additional $7,300 in aid after the adjustment at one school and $5,800 at another. Completely worth the effort!

0 coins

Liam Duke

•

Thank you SO much for sharing your experience! This gives me hope. The potential adjustment amounts you mentioned would make a huge difference for us. I'll definitely start contacting schools as soon as our FAFSA is processed.

0 coins

Naila Gordon

•

FAFSA is such a joke. They KNOW this is everyone's situation but they FORCE us to use outdated info anyway. Then you have to jump through a million hoops to fix it and half the time they don't even adjust it enough! The whole system is designed to give you less aid than you deserve. Good luck but don't get your hopes up.

0 coins

Cynthia Love

•

While the process can be frustrating, I've worked with many families who successfully received adjustments through Professional Judgment reviews. The system uses prior-prior year tax data to allow for earlier FAFSA filing, giving families more time to plan. Schools genuinely want to provide appropriate aid based on current circumstances, but they need documentation to justify adjustments. Most financial aid officers are advocates for students, not gatekeepers.

0 coins

Darren Brooks

•

I had a similar situation when submitting my 2024-2025 FAFSA. I lost my job and had a significant income reduction. I tried calling the Federal Student Aid helpline for WEEKS and couldn't get through. Finally, I discovered a service called Claimyr (claimyr.com) that helped me skip the phone queue and got me connected to an actual FSA agent in about 20 minutes. They have a video showing how it works: https://youtu.be/TbC8dZQWYNQ The agent explained that I needed to complete the FAFSA with my 2022 tax info as required, but then contact each school for a "Professional Judgment" review. Getting that direct advice from FSA was really helpful because each school handled it slightly differently. Some had online forms while others needed detailed letters.

0 coins

Khalid Howes

•

does that claimyr thing actually work?? i tried calling fsa like 10 times last month and kept getting disconnected!!

0 coins

Darren Brooks

•

Yes! I was super skeptical but I was desperate after trying for weeks. It connected me to an agent in about 18 minutes when I had been trying on my own for days. The FSA agent was able to answer all my questions about the income appeal process and even noted in my file that I'd be doing professional judgment reviews.

0 coins

Cynthia Love

•

Financial aid professional here! This is called a "Professional Judgment" review, and it's specifically designed for situations like yours. The federal methodology requires using 2023 tax data for the 2025-2026 FAFSA, but colleges have the authority to make adjustments for significant income changes. Important points: 1. You MUST submit the FAFSA with 2023 data first - no exceptions 2. Contact EACH college where your daughter is applying (each has different forms) 3. Be prepared to document both the change AND your new income level 4. Start this process IMMEDIATELY after submitting FAFSA - don't wait for aid packages 5. Follow up persistently - these reviews take time and often require additional information For your $74K to $52K change, many schools would make a significant adjustment to your SAI calculation. Based on the federal formula, this could potentially increase eligibility for need-based aid by $5,000-9,000 depending on your other financial factors. Don't get discouraged by the process - this is a legitimate and common adjustment!

0 coins

Liam Duke

•

Thank you for this professional perspective! I feel much more confident now. Quick follow-up question: should I mention this income change in the "additional information" section when I'm submitting the FAFSA, or is that not the right place?

0 coins

Cynthia Love

•

The "additional information" section won't affect your SAI calculation - the FAFSA processor doesn't make these adjustments. However, it doesn't hurt to mention it there briefly as a heads-up to schools reviewing your application. The real action happens with the formal Professional Judgment request directly to each school. Just write something simple like "Income significantly reduced in 2024 due to job change, will be submitting Professional Judgment request.

0 coins

Manny Lark

•

i went thru this last year, different reason but same problem. you NEED to save all ur paystubs from old and new job. the schools wanted like 3 months worth to prove the change. and they made me write a letter explaining everything.

0 coins

Ben Cooper

•

One important thing nobody has mentioned yet - if your daughter is applying to multiple schools, you'll need to complete the Professional Judgment process at EACH school separately. They don't share this information with each other. Also, the timing can be tricky. Some schools want you to wait until you receive the initial aid package before requesting a review, while others prefer you start the process immediately after FAFSA submission. I recommend calling each financial aid office after submitting your FAFSA to ask about their specific process and timeline. Don't get discouraged if one school is more difficult than others - each institution has different policies and available funding. Some might adjust your aid significantly while others might make minimal changes even with the same documentation.

0 coins

Liam Duke

•

That's a great point about the timing differences between schools. I'll make a list of all the schools and contact each one individually to understand their specific process. Thank you!

0 coins

Amina Bah

•

One thing that helped me when I went through this process was creating a spreadsheet to track each school's requirements and deadlines for Professional Judgment appeals. Some schools had online portals for uploading documents, others wanted everything mailed or faxed (yes, faxed in 2024!). Also, when you're gathering documentation, include a brief cover letter explaining the timeline of your job change. I found that being very specific about dates (like "employed at Company A until January 31, 2024, started at Company B on February 5, 2024") helped the financial aid officers understand the situation quickly. Your income drop from $74K to $52K is substantial enough that most schools should make a meaningful adjustment. Don't let anyone tell you it's "not enough of a change" - that's over a 29% reduction in income!

0 coins

FAFSA AI

Expert Assistant
Secure

Powered by Claimyr AI

T
I
+
20,095 users helped today