FAFSA confusion: Where to report non-IRA investments vs. savings accounts with 'shares'?
I'm completely lost on how to categorize my assets on the FAFSA. My financial advisor manages some of our money (about $24,000) that's not in IRAs or 401ks - just regular investment accounts. Then I have a savings account at my credit union that shows up as 'shares' on the statement (only about $2,800). For FAFSA reporting, should the advisor-managed money go under 'investments' even though it's not retirement? And what about my credit union savings that says 'shares'? The wording is confusing me and I don't want to report incorrectly and mess up my daughter's financial aid.
23 comments
Join the conversation
Finley Garrett
The FAFSA asset categorization can definitely be confusing! Here's how to correctly report these: 1. The $24,000 managed by your financial advisor goes under 'investments' - this category includes any money in brokerage accounts, mutual funds, stocks, bonds, etc. that aren't in retirement accounts. 2. Your credit union savings that shows as 'shares' (this is common credit union terminology) should be reported under 'cash, savings, and checking accounts' - it functions as a savings account regardless of what they call it. Basically, 'investments' includes money intended for growth/returns, while 'cash/savings/checking' includes money kept liquid for everyday use or short-term needs.
0 coins
Cass Green
•Thank you so much! That makes perfect sense. So even though my financial advisor accounts aren't retirement-specific, they still count as investments since they're meant for growth. And I'm relieved about the credit union account - I was overthinking the 'shares' language.
0 coins
Madison Tipne
the credit union thing confused me 2! they always call it 'shares' but its just a regular savings acct. fafsa doesnt make this stuff easy lol
0 coins
Cass Green
•Right?! Why can't they use clearer language on these forms? It's stressful enough figuring out how to pay for college without all this confusion.
0 coins
Holly Lascelles
I had this EXACT same issue last year! I spent HOURS on the phone trying to reach someone at Federal Student Aid to clarify this. The explanation you got is correct - anything with your financial advisor that's not a retirement account goes under investments. Your credit union savings (even with the weird 'shares' terminology) is just regular savings. BTW - if you ever need to reach a real person at FSA, try Claimyr.com - they got me through to a live agent in about 15 minutes when I was stuck on hold forever. They have a demo video that shows how it works: https://youtu.be/TbC8dZQWYNQ. Totally saved me last year when I was completely confused about where to report our trust fund.
0 coins
Malia Ponder
•does claimyr really work? ive been trying to get someone on the phone for days to ask about my verification requirements...
0 coins
Holly Lascelles
•Absolutely! I was skeptical too, but it saved me so much frustration. The FAFSA phone system is impossible otherwise - I kept getting disconnected after waiting 40+ minutes.
0 coins
Kyle Wallace
I think I might have reported this wrong on our 2024-2025 FAFSA 😰 I put my husband's brokerage account under savings because I thought investments only meant retirement accounts and college savings plans. Should I go back and correct our form? Will this cause problems with my son's aid package?
0 coins
Ryder Ross
•You should definitely submit a correction. Log into studentaid.gov, select your FAFSA application, and click on "Make FAFSA Corrections." It's better to fix this now than to have verification issues later. The SAI (Student Aid Index) calculation treats different assets at different rates, so having them in the wrong category could affect your aid eligibility.
0 coins
Kyle Wallace
•Thank you! I'm going to correct it right away. I'm always so nervous about making mistakes on these forms.
0 coins
Gianni Serpent
I've been doing financial aid applications for my three kids for years, and here's what I've learned: FAFSA's asset categorization is WAY more straightforward than the CSS Profile if your schools require that! On FAFSA: - Cash/Savings/Checking = liquid funds (including CDs, money market accounts, and yes, credit union 'shares') - Investments = everything else that's not retirement or your primary home (stocks, bonds, mutual funds, 529 plans, rental properties, etc.) - Business/Farm = self-explanatory but has specific requirements The most important thing is to be CONSISTENT between years unless your situation changes. The financial aid office looks for big unexplained changes.
0 coins
Cass Green
•This is so helpful! My daughter's considering some schools that require the CSS Profile too, and I've heard that's even more detailed. Do they treat these categories differently?
0 coins
Gianni Serpent
•Oh yes, CSS Profile is MUCH more detailed. They ask about home equity, more business details, and even non-custodial parent finances. They also have different formulas for calculating how assets affect aid. If you need help with CSS Profile specifically, that's a whole different conversation!
0 coins
Malia Ponder
wait so do i need to report my bitcoin as an investment? its only like $900 worth
0 coins
Finley Garrett
•Yes, cryptocurrency like Bitcoin should be reported as an investment on the FAFSA. Any asset that could potentially generate returns or has value beyond cash would fall into this category. Even though $900 isn't a huge amount, it should still be included for accuracy.
0 coins
Kyle Wallace
My financial advisor told me that money market accounts should go under "Cash, Savings and Checking" on FAFSA even though they're with our investment firm. Is that right? The categorization is so confusing!
0 coins
Ryder Ross
•Your advisor is correct. Money market accounts, regardless of where they're held, are typically reported under "Cash, Savings and Checking" because they function similarly to savings accounts. They're considered liquid assets rather than investments, even when managed by an investment firm. The key differentiation is the function of the account, not where it's held.
0 coins
Cass Green
Update: I just went through the FAFSA and found the help text explaining this! If anyone else is confused, click the little question mark icon next to each category. The explanation for investments specifically mentions "stock, bonds, mutual funds" and other non-retirement investments should go there. I'm feeling much more confident now about how to report everything correctly.
0 coins
Madison Tipne
•those little question marks saved me too! the help text is actually pretty good once you find it
0 coins
Henry Delgado
I included my rental property as an investment last year and got selected for verification. Had to provide so much documentation it was ridiculous. Just make sure whatever you report you have statements to back it up in case they ask!
0 coins
Cass Green
•That's good advice! I'll make sure to save all my statements from both accounts. Did the verification process take long? I'm worried about delays affecting my daughter's aid.
0 coins
Henry Delgado
•It took about 3 weeks which wasn't too bad, but this was in April before the rush. I've heard it can take 6-8 weeks during busy periods. Definitely keep those statements handy!
0 coins
Oliver Zimmermann
Thanks everyone for this helpful discussion! As someone new to the FAFSA process, I was struggling with the same asset categorization questions. The clarification about advisor-managed non-retirement accounts going under "investments" and credit union "shares" going under "cash/savings" is exactly what I needed. I also appreciate the tip about using the question mark help icons - I completely missed those! Going to make sure I have all my statements organized in case of verification. This community is so valuable for navigating these confusing forms.
0 coins