FAFSA aid package deadline in 24 hours - will accepting it disqualify us from academic scholarships?
Just got our SAI and financial aid package on Friday and I'm freaking out. The school is giving us until tomorrow at 3pm EST to accept (literally less than 24 hours notice!) or supposedly we'll "lose the offer." The package they offered is honestly pathetic - mostly unsubsidized loans with a tiny Pell Grant that barely covers textbooks. My daughter has a 3.8 GPA and we're still waiting to hear about potential academic scholarships from the same school. If we accept this crappy aid package now, will that somehow disqualify her from receiving academic scholarships later? The financial aid office doesn't answer their phone and I'm panicking about this deadline. Has anyone dealt with this before? Do schools actually take back aid offers if you don't instantly accept them?
21 comments
Join the conversation
Abigail Spencer
Don't worry - accepting federal aid will NOT disqualify your daughter from academic scholarships. Those are completely separate processes. The financial aid package is based on your FAFSA and SAI calculation, while academic scholarships are merit-based and handled by different departments. Schools often set these quick deadlines to pressure families, but in my experience working with several students last year, the "deadline" is usually flexible. They want your tuition dollars! I'd recommend accepting the package to secure the federal aid (especially that Pell Grant), and then continue pursuing academic scholarships.
0 coins
Anita George
•Thank you so much - that's a relief! So just to be 100% clear, when those academic scholarship decisions come through (hopefully next week), she can still receive those ON TOP OF whatever federal aid I accept tomorrow? The communication from this school has been horrible.
0 coins
Logan Chiang
OMG schools are THE WORST with these fake deadlines!!! My son got the same 24hr ultimatum last yr and I totally panicked and accepted everything including the parent plus loan which I DIDNT EVEN WANT. then I called financial aid like 10 times and finally got thru and they said "oh yeah we can adjust that later" 🙄 LIKE WHY THE DRAMA THEN???
0 coins
Isla Fischer
•Same!! They do this every year and it drives me CRAZY. Last year they told my nephew he had 48 hrs to accept and then we found out his roommate got the same package but had a full week to decide?? It's all mind games!
0 coins
Miles Hammonds
Financial aid counselor here. There's often confusion about how aid packages work with scholarships, so let me clarify: 1. Federal aid (loans, grants based on your FAFSA) is separate from merit scholarships 2. Accepting your current package will NOT disqualify her from academic scholarships 3. When academic scholarships are awarded, the financial aid office will ADJUST your package 4. This adjustment usually reduces loans first, not grants 5. Most schools have a total aid ceiling that can't exceed Cost of Attendance The deadline may seem tight, but it's to ensure they can distribute all available aid. If you don't accept, they reallocate those funds to other students. I recommend accepting now and then requesting an adjustment when scholarships come through.
0 coins
Anita George
•Thank you for the detailed explanation! One followup - if she gets a big academic scholarship that covers most costs, can we then decline some of these loans we're accepting now? We really don't want to take on debt if we don't have to.
0 coins
Miles Hammonds
•Absolutely! You can decline or reduce loan amounts at any point before disbursement. Even after accepting the current package, you're not obligated to take the full loan amounts. When scholarships come in, contact the financial aid office to reduce or cancel loans as needed. Just keep the Pell Grant - that's free money!
0 coins
Ruby Blake
this happens to evry1 dont worry. my daughter got a full ride academic scholarship AFTER we accepted the fafsa stuff and it was fine they just redid everything. the financial aid and scholarship offices dont even talk to each other lol
0 coins
Micah Franklin
I've been through this nightmare THREE times with my kids. The whole system is designed to confuse parents and force quick decisions. After days of trying to reach someone at my son's financial aid office, I finally discovered Claimyr.com which connected me directly to a live FSA agent who explained how these packages work with scholarships. Saved me hours of frustration! You can see how it works at https://youtu.be/TbC8dZQWYNQ Your daughter's academic achievements should definitely still qualify for merit scholarships regardless of what aid package you accept now. Those are separate pools of money.
0 coins
Isla Fischer
•does this actually work?? i spent 4 HOURS on hold with financial aid yesterday and got disconnected TWICE
0 coins
Micah Franklin
•Yes! I was skeptical too but it connected me within 10 minutes when I'd been trying for days on my own. The FSA agent was able to explain exactly how accepting aid now wouldn't affect future scholarships.
0 coins
Ella Harper
Your making a big deal out of nothing. Schools always do this. Just accept the package, it's not like your signing away your life or something. When my kid got his academic scholarship later they just adjusted everything. You can always turn down loans later but can't get more aid if you miss deadline. My daughter lost out on $3k because she missed a deadline by ONE DAY.
0 coins
Anita George
•I don't think it's "making a big deal out of nothing" when we're talking about thousands of dollars in potential debt with less than 24 hours to decide. But I appreciate knowing that they adjusted things later when your child received scholarships.
0 coins
PrinceJoe
I work in higher ed (not financial aid specifically). The system is incredibly frustrating, but here's what's actually happening: Your FAFSA created an SAI score which determines your federal aid eligibility (Pell Grants, federal loans, etc). Academic scholarships are completely separate and come from the institution's own funds. Accepting this package now ONLY means you're reserving those federal dollars. When academic scholarships are awarded, they'll be ADDED to your package, and then the financial aid office will recalculate. They typically reduce loans first when this happens. The reason for the quick deadline is that federal aid is limited, especially campus-based aid. If you don't claim it, they reassign it to other students. It's not a marketing tactic - they literally have to reallocate unclaimed federal dollars.
0 coins
Anita George
•Thank you for explaining from the school's perspective. I didn't realize they had to reallocate funds so quickly. That makes more sense than just trying to pressure us. I'll accept the package today and hope for good scholarship news soon!
0 coins
Brooklyn Knight
The financial aid system is DESIGNED to be confusing and predatory. My daughter had a similar situation and we accepted the aid package only to realize later we'd unknowingly signed up for the highest interest Parent PLUS loans when she qualified for much better options. These schools prey on confusion and fear with these fake "deadlines" to maximize their revenue. It should be criminal how they operate.
0 coins
Miles Hammonds
•I understand your frustration, but I want to clarify that Parent PLUS loans require a separate application and credit check - they can't be unknowingly included in an acceptance of a financial aid package. You must specifically apply for them. And the interest rates are standardized by the federal government, not set by individual schools. While the system is definitely complex, it sounds like there might have been some miscommunication in your specific case.
0 coins
Brooklyn Knight
•Maybe at YOUR school, but that's not how it worked for us! The "acceptance" page had everything bundled together and the fine print was deliberately misleading. And they absolutely pushed the most expensive options first!
0 coins
Abigail Spencer
One thing nobody has mentioned - you can actually NEGOTIATE your financial aid package! After you accept this one, gather information about better offers from other schools, documentation of any special circumstances, and examples of your daughter's academic achievements. Then request a financial aid appeal meeting. Many schools have additional institutional funds they can offer, especially for students with strong academics. Don't just take their first offer as final!
0 coins
Anita George
•I had no idea we could negotiate! That's really helpful. We did get a slightly better offer from another school - can I use that in the negotiation even though we already committed to this school for other reasons?
0 coins
Abigail Spencer
•Absolutely! Other school offers are your strongest negotiating tool. Just be respectful in how you present it - frame it as "We're committed to your school, but the cost difference is significant. Is there any way you can help us bridge this gap?" Have the other offer letter ready to share. Many schools have special scholarship funds they can tap into for students they really want to enroll.
0 coins