Can SS benefits increase from working before FRA, or only after reaching Full Retirement Age?
I've been trying to understand how continued work affects Social Security benefits after you start collecting. I get that if your current earnings replace a zero or low-income year in your top 35, the SSA will recalculate and potentially increase your monthly benefit (usually happening in October with back pay and the new amount starting in November). But here's where I'm confused - does this benefit recalculation only happen for people working past their Full Retirement Age? Or can those of us who took benefits early (62) ALSO get these recalculations and increases if our current wages are high enough to bump out lower years? I know early retirees who work get hit with the earnings limit ($1 reduction for every $2 over $21,240 in 2025), but I'm wondering if we still get the BENEFIT of having those earnings counted toward a potential increase. I thought yes, but now I'm doubting myself. Anyone know for sure?
15 comments
Join the conversation
StarStrider
Yes, your benefit can be recalculated based on additional earnings even if you claimed early. The SSA looks at your earnings record every year regardless of when you started collecting. If your current year's earnings are high enough to replace one of your lower 35 years, they'll automatically recalculate your Primary Insurance Amount (PIA) and adjust your benefits accordingly. The earnings test (the $1 for $2 reduction) is a separate issue from the recalculation. You might have your benefits temporarily reduced due to the earnings test, but those earnings can still increase your benefit amount through recalculation. The difference is that if you're past FRA, you get the full benefit of the increase immediately. If you're pre-FRA, any increase would still be reduced by your early claiming reduction factor.
0 coins
Zara Ahmed
•Thank you so much for clarifying! So just to make sure I understand - if I'm 63 and working while collecting reduced benefits (I started at 62), my 2025 earnings could bump a low year from my top 35, resulting in a recalculated higher benefit amount in October 2026. But that new higher amount would still be reduced by the early claiming percentage I locked in when I started at 62. Is that right?
0 coins
Luca Esposito
my mom had this happen!!! she started ss at 63 and kept workin part time and her check went up like $37 the next oct. not huge but better than nothing lol
0 coins
Nia Thompson
•Did your mother get any kind of notice about the increase? I've been working while collecting for 2 years (started at 62) and haven't seen any adjustments to my benefit. Now I'm wondering if I need to contact them or if it happens automatically. The SSA doesn't exactly have a reputation for proactive communication...
0 coins
Mateo Rodriguez
I think it depends on your birth year. My financial advisor told me different rules apply depending on when you were born. Something about WEP calculations for people born before 1960, but I could be mixing things up.
0 coins
Aisha Abdullah
•You're mixing up a couple of different concepts. WEP (Windfall Elimination Provision) has nothing to do with birth year - it affects people who earned pensions from jobs not covered by Social Security (like some government jobs). The benefit recalculation from additional earnings works the same way regardless of birth year. Your birth year only affects your Full Retirement Age and the reduction percentages for early claiming. To answer the original question: YES, earnings before FRA will be included in annual recalculations, but any increase will still be subject to your early retirement reduction factor.
0 coins
Ethan Wilson
My aunt lost so much taking SS at 62 and still working - they took back almost HALF her benefit because of the earnings limit!!! The whole system is RIGGED to punish people who need to work. She should have just waited until FRA but she didn't understand the rules. The SSA doesn't explain ANYTHING clearly on purpose!!!
0 coins
StarStrider
•I understand your frustration, but there's an important point to clarify here. The money withheld due to the earnings test isn't permanently lost. Once your aunt reaches FRA, the SSA will recalculate her benefit amount to credit her for those months when benefits were withheld, resulting in a higher monthly payment going forward. It's essentially like temporarily suspending part of the early retirement reduction. Many people don't realize this and think those withheld benefits are gone forever, but they're actually transformed into higher monthly payments later.
0 coins
NeonNova
Have you tried calling Social Security directly? I recently needed to ask about my benefit calculation and kept hitting busy signals and disconnections for DAYS. Then I found this service called Claimyr (claimyr.com) that got me through to a real person at SSA in under 10 minutes. They have a video showing how it works here: https://youtu.be/Z-BRbJw3puU Saved me hours of frustration. The agent I spoke with confirmed that benefits are recalculated annually regardless of whether you're above or below FRA. Your specific situation sounds a bit complex though, so speaking with them directly might give you the clearest answer.
0 coins
Zara Ahmed
•Thanks for the tip! I've been trying to get through to SSA for the past week with no luck. The constant busy signals have been driving me crazy. I'll check out that service - at this point I just need a definitive answer from someone official.
0 coins
Aisha Abdullah
Social Security benefits specialist here. Let me clear this up definitively: 1. Yes, the SSA recalculates benefits annually regardless of your age (pre or post FRA) 2. If your current earnings replace a lower year in your top 35, your Primary Insurance Amount (PIA) will increase 3. If you claimed early, any PIA increase will still be subject to your reduction factor 4. The recalculation typically happens in October of the following year (2025 earnings affect benefits in Oct 2026) 5. Back payments from January-September are paid in a lump sum 6. The earnings test ($1 for $2 over limit) is completely separate from benefit recalculations Bottom line: Working before FRA CAN increase your benefit if your earnings bump out a lower year, even though you'll still face the earnings test reduction temporarily.
0 coins
Nia Thompson
•This is so helpful! Quick follow-up question - if someone has their benefits completely withheld some months due to the earnings test, do those earnings still count toward potentially increasing their benefit through recalculation? Or do you have to actually receive some benefit during the year for the earnings to count?
0 coins
Luca Esposito
My friend says shes getting 3700 a month from social security, is that even possible??? seems way too high
0 coins
StarStrider
•The maximum Social Security retirement benefit for someone at FRA in 2025 is around $3,800/month (for someone who earned at or above the maximum taxable earnings limit for 35 years and waited until FRA to claim). So yes, it's possible, but quite rare - less than 1% of beneficiaries receive amounts that high. The average benefit for 2025 is closer to $1,900/month. Your friend might be including other benefits or income in that figure.
0 coins
Zara Ahmed
Thanks everyone for the great responses! This has been incredibly helpful. Just to summarize what I've learned: 1. Yes, the SSA will recalculate my benefit even before FRA if my current earnings replace a lower year 2. Any increase will still be reduced by my early claiming penalty 3. The earnings test reduction is temporary and gets factored back in at FRA 4. The recalculation happens automatically each year For anyone else wondering about this - this thread has great info! I'm going to try calling SSA to confirm my specific situation. If I can't get through I'll check out that Claimyr service mentioned above.
0 coins