NYS Department of Labor unemployment eligibility if someone quits their job - what are the rules?
I'm trying to understand the rules about quitting and unemployment benefits in New York. My sister had to quit her retail job last month because her manager was making the workplace really hostile and she couldn't take it anymore. She's been looking for work but hasn't found anything yet. Can she file for unemployment with NYS Department of Labor even though she quit? I thought you had to be laid off to get benefits but I'm seeing conflicting information online. What counts as a good reason to quit that would still make you eligible?
14 comments
Join the conversation
Sofia Price
Yes, you can potentially get unemployment benefits even if you quit, but NYS Department of Labor requires that you had 'good cause' for quitting. This includes things like unsafe working conditions, harassment, discrimination, or if your employer changed your job duties or pay significantly. Your sister would need to document the hostile work environment - emails, witness statements, complaints she filed with HR, etc. When she files her claim, she'll need to explain why she quit and provide evidence.
0 coins
Mateo Warren
•Thank you! She did try to talk to the store manager about it but they basically brushed her off. She didn't file anything formal though. Would that hurt her case?
0 coins
Sofia Price
•It could make it more challenging, but not impossible. NYS Department of Labor will look at whether she made reasonable efforts to resolve the situation first. Even informal complaints or attempts to address the issue can help her case.
0 coins
Alice Coleman
I quit my job for similar reasons and got approved for benefits. The key is being really detailed when you file your claim about WHY you quit. Don't just say 'hostile workplace' - explain specific incidents, dates if you remember them, and what you tried to do to fix it. NYS Department of Labor adjudicators need concrete examples.
0 coins
Mateo Warren
•That's really helpful to know! How long did it take for them to make a decision on your claim?
0 coins
Alice Coleman
•Mine took about 5 weeks because it went to adjudication. They had to investigate and probably contacted my former employer too.
0 coins
Owen Jenkins
Just a heads up - even if she gets approved, her former employer might appeal the decision. A lot of companies fight unemployment claims when someone quits because it affects their unemployment insurance rates. She should be prepared for that possibility and keep all her documentation organized.
0 coins
Mateo Warren
•Oh I didn't know employers could appeal! That's stressful to think about.
0 coins
Lilah Brooks
I've been trying to get through to NYS Department of Labor for weeks about my own claim situation and it's impossible! If your sister needs to talk to someone about her specific case, I recently found this service called Claimyr (claimyr.com) that helps you actually get through to agents. They have a video demo at https://youtu.be/qyftW-mnTNI showing how it works. Saved me so much frustration after being hung up on like 20 times.
0 coins
Jackson Carter
•Never heard of that service before. Does it actually work or is it just another scam?
0 coins
Lilah Brooks
•It's legit - I was skeptical too but I actually got through to a real NYS Department of Labor person and got my questions answered. Way better than sitting on hold for hours.
0 coins
Kolton Murphy
The system is so messed up honestly. They make it nearly impossible to get benefits even when you have legitimate reasons for quitting. I hope your sister gets approved but don't be surprised if they deny her first and she has to appeal. That's just how they operate - deny first, ask questions later.
0 coins
Evelyn Rivera
•So true! My friend got denied twice before finally getting approved on appeal. It's like they hope you'll just give up.
0 coins
Sean O'Brien
Your sister should definitely apply - don't let her assume she's not eligible just because she quit. I work in HR and see this situation a lot. NYS Department of Labor specifically recognizes hostile work environment as good cause for quitting under Section 593 of the labor law. The key things she should gather before filing: any texts or emails showing the hostile behavior, names of coworkers who witnessed incidents, documentation of any complaints she made (even informal ones), and a detailed timeline of events. She should file as soon as possible since there's usually a waiting period anyway. Even if the initial decision takes time, she won't get benefits for weeks she doesn't claim. The worst they can say is no, but she might be surprised and get approved.
0 coins