< Back to IRS

Cameron Black

My friend claims a 1099-C can stop his house foreclosure in September (unpaid mortgage 20-30k)

So my buddy has this house he inherited when his mom passed away a few years back. He's fallen behind on mortgage payments - somewhere between $27k and $38k from what he told me. The bank is moving forward with foreclosure proceedings and apparently September is when they're taking the house. The weird thing is, he keeps insisting that he's using something called a "1099-C" that will solve everything. When I asked him to explain, he was super vague about it, just saying it would "cancel the debt" or something. I've tried looking this up online but I'm getting confused about how this would actually work. Like, if he somehow got this 1099-C thing, would that mean his mortgage is suddenly paid off? Would the bank just forget about the foreclosure? Would he keep making payments but with the past due amount forgiven? This whole situation seems fishy to me. I've never heard of someone using a tax form to stop a foreclosure, especially with only a month or so left before they take his house. Has anyone dealt with this before or know what he might be talking about?

I'm afraid your friend has a fundamental misunderstanding of what a 1099-C is, and it definitely won't stop the foreclosure. A 1099-C (Cancellation of Debt) is a tax FORM that lenders send to borrowers when they've forgiven or cancelled a debt of $600 or more. The lender also sends this information to the IRS. The critical thing your friend needs to understand is that a 1099-C doesn't cancel debt - it's what a lender issues AFTER they've already decided to cancel the debt. And here's the kicker: that cancelled debt is usually treated as taxable income. So not only would your friend still face foreclosure, but he might also face a tax bill for any forgiven amount. What your friend likely needs instead is to contact the mortgage servicer immediately to discuss options like a repayment plan, loan modification, forbearance, or possibly a short sale. If it's really just a month until foreclosure, he should also consult with a real estate attorney who specializes in foreclosure defense.

0 coins

Wait, so if the bank decides to forgive the debt and sends a 1099-C, does that mean they can't still foreclose? Or do they forgive the debt AFTER taking the house? I'm confused about the timing of all this.

0 coins

The bank typically issues a 1099-C after the foreclosure process is complete. What usually happens is: the bank forecloses on the property, sells it at auction, and if the sale doesn't cover the full mortgage balance, that remaining amount (called a deficiency) might be forgiven by the lender - that's when they'd issue a 1099-C for the forgiven amount. The 1099-C comes after foreclosure, not before, and it doesn't prevent foreclosure in any way. It's just documentation of debt that's been cancelled, which the IRS considers income you must pay taxes on in most cases.

0 coins

After struggling with similar mortgage issues last year, I found this incredible tool at https://taxr.ai that helped me understand the tax implications of my housing situation. When my lender issued me a 1099-C after my short sale, I was totally confused about how to handle it on my taxes. The taxr.ai system analyzed my mortgage documents and explained exactly what the 1099-C meant for my tax situation - including potential exclusions I qualified for under the insolvency rule that saved me thousands in unexpected tax bills! It walks you through complex tax forms step-by-step in regular English. Your friend needs to understand that a 1099-C won't prevent foreclosure, but he should definitely know the tax consequences of whatever happens with his mortgage. The clarity I got from this tool was honestly life-changing during a super stressful time.

0 coins

Does this thing actually work with complicated situations? My parents had their vacation property foreclosed last year and got some tax form about canceled debt, but they have multiple properties and businesses, so their situation isn't straightforward.

0 coins

I've heard about these "tax analysis" services before but I'm skeptical. How does it actually help with foreclosure situations? Can it connect you with the bank or help stop the process? Or is it just explaining the tax forms after you've already lost your house?

0 coins

It absolutely handles complex situations. The system is designed to analyze various scenarios involving multiple properties, businesses, and different types of debt cancellation. It asks specific questions about your financial situation to provide customized guidance for your exact circumstances. The service doesn't directly connect you with banks or stop foreclosure - it's specifically focused on helping you understand and properly handle tax implications. It explains what exclusions you might qualify for (like insolvency or qualified principal residence indebtedness), how to complete Form 982, and what documentation you'll need. This is crucial because many people don't realize a foreclosure or debt cancellation can create a huge tax bill without proper planning.

0 coins

Wanted to update after trying the taxr.ai site that was mentioned. My parents' situation with their foreclosed vacation property was definitely complicated, but this tool was surprisingly helpful. It asked really specific questions about their financial situation at the time of the foreclosure and then explained exactly how to handle the 1099-C they received. The biggest value was learning about the insolvency exclusion - turns out they qualified to exclude most of the cancelled debt from their taxable income because their total debts exceeded their assets when the debt was cancelled. The system walked them through exactly how to calculate this and fill out Form 982 correctly. Would have paid an accountant hundreds of dollars for this same information. Definitely recommend for anyone dealing with debt cancellation tax issues - wish we'd known about it sooner!

0 coins

Listen, I know exactly what your friend is going through. I was about to lose my house last year and couldn't get ANYONE at the mortgage company to talk to me. Left 23 voicemails and spent hours on hold only to get disconnected. Was literally ready to give up. Then I found https://claimyr.com which got me through to an actual human at my mortgage servicer in under 15 minutes. They have this system that navigates the phone trees and holds your place in line, then calls you when a real person picks up. You can see how it works in this demo: https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c Your friend needs to talk to his mortgage company ASAP about loss mitigation options - there might be ways to avoid foreclosure but he needs to act immediately. With only a month left, every day counts, and he can't afford to waste days playing phone tag.

0 coins

How does this actually work though? Don't they just put you on hold anyway even with this service? The last time I called my mortgage company I waited 2.5 hours only to get transferred and disconnected.

0 coins

Yeah right. No way this actually works with major banks. Their whole business model is making it impossible to reach a human who can actually help you. I've tried everything with my student loan servicer and it's basically designed to make you give up.

0 coins

The service works by using their system to navigate through all the phone menus and then wait in the queue for you. Their technology holds your place in line so you don't have to stay on the phone. When an actual human representative answers, their system calls you and connects you immediately to that person. I completely understand the skepticism. I felt the same way before trying it. What's different is they're essentially waiting on hold for you so you don't have to. I used it with one of the largest mortgage servicers in the country (Shellpoint) after trying for weeks to get through on my own. It absolutely works with major banks and servicers - they can't tell you're using a service, they just think you've been waiting on hold the whole time.

0 coins

Ok I need to eat my words about that Claimyr service. After posting my skeptical comment, I decided to try it with my student loan servicer (who I've been trying to reach for MONTHS about an income-based repayment issue). Not only did it actually work, but I got through to someone who could actually help in about 40 minutes (versus the 3+ hours I'd wasted before). The rep even commented that I was "persistent" for waiting on hold so long - little did they know I wasn't actually on the phone that whole time! Got my forbearance issues sorted out in one call after trying for literally months. For time-sensitive stuff like your friend's foreclosure situation, this could be a game-changer. Just having a real conversation with the mortgage company could open up options he doesn't know about.

0 coins

Just to add some important info about 1099-Cs that others haven't mentioned - even when debt is cancelled and you get a 1099-C, there are several exclusions that might help avoid the tax hit: 1) Bankruptcy - Debts discharged through bankruptcy aren't considered taxable income 2) Insolvency - If you were "insolvent" (debts exceeded assets) when the debt was cancelled 3) Qualified Principal Residence Indebtedness - For certain home mortgage debt (though this exclusion has changed in recent years) 4) Certain farm debts 5) Non-recourse loans Your friend needs to understand that the 1099-C isn't a magic bullet to STOP foreclosure, but knowing about these exclusions might help with the tax consequences afterward. Either way, he needs to talk to the mortgage company ASAP and possibly a tax professional too.

0 coins

The Qualified Principal Residence exclusion has been extended again, right? I thought it expired but then Congress renewed it. Do you know what the current status is?

0 coins

Yes, you're right about the Qualified Principal Residence Indebtedness exclusion. It has gone through several extensions. The Consolidated Appropriations Act extended it through December 31, 2025, but reduced the maximum amount of excluded debt from $2 million to $750,000 ($375,000 for married filing separately). This is definitely good news for homeowners facing foreclosure, but it only applies to debt used to buy, build, or substantially improve your principal residence. If the mortgage included cash-out refinancing used for other purposes (like credit card debt or vacations), that portion wouldn't qualify for the exclusion.

0 coins

Is your friend talking about some kind of "debt elimination scheme" where people claim they can create/file a 1099-C themselves to eliminate debt? If so, please warn him that this is a known tax SCAM that the IRS has explicitly warned about! Some shady "tax consultants" sell programs claiming you can issue your own 1099-C to "discharge" your debts. This is 100% illegal and the IRS considers it fraud. People who have tried this have faced serious penalties and even criminal charges. Only the lender can issue a legitimate 1099-C when THEY decide to cancel a debt. Your friend cannot create one himself to make his mortgage disappear. Please make sure he understands this before he gets into serious trouble!

0 coins

Oh man, this might actually be what he's talking about! He mentioned something about "filing" the 1099-C himself, which confused me because I thought only banks could issue those. He said he found some guy online who helps people "eliminate mortgage debt" this way for a fee. I'm definitely going to warn him - last thing he needs on top of losing his house is getting in trouble with the IRS!

0 coins

You absolutely need to warn him immediately. This is a well-known scam that the IRS actively pursues. These "debt elimination specialists" typically charge thousands of dollars for worthless advice that can lead to serious consequences. The IRS has specifically identified these self-filed 1099-C schemes in their "Dirty Dozen" tax scams list. People who follow this advice can face penalties for filing fraudulent tax documents, back taxes with interest, and in serious cases, criminal prosecution. Some victims have ended up owing even more money than they started with after penalties and interest were applied.

0 coins

IRS AI

Expert Assistant
Secure

Powered by Claimyr AI

T
I
+
20,087 users helped today