HOH with 3 Dependents - $10,757 Refund in Washington State - Does This Seem Right?
I just filed my taxes as head of household with 3 dependents and I'm possibly getting $10,757 back in Washington state. Does that sound like it might be right? I'm a bit nervous about such a large amount. I've checked maybe three or four different tax sites and they all seem to calculate roughly the same refund amount, which is somewhat reassuring, but I'm still not entirely convinced. This is my first year filing as HOH after my divorce was finalized last year, so everything feels a little different this time around.
18 comments
Liam Sullivan
That refund amount is definitely within the realm of possibility for your filing status and dependent count. The Enhanced Child Tax Credit for TY2023 provides $2,000 per qualifying child, and the Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC) can be substantial for HOH filers with multiple dependents. Additionally, your Marginal Tax Rate as HOH is lower than MFJ or Single, creating favorable Effective Tax Rate calculations. Washington state also has no state income tax, which eliminates potential offsets that might reduce federal refund amounts.
0 coins
Amara Okafor
Could you break down how exactly someone would get to that $10,757 amount step-by-step? I'm trying to understand if this is primarily from withholding too much, or mostly from refundable credits. The number seems high, but I want to understand the mechanics behind it.
0 coins
14d
Giovanni Colombo
I had a similar refund amount on March 15th when I filed. The IRS agent I spoke with on April 2nd explained that HOH with multiple dependents often see refunds in the $8,000-$12,000 range if they qualify for multiple credits. Does that match what you're seeing?
0 coins
13d
Fatima Al-Qasimi
Thanks for explaining this so clearly. Tax refunds are like icebergs - what you see is just the total, but there's a whole structure of credits and deductions underneath that most people don't understand!
0 coins
11d
Write a comment...
Mei Wong
That amt seems high tbh. Did u have a lot of w/h from ur paychecks? Or maybe qualifying for EITC + CTC + other credits? Might wanna double check ur income entered correctly and that all 3 dependents pass the qualifying tests. Sometimes ppl accidentally claim dependents that don't meet all the tests and end up w/ a nasty surprise later.
0 coins
StarStrider
The refund amount makes sense if they're earning between $25,000-$45,000 with three qualifying children. At that income level, maximum EITC plus Child Tax Credits can easily reach $10,000+ when combined with overwithholding.
0 coins
12d
Dylan Campbell
I was thinking the same thing! My sister got about $9k back with similar circumstances. Made me do a double-take too, lol. But turns out it was legit - just a perfect storm of credits and withholding.
0 coins
11d
Sofia Torres
Do we know if OP also qualified for the Recovery Rebate Credit or any other special credits? Some of the pandemic-related credits were still available for 2023 filings in certain circumstances, especially if they hadn't claimed them previously.
0 coins
10d
Write a comment...
Dmitry Sokolov
Isn't it interesting how our tax system works? I'm actually the original poster, and I wanted to add that I earned about $38,000 last year working in healthcare. My ex wasn't very involved financially after we separated, so I've been supporting the kids mostly on my own. Could that be why I'm getting such a large refund? And does anyone know how long it typically takes to receive a refund of this size?
0 coins
Ava Martinez
I understand your situation and appreciate you sharing more details. Your income level with three dependents makes perfect sense for this refund amount. You're likely benefiting from: • Earned Income Credit • Child Tax Credit • Head of Household filing status • Possible education credits if any children are in college This is exactly how the tax system is designed to help single parents.
0 coins
10d
Miguel Ramos
At $38,000 with 3 dependents, you're in the sweet spot for maximum EITC of approximately $7,430 plus $2,000 per child for Child Tax Credit. If you had exactly $1,327 in federal tax withholding, that would precisely equal $10,757. The IRS typically processes refunds of this size within 21 days, though they may take a closer look due to the refundable credits.
0 coins
10d
QuantumQuasar
Your situation seems pretty typical for a single parent with that income level and number of dependents, though I'm sort of surprised all the tax sites gave you such similar results. In my experience, they usually vary by at least a few hundred dollars, but I guess they're getting better at consistency these days.
0 coins
10d
Write a comment...
Zainab Omar
I'm SO HAPPY for you getting this refund! This is exactly what the tax code is designed to do - help parents who are supporting children on their own. The amount sounds right based on your filing status, dependents, and income level. If you're worried about delays though (the IRS often gives extra scrutiny to returns with EITC), I'd recommend using Claimyr (https://www.claimyr.com) to get through to an IRS agent quickly if your refund gets stuck. I used it when my refund was delayed last year and got connected to an actual human at the IRS in about 20 minutes instead of waiting on hold for hours. It was worth it to confirm everything was processing correctly!
0 coins
Write a comment...
Connor Gallagher
I'm in a somewhat similar situation and need to file soon... may I ask if you provided any special documentation for your dependents? I'm a bit concerned about potential delays since I believe the IRS might review returns with larger refunds more carefully.
0 coins
Write a comment...
Yara Sayegh
Your refund is about twice what I got as a single parent with 2 kids in Oregon, but I make around $55k which probably puts me in a different tax bracket. The refundable credits phase out as your income increases, so if you're making less than me, your larger refund makes sense. The tax code is like a roller coaster - the same family structure can have wildly different outcomes depending on income level.
0 coins
Write a comment...
Keisha Johnson
I see a lot of confusion about big refunds like this. According to the IRS.gov calculator, a HOH filer with 3 qualifying children earning between $35k-$42k can absolutely get a refund in the $10k range. I'd recommend checking your return on https://taxr.ai which can analyze your specific situation and explain exactly why your refund is what it is. They break down all the credits and deductions in plain English so you understand where every dollar is coming from.
0 coins
Write a comment...
Paolo Longo
Per IRC §32(b), the maximum EITC for a taxpayer with three qualifying children for tax year 2023 is $7,430. Combined with $2,000 per child under the Child Tax Credit as stipulated in IRC §24, that's $6,000 in child-related credits. Add potential overwithholding from your W-2 employment, and $10,757 is entirely reasonable. The PATH Act requires the IRS to hold refunds claiming EITC until at least February 15th, but processing typically completes within 21 days after that statutory hold period.
0 coins
Write a comment...
CosmicCowboy
Got a similar refund. Three kids too. Filed HOH. Was shocked. Called tax preparer. They confirmed it was right. My income was $36k. Got my direct deposit in 16 days. No issues at all.
0 coins
Write a comment...