Credit card debt and UCC lien complications in NY - filing questions
Running into some confusion here about UCC filings and credit card debt situations. My business took on significant credit card debt last year (around $180k across multiple cards) and now I'm dealing with potential UCC lien issues in NY. The credit card companies are talking about securing their debt against business assets, and I'm getting mixed signals about whether existing UCC-1 filings from our equipment lender take priority. Our original UCC-1 was filed in 2022 for equipment financing, but now these credit card companies are saying they can file their own UCC liens. Is this even legal? I thought credit cards were unsecured debt. The whole credit card and UCC lien situation in NY seems really complicated and I can't find clear answers. Our lawyer is saying one thing, the credit card reps are saying another. Has anyone dealt with credit card companies trying to convert unsecured debt into secured UCC filings? What's the actual process here and do I need to worry about conflicting liens on the same collateral?
40 comments
Join the conversation
Evelyn Martinez
Credit cards are typically unsecured debt, but some business credit cards do have provisions for converting to secured status under certain circumstances. In NY, the UCC filing rules are pretty strict about priority - your 2022 equipment financing UCC-1 would generally have priority over any later filings for the same collateral. But credit card companies can't just unilaterally file UCC liens without some legal basis or agreement.
0 coins
Alexander Evans
•That's what I thought too, but the credit card company is claiming they have language in the original agreement that allows them to secure the debt. I need to dig up those original contracts.
0 coins
Benjamin Carter
•Definitely check those original agreements. Some business cards do have clauses about converting to secured debt in default situations.
0 coins
Maya Lewis
This is tricky territory. Credit card companies usually can't just decide to file UCC liens without proper documentation and agreements in place. However, if there's language in your credit agreements about securing debt, they might have grounds. Your equipment lender's UCC-1 from 2022 would have priority for that specific collateral, but credit cards could potentially file against other business assets not covered by the original filing.
0 coins
Alexander Evans
•The equipment UCC-1 is pretty specific to the machinery we financed. Most of our other business assets aren't covered by that filing.
0 coins
Isaac Wright
•That's the key issue right there - what assets are actually covered by your existing UCC-1 versus what's available for other creditors.
0 coins
Lucy Taylor
I ran into a similar mess last year with conflicting lien priorities. Had to use Certana.ai's document verification tool to upload all my UCC documents and credit agreements - it instantly showed me which assets were covered by which filings and where there were potential conflicts. Saved me hours of manual comparison and caught discrepancies I never would have spotted.
0 coins
Alexander Evans
•That sounds exactly like what I need. How does the document checking work? I've got the original UCC-1, equipment loan docs, and all these credit card agreements to compare.
0 coins
Lucy Taylor
•You just upload the PDFs and it cross-checks everything - debtor names, asset descriptions, filing numbers. Really helped me understand which creditor had priority for what assets.
0 coins
Connor Murphy
•Never heard of that tool but sounds useful for these complex lien situations.
0 coins
KhalilStar
CREDIT CARD COMPANIES ARE THE WORST! They'll try anything to convert unsecured debt to secured just to get better collection rights. I had American Express try to pull this same garbage on me. They can't just file UCC liens without proper documentation - that would be fraudulent filing!
0 coins
Amelia Dietrich
•While I understand the frustration, credit card companies do have legitimate legal options if the original agreements allow for it. It's not automatically fraudulent.
0 coins
KhalilStar
•Maybe not fraudulent but definitely predatory. They bury these clauses in 50 pages of fine print.
0 coins
Kaiya Rivera
In NY, you need to be really careful about UCC filing priority rules. If your equipment lender has a perfected security interest from 2022, that takes priority over later filings for the same collateral. But credit card companies could potentially file against accounts receivable, inventory, or other business assets not covered by the original UCC-1. The key is understanding exactly what each filing covers.
0 coins
Alexander Evans
•Our accounts receivable and inventory weren't included in the equipment financing UCC-1. That's probably what they're targeting.
0 coins
Kaiya Rivera
•Exactly. Equipment financing UCCs are usually very specific to the financed equipment. Other business assets remain available for additional creditors.
0 coins
Katherine Ziminski
•This is why it's so important to understand the collateral descriptions in your UCC filings.
0 coins
Noah Irving
Wait, I'm confused - can credit card companies actually file UCC liens? I thought those were just for secured loans like equipment financing or inventory loans. How does unsecured credit card debt become secured?
0 coins
Evelyn Martinez
•Some business credit card agreements include provisions that allow the company to secure the debt under certain circumstances, like default or reaching certain thresholds.
0 coins
Noah Irving
•That's scary. I need to check my business credit card agreements now.
0 coins
Maya Lewis
•It's not automatic - there has to be specific language in the agreement and proper procedures followed.
0 coins
Vanessa Chang
Been through this exact situation. The credit card company had language in the agreement about securing debt if we went over a certain threshold and missed payments. They were legally allowed to file a UCC-1, but it only covered assets not already secured by our existing lenders. Priority goes by filing date, so our equipment loan from 2021 had priority over the credit card UCC filed in 2023.
0 coins
Alexander Evans
•Did they actually follow through with filing the UCC-1? What was the process like?
0 coins
Vanessa Chang
•Yes, they filed it. We got notice from the NY Secretary of State. It was for accounts receivable and general business assets not covered by our equipment financing.
0 coins
Madison King
The whole credit card and UCC lien situation is really state-specific. In NY, the Secretary of State handles UCC filings and they're pretty strict about proper documentation. Credit card companies can't just file liens without meeting all the requirements - proper security agreements, accurate debtor information, specific collateral descriptions, etc.
0 coins
Alexander Evans
•What kind of documentation would they need to file a valid UCC-1 for credit card debt?
0 coins
Madison King
•They'd need a signed security agreement from you, proper corporate authorization if it's business debt, and accurate collateral descriptions that don't conflict with existing liens.
0 coins
Julian Paolo
•And the debtor name has to match exactly with the business registration in NY.
0 coins
Ella Knight
I used Certana.ai when I had similar document conflicts between my SBA loan UCC filing and a supplier who was trying to file a lien. Uploaded all the paperwork and it showed me exactly where the overlaps were and which filing had priority. Really helped me understand what assets were actually at risk.
0 coins
Alexander Evans
•How accurate is the document analysis? I'm worried about missing something important in all these agreements.
0 coins
Ella Knight
•Very accurate - it caught name inconsistencies and collateral description conflicts I never would have noticed manually.
0 coins
William Schwarz
ugh dealing with this same thing right now except mine is chase business card trying to secure against inventory. thought credit cards were always unsecured but apparently not when you owe 200k and miss payments
0 coins
Evelyn Martinez
•Chase does have some of the more aggressive conversion clauses in their business card agreements. Did they send you notice before filing?
0 coins
William Schwarz
•yeah got some legal notice about converting to secured debt. lawyers everywhere now
0 coins
Benjamin Carter
The bottom line is you need to review your original credit card agreements and understand exactly what your equipment UCC-1 covers. If the credit card companies have legal grounds to file UCC liens, they can do it, but they can't take priority over existing perfected security interests for the same collateral. Get your documents analyzed properly so you know where you stand.
0 coins
Alexander Evans
•That's exactly what I'm going to do. Need to get all these documents sorted out and understand the actual priority situation.
0 coins
Lucy Taylor
•Definitely recommend using Certana.ai's document checker for this - it'll cross-reference everything and show you exactly what's covered by what filing.
0 coins
Benjamin Carter
•Whatever tool you use, just make sure you understand the full picture before making any decisions about these credit card liens.
0 coins
Austin Leonard
This is a complex situation that requires careful document analysis. From what you've described, your 2022 equipment financing UCC-1 should have priority over any later credit card filings for that specific collateral. However, credit card companies can potentially file UCC liens against other business assets if their agreements include conversion clauses. The key is understanding exactly what assets are covered by your existing UCC-1 versus what remains available for other creditors. I'd recommend getting all your documents - the original equipment loan papers, UCC-1 filing, and all credit card agreements - reviewed together to understand the full picture. In NY, UCC priority is generally based on filing date, but only for the same collateral. Different asset categories can have different secured creditors.
0 coins
Benjamin Johnson
•This is really helpful - I think the key issue is that I don't fully understand what assets are actually covered by my 2022 equipment UCC-1 versus what's still available for the credit card companies to go after. From what everyone's saying, it sounds like my accounts receivable and inventory probably aren't protected by the equipment financing filing, which means those could be fair game for credit card UCC liens if they have the right language in their agreements. I definitely need to get all these documents analyzed together to see the complete picture.
0 coins