< Back to FAFSA

Eleanor Foster

Parents' identity theft issue delaying tax filing - Will this ruin my FAFSA deadline and financial aid chances?

I'm in a complete panic about my FAFSA application for 2025-2026. My parents have this major complication with their taxes that I just found out about - they were victims of identity theft years ago and now have to file their taxes through this complicated identity theft affidavit process. They can't e-file, have to submit everything in person, and worst of all, processing takes like 6+ MONTHS! They haven't even filed their 2022 taxes yet (which I need for the FAFSA) and most of my college application deadlines are January 31st. I originally thought "no big deal, they can just file now" but with this identity verification nightmare, there's zero chance their tax return will be processed in time. Is there any way to get a FAFSA extension because of this situation? And if I did somehow get an extension, would I still be eligible for priority consideration? I'm terrified I'll miss out on scholarships and grants even though I'd normally qualify for decent aid (family income around $120k, and I have really strong academic stats). Does anyone know if there are special provisions for situations like identity theft? Or am I completely screwed for the upcoming academic year? I've worked so hard to get into my dream schools and now this tax situation might ruin everything!

Lucas Turner

•

Don't panic yet! You actually have options in this situation. For the 2025-2026 FAFSA, you can submit what's called a "special circumstance" documentation. The FSA (Federal Student Aid) office has specific provisions for victims of identity theft. You'll need to gather documentation of your parents' identity theft situation - the affidavit they file with the IRS, any police reports they filed, correspondence about the identity theft, etc. Then contact your schools' financial aid offices directly. Each school handles these situations differently, but most have procedures in place. Be aware that while you can submit FAFSA without the processed tax return using estimated figures, you'll eventually need to verify that information once their taxes are processed. The key is proactive communication with each financial aid office.

0 coins

Thank you so much for this info! Will calling the financial aid offices work or do I need to request these special circumstances in writing? I'm also wondering if I need to file the FAFSA with estimated figures first and THEN talk to the financial aid offices, or contact them before even submitting anything?

0 coins

Kai Rivera

•

ur not screwed but u need 2 act fast!! my brother had something similar (not ID theft but my dad had tax problems) and he still got aid BUT he had to do all this extra paperwork. call every school ur applying to ASAP and tell them whats happening. some might give u a form to fill out 4 special circumstances. also u should still submit the FAFSA on time even if u have to use estimated numbers! u can fix it later

0 coins

That's good to hear your brother wasn't completely out of luck! Did he end up getting less aid than he might have otherwise? That's my big fear - that even if I can submit something, I'll get pushed to the bottom of the pile for scholarships and grants.

0 coins

Anna Stewart

•

This is actually quite a common scenario! I work in financial aid, and here's what you need to know: 1. File your FAFSA by the priority deadline using ESTIMATED income figures. Check the box indicating this information is estimated. 2. Immediately contact each school's financial aid office to explain the identity theft situation. Request their "Income Verification" or "Special Circumstances" form. 3. Most schools will put a hold on your file rather than deny aid outright. 4. Gather documentation: the IRS identity theft affidavit (Form 14039), any police reports, FTC identity theft reports, and correspondence with IRS. 5. You'll likely need to complete an Income Verification form with your best-faith estimates. You won't lose priority consideration if you file on time with estimates and communicate proactively. Schools have procedures for these situations and won't penalize students for parents' identity theft issues.

0 coins

This is incredibly helpful, thank you! One more question - for the estimated income, should I use their W-2s from 2022 (which they have but just haven't filed with IRS) or should I use their 2021 tax return (the last one that was successfully processed)?

0 coins

Anna Stewart

•

Use the 2022 W-2s for more accurate estimates since the FAFSA specifically requires 2022 tax year information. Also gather any 1099s or other income documentation they might have for 2022. This gets you closest to what the actual tax return would show. Keep in mind you'll need to update this information once their tax return is finally processed, but having accurate W-2 based estimates will minimize any major surprises or adjustments later. Make copies of everything for your records before submitting!

0 coins

Layla Sanders

•

dude u are DEF screwed!!!! my cousin went thru something like this and ended up with ZERO financial aid bc he missed the priority deadline. schools don't care WHY u missed it just that u did. especially with ur stats u would've gotten good money but now...good luck getting anything. the system is totally broken and favors people who can file everything perfectly on time. so unfair!!

0 coins

Anna Stewart

•

This information is simply incorrect. Schools absolutely consider extenuating circumstances like identity theft, which is documented through official IRS procedures. The financial aid process has specific provisions for these situations. Please don't spread misinformation that causes unnecessary panic.

0 coins

Layla Sanders

•

whatever. maybe my cousin's school just sucked then but he definitely got screwed over for something that wasn't his fault. not saying it'll happen to everyone but people should know the system isn't perfect

0 coins

Have you tried reaching Federal Student Aid directly? I was in a somewhat similar situation a few months ago (not identity theft but another tax complication) and spent DAYS trying to get through to someone at the FSA office. Kept getting disconnected or facing hour-long wait times. I ended up using a service called Claimyr (claimyr.com) which helped me get through to an actual FSA agent without the endless waiting. They have a video showing how it works: https://youtu.be/TbC8dZQWYNQ The FSA agent I spoke with was able to document my situation and gave me specific instructions for my application. They can make notes on your FAFSA application about the identity theft situation so schools see it. Definitely worth talking to them directly in addition to contacting individual schools.

0 coins

Kai Rivera

•

omg those FSA wait times are THE WORST!! will check out that video bc i legit hung up after waiting 2hrs last time i tried calling them 😩

0 coins

Thanks for this suggestion! I didn't even consider trying to contact FSA directly, but that makes sense. Getting an official note on my application would probably help a lot. I'll check out that link because honestly, I don't have time to spend days on hold right now with application deadlines coming up.

0 coins

Kaylee Cook

•

The EXACT same thing happened to me last year!!! My dad had his identity stolen and all the tax nightmare that came with it. It was super stressful but here's what worked for me: - I got a letter from the IRS confirming the identity theft case (took about 2 weeks but worth it) - Submitted the FAFSA with estimated info (used his W-2s) - Got a letter from my dad's accountant explaining the situation - Hand-delivered all this to my top choice schools' financial aid offices I DID still qualify for priority aid at 3 of my 5 schools. The other two required additional verification but eventually came through with decent packages. Also make sure your parents start filing their 2023 taxes ASAP since you might need those for verification later in the process. The whole system is MADDENING but you're not alone and there ARE procedures for this!!!!

0 coins

Wow, it's such a relief to hear from someone who went through almost exactly the same thing! Getting the letter from the IRS is a great idea. Did you have to make appointments at the financial aid offices to hand-deliver everything, or did you just show up? I'm trying to figure out the most efficient way to handle this with multiple schools.

0 coins

Kaylee Cook

•

I made appointments at 2 schools and just showed up at the others. DEFINITELY make appointments if you can - the walk-in wait times were crazy and the appointments got me face time with actual financial aid counselors instead of just front desk staff. Those meetings were super helpful because they could look at my specific situation and tell me exactly what they needed. Good luck!!!

0 coins

just wondering why your parents havent filed taxes for so long? identity theft or not thats kinda a big deal and the irs probably isnt happy about that... not judging just saying maybe theres bigger issues here than just fafsa

0 coins

I probably didn't explain well - they DO file taxes every year, but the process is extremely complicated and time-consuming because of the identity theft protocols. Each year takes months longer than normal, and according to my mom, it's a complete nightmare dealing with all the extra verification steps. So they're always behind schedule compared to normal tax filers.

0 coins

Lucas Turner

•

One more important thing: make sure you understand how the SAI (Student Aid Index) will be calculated with estimated figures. Your family income of $120k puts you in a particular range, but the SAI formula also considers assets, number of family members in college, and other factors. When you submit estimated figures, try to be as accurate as possible because significant changes later could affect your aid packages. Schools may place your file in a "verification" status, which is standard procedure - don't panic if this happens. Also, keep in mind that for many schools, missing the priority deadline impacts institutional aid more than federal aid. You'll still be eligible for federal programs even with a later filing, but some school-specific scholarships have stricter deadlines.

0 coins

This is a really good point about the SAI calculation. My parents do have some investments, and my younger sister will be starting college in two years. Should I be including all of that information in my initial FAFSA with estimates, or focus just on getting the income parts right first?

0 coins

Lucas Turner

•

Include ALL the information - income, assets, family members, etc. - in your initial FAFSA submission. The SAI calculation uses all these factors, and providing complete information gives you the most accurate initial estimate. Only the income figures would be considered estimates in your case. Especially make sure to note your sister will be in college in two years, as having multiple family members in college significantly impacts your SAI calculation (usually favorably). You want your initial application to be as complete and accurate as possible outside of the estimated tax information.

0 coins

Kai Rivera

•

wait ur parents make 120k and u think ull get good aid?? lol maybe at like harvard or smth but most places will give u squat with that income js

0 coins

Lara Woods

•

That's not necessarily true. $120k for a family of 4+ doesn't go as far as people think, especially in high-cost areas. And many schools now meet full demonstrated need. My family income was similar and I got decent aid packages from several schools. It really depends on the individual schools and their financial aid policies.

0 coins

We're actually a family of 5 with some medical expenses, so our EFC/SAI has been pretty reasonable in the net price calculators I've tried. I know we're not getting full rides, but several of my target schools have good aid for middle-income families.

0 coins

Omar Fawaz

•

I'm sorry you're dealing with this stressful situation! Identity theft complications are more common than you might think, and schools are generally understanding about these circumstances. Here's my advice as someone who went through a similar process: 1. Document everything NOW - get copies of the IRS Identity Theft Affidavit (Form 14039), any correspondence with the IRS about the identity verification process, and police reports if they filed any. 2. Contact each school's financial aid office BEFORE submitting your FAFSA. Explain the situation and ask about their specific procedures for identity theft cases. Many have special forms or processes. 3. Submit your FAFSA with estimated figures using your parents' 2022 W-2s and other available documents. Mark clearly that these are estimates due to the identity theft situation. 4. Keep detailed records of all communications with schools and the IRS - you'll likely need to reference these multiple times throughout the process. The good news is that this won't automatically disqualify you from aid or priority consideration if you're proactive about communication. Schools deal with these situations regularly and have procedures in place. The key is being transparent and organized with your documentation. Don't let this derail your college plans - you have options!

0 coins

FAFSA AI

Expert Assistant
Secure

Powered by Claimyr AI

T
I
+
20,087 users helped today