My FAFSA SAI score is -1500 - is this good for financial aid eligibility?
Just got my Student Aid Index (SAI) back from my FAFSA application and it shows -1500. I have no idea if this is good, bad, or what it even means for financial aid. I'm a first-gen college student so I'm figuring this all out on my own. Will this score get me decent aid for state universities? My EFC from last year was around 1200 if that helps for comparison. Anyone know what aid I might qualify for with this number?
26 comments


KingKongZilla
Congrats! A negative SAI is actually really good news for financial aid. The lower your SAI (and negative is as low as it gets), the more financial aid you'll likely receive. With -1500, you should qualify for the maximum Pell Grant amount for 2025-2026 (currently around $7,400/year), and you'll likely be eligible for significant institutional aid at most colleges. Remember that each school has their own formula for distributing institutional aid, but having a negative SAI puts you in an excellent position. Make sure you check each school's financial aid website to see if they require additional forms like the CSS Profile for institutional aid.
0 coins
Bethany Groves
•Omg thank you!! That's a huge relief. I had no idea what these numbers meant. So negative is better than my old EFC which was positive? Do I automatically get the Pell Grant or do I need to apply for it separately?
0 coins
Rebecca Johnston
An SAI of -1500 is great! But don't just assume you'll get everything automatically. Here's what to do next: 1. Check your Student Aid Report (SAR) for any flags requiring verification - about 30% of applications get selected for this 2. Contact each school's financial aid office to confirm they received your FAFSA data 3. Watch for aid award letters from each school - they'll detail grants, loans, work-study 4. Some private schools require the CSS Profile too - check their websites With that SAI, you're eligible for maximum Pell Grant, but institutional aid varies widely between schools. Some might offer you nearly full rides while others will still expect significant contribution.
0 coins
Bethany Groves
•This is super helpful! I just checked and I do have to submit verification docs. Ugh. Is there a deadline for that? I'm applying to 5 schools and wondering if I need to send verification stuff to all of them or just my top choice?
0 coins
Nathan Dell
My SAI was -900 last year and I got full Pell + state grants + some institutional scholarships. You're in good shape with -1500! Just make sure u dont mess up verification if u get selected for it, that held up my aid for like 2 months lol
0 coins
Bethany Groves
•Thanks! How did you know you were selected for verification? Did they email you or was it on the FAFSA site?
0 coins
Maya Jackson
The negative SAI is excellent, but be prepared for verification headaches. I've been dealing with FAFSA for 15+ years as both a student and parent. The new FAFSA system has been a nightmare for verification. My daughter has an SAI of -2000 and has been stuck in verification for 8 weeks! We've submitted documents THREE times. My advice: call FSA directly to check your verification status every couple weeks. You'll probably get disconnected 10+ times trying to reach them. The whole system is broken.
0 coins
Tristan Carpenter
•omg same!! ive been calling for WEEKS and either get disconnected or wait for hours. this whole process is insane
0 coins
Amaya Watson
I was having the same issue trying to reach someone at Federal Student Aid about my verification. Kept getting disconnected or waiting for hours. Someone on my campus recommended using Claimyr to get through to an agent. You can see how it works at https://youtu.be/TbC8dZQWYNQ - it helped me finally talk to someone after weeks of trying. I was able to confirm my verification documents were received and find out when they'd be processed. Definitely worth checking out if you get stuck in verification limbo at claimyr.com
0 coins
Bethany Groves
•Thank you! I just checked my status and I am selected for verification so I might need this. How long did it take to get through once you used it?
0 coins
Amaya Watson
•Got through in about 10 minutes instead of hours of waiting and disconnects. Just had my phone nearby and they called when an agent was available. Much better than the endless hold music!
0 coins
Grant Vikers
a negative SAI is the best u can get!! my brother had -2000 and got full tuition at state school plus housing grant. Each school has different aid tho so wait for all ur offers before deciding
0 coins
Bethany Groves
•That's amazing! Did he apply to multiple schools? I'm wondering if I should apply to more than 5 to compare financial aid packages.
0 coins
Maya Jackson
One important thing to remember: your SAI of -1500 is great for federal aid like Pell Grants, but some colleges have their own institutional methodology that might calculate your need differently. If you're considering private colleges, many use the CSS Profile which digs deeper into your finances and may result in a different expected contribution amount. Also, not all colleges meet 100% of demonstrated need. Some may leave a gap between what they think you can pay and the aid they offer. Always ask each financial aid office what their "average percentage of need met" is for freshmen.
0 coins
Bethany Groves
•I didn't even consider that! I am looking at one private college that might be a reach financially. Is the CSS Profile free or is there a cost to submit it?
0 coins
Maya Jackson
•The CSS Profile has a fee of $25 for the first school and $16 for each additional school. They do offer fee waivers for students with financial need. Given your SAI, you might qualify for the waiver. Check the College Board website for details on how to request it.
0 coins
Nathan Dell
btw the new system is way different from last year! the old EFC (expected family contribution) and new SAI (student aid index) use different calculations. so ur old EFC of 1200 vs new SAI of -1500 aren't directly comparable. negative is definitely better tho!!
0 coins
Giovanni Martello
•This is correct! The new SAI calculation is different and allows for negative values down to -1500, while the old EFC could never go below 0. The change better identifies students with the highest financial need.
0 coins
Tristan Carpenter
im so confused with this whole system!! my SAI is 5500 and my friends is -750 but we have similar family situations?? how does this even work????
0 coins
Rebecca Johnston
•The new FAFSA has some significant calculation changes. Key factors that can create these differences include: number of family members in college simultaneously, whether you qualify as independent or dependent, specific income thresholds that trigger different formulas, and how retirement assets are counted. Small differences in these areas can create very different SAI results. I'd recommend using the FAFSA comparison tool on studentaid.gov to understand why your calculations differ so much.
0 coins
Bethany Groves
UPDATE: I called my top choice school's financial aid office today and they confirmed that with my -1500 SAI, I'll qualify for their full need-based institutional grant PLUS the federal Pell Grant! This would cover almost everything except about $3,000 per year which they said could be covered by work-study and small loans if needed. Thanks everyone for your help explaining this!
0 coins
KingKongZilla
•That's fantastic news! So glad it worked out well for you. Just make sure to keep an eye on your verification status if you were selected, and remember you'll need to submit a new FAFSA each year to maintain your aid eligibility. Best of luck with your college journey!
0 coins
Malik Davis
That's amazing news, Bethany! You're so lucky to have found a school that meets full need with institutional grants. Just a heads up - make sure to ask them about their aid renewal requirements. Some schools require you to maintain a certain GPA or complete a minimum number of credit hours each semester to keep your institutional grants. Also, if your family's financial situation changes significantly (like a parent gets a new job or loses one), your aid could be recalculated, so it's worth understanding their appeal process too. Congratulations on getting such great aid!
0 coins
Logan Stewart
•This is such great advice! I didn't even think about GPA requirements or what happens if my family's income changes. I'll definitely ask about their renewal criteria when I visit campus next month. Do you know if most schools have similar requirements or does it vary a lot between institutions?
0 coins
Emma Johnson
Your -1500 SAI is excellent! As a newcomer here, I just wanted to add that you should also look into state-specific grants in addition to the Pell Grant. Many states have their own need-based aid programs that stack on top of federal aid, and with your SAI you'd likely qualify for maximum amounts. Also, don't forget to check if any of your target schools participate in programs like the Yellow Ribbon Program (if you have military connections) or have special first-generation college student support programs that might offer additional funding or resources. It sounds like you're already on the right track by calling schools directly - that personal contact can make a huge difference in understanding your full aid picture!
0 coins
Miguel Alvarez
•Thanks for mentioning state grants! I hadn't really looked into those yet. Do you know if I need to apply separately for state aid or does submitting the FAFSA automatically put me in consideration? Also, what's the Yellow Ribbon Program? I don't have military connections but I'm curious what other programs might be out there for first-gen students like me.
0 coins