< Back to FAFSA

Zainab Khalil

FAFSA gave me a 40k+ SAI score - did I make huge mistakes on my form?

I just checked my Student Aid Index (SAI) score after submitting my FAFSA for 2025-2026 and nearly had a heart attack when I saw it's over $40,000! That seems insanely high to me and I'm panicking that I messed something up when filling out the form. I know the SAI is calculated from our tax info, but could I have entered something wrong? My parents make decent money but not THAT much. Are there specific numbers or sections I should double-check? Anyone know what parts of the form typically cause calculation errors? Starting to think we won't qualify for ANY aid with an SAI this high. Help!!

same happened to my daughter last yr. SAI was like 38k and we freaked out!!! turns out we put our retirement accounts as cash assets which TOTALLY screwed the calculations. check if u included 401k or IRA as liquid assets - ur not supposed to!!

0 coins

OMG thank you! I think I did exactly that - I included my parents' retirement accounts. Going to log back in and see if I can fix this disaster.

0 coins

An SAI over 40k doesn't necessarily mean you made a mistake on the FAFSA. The calculation is primarily based on your parents' Adjusted Gross Income (AGI) from their tax return, but also factors in assets, number of family members in college, and your household size. If your parents have a combined income above ~$150,000, an SAI in that range might be accurate. Here are specific areas to review: 1. Verify you entered the correct AGI from your parents' tax return (line 11 on Form 1040) 2. Check that you excluded retirement accounts (401k, IRA, pension funds) 3. Confirm you correctly reported real estate (exclude primary residence value) 4. Verify the number of family members in college is accurate 5. Make sure you entered the correct household size

0 coins

Thank you for the detailed breakdown! My parents' AGI is around $145k, so I guess maybe the SAI isn't completely off. I'll double-check all those points though, especially the retirement accounts and real estate sections.

0 coins

Don't panic yet! Even with high SAI you might still qualify for aid. Schools have their own formulas and many offer institutional aid separately. Plus, high SAI doesn't disqualify you from merit scholarships which aren't need-based. My SAI was 35k but I still got decent packages from some schools. What schools are you applying to?

0 coins

That's really reassuring to hear. I'm applying to State University, Tech Institute, and a couple of private colleges. Good to know merit scholarships are still on the table - I've got a 3.8 GPA so hopefully that helps.

0 coins

Common FAFSA mistakes that inflate SAI: • Including retirement accounts as assets (as mentioned above) • Double-counting income (entering the same income in multiple sections) • Incorrectly reporting home equity (primary residence shouldn't be reported) • Misreporting business/farm assets (small family businesses under certain sizes are protected) • Reporting 529 plans incorrectly If you find errors, you'll need to submit a correction. Log in to studentaid.gov, go to your FAFSA form, and select 'Make FAFSA Corrections.

0 coins

This list is super helpful. I definitely think I made the retirement account mistake, and possibly the home equity one too. I'll check on the small business reporting since my dad has a side business. Fingers crossed I can get this fixed!

0 coins

FAFSA is THE WORST!!!! When I called to ask about our high SAI, I was on hold for 3+ HOURS and then got disconnected. Next day, same thing. Finally found Claimyr (claimyr.com) that got me through to a real FAFSA agent in 20 minutes. They have a video demo showing how it works: https://youtu.be/TbC8dZQWYNQ The agent confirmed I had included retirement accounts AND made a decimal error on one entry (put $250,000 instead of $25,000). Fixed it and SAI dropped by almost $12k!

0 coins

omg thx for sharing this!! been trying to get thru to them for 2 weeks about verification issues and keep getting dropped calls

0 coins

Wow, a decimal error could make a huge difference! I'll definitely check my entries carefully. And good to know about that service if I need to actually talk to someone at FAFSA.

0 coins

My brother got super high SAI too but his school financial aid office helped him file a special circumstances form because our parents had unusual business expenses that year. Talk to your school's financial aid office - sometimes they can help you get more aid even with high SAI!

0 coins

That's really good to know, thanks! I'll definitely contact the financial aid offices at the schools I'm applying to.

0 coins

Everyone here thinks high SAI means no aid, but don't forget about Direct Unsubsidized Loans and Parent PLUS loans which are available regardless of your SAI. Not ideal since they're loans, but better than nothing if you need the money for school.

0 coins

Good point about unsubsidized loans being available regardless of SAI. Parent PLUS loans require a credit check but aren't need-based. However, I'd encourage exploring all scholarship options before taking on significant loan debt.

0 coins

I was hoping to avoid loans if possible, but it's good to know they're an option if needed. Will definitely prioritize scholarship applications!

0 coins

Also check if you accidentally entered income or assets in the wrong sections. My friend entered her parents' income as her own student income AND as parent income. Doubled everything and made their SAI crazy high!

0 coins

Oh no, I hope I didn't do that! Will check when I review the form. Thanks for pointing this out.

0 coins

After you review and correct any errors, remember to notify all the schools on your FAFSA list about the corrections. Sometimes they don't automatically get updated SAI information in a timely manner. A quick email to each financial aid office can ensure they're working with your current information.

0 coins

That's really helpful advice - I wouldn't have thought to notify the schools directly. Will definitely do that after making any corrections!

0 coins

FAFSA AI

Expert Assistant
Secure

Powered by Claimyr AI

T
I
+
20,087 users helped today