FAFSA SAI calculation showing 3977 with minimal assets - why only partial Pell Grant?
I'm really confused about my daughter's FAFSA results. According to every income chart I've looked at, our adjusted gross income should qualify her for a full Pell Grant. We don't have significant assets - literally just a few thousand dollars in savings (maybe $3000 total). But when I check studentaid.gov, it shows our SAI is 3977 and my daughter only qualifies for about half of the full Pell Grant amount. Could $3000 in assets really cause this dramatic reduction? I triple-checked all our income entries and everything seems correct. Has anyone experienced something similar or know what might be causing this discrepancy? I was counting on the full Pell amount for her freshman year this fall.
22 comments


Alejandro Castro
Assets shouldn't impact ur Pell that much. Did u include all household members correctly? Also double check if you accidentally reported retirement savings as regular assets. Lots of ppl make that mistake and it can mess up ur SAI bad
0 coins
Maggie Martinez
•We have 4 people in our household (me, spouse, daughter applying for aid, and a younger son in high school). I'm pretty sure I didn't include our 401k - I know that's not supposed to be counted. Is there a way to see exactly how they calculated the SAI?
0 coins
Monique Byrd
The SAI calculation changed significantly for the 2025-2026 aid year. The formula now weighs certain factors differently than in previous years. A few things that could be affecting your calculation: 1. Number of family members in college simultaneously 2. Protected income allowance thresholds changed 3. Income protection allowances were adjusted 4. How much of your income comes from work vs. other sources Also check if you correctly reported any untaxed income or benefits. That's often overlooked but can significantly impact your SAI calculation.
0 coins
Maggie Martinez
•Thank you! I didn't realize the formula had changed so much. My daughter is our only college student right now. We do receive some untaxed disability benefits - around $4800 annually. Could that be the culprit?
0 coins
Monique Byrd
•Yes, that's very likely part of the issue. Untaxed income is factored into the SAI calculation. The $4800 in disability benefits plus your $3000 in assets could easily explain the higher SAI score. You might want to check if your daughter qualifies for any institutional aid at her specific schools to help make up the difference.
0 coins
Jackie Martinez
the same exact thing happened to me last year!!! i was SO CONFUSED because our family income was def under the cutoff for full pell but we only got partial. turns out i messed up and included my moms small business assets that weren't supposed to be reported. you might want to check if you accidentally included something similar?? the asset questions are super confusing
0 coins
Maggie Martinez
•That's interesting - we do have a small side business selling crafts online. I think I might have included our craft supplies inventory (about $1500 worth) as an asset. I didn't realize that might not count!
0 coins
Lia Quinn
You should DEFINITELY call Federal Student Aid to ask for a detailed breakdown of your SAI calculation!!! I had almost the EXACT same issue and it turned out there was a random error in how they processed my information. They fixed it and my daughter got the full Pell Grant she deserved!!!! Don't give up!!!!
0 coins
Haley Stokes
•Good luck with that... I've been trying to get through to someone at Federal Student Aid for over two weeks. Either busy signals or 2+ hour hold times before getting disconnected. Their phone system is a complete disaster this year with all the FAFSA changes.
0 coins
Asher Levin
•I had the same frustrating experience trying to reach FSA about a similar SAI issue. After getting disconnected three times, I tried using Claimyr.com and got through to an agent in about 20 minutes. They have this system that holds your place in line and calls you when an agent is available. Saved me hours of waiting on hold. There's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/TbC8dZQWYNQ if you're interested. The agent I spoke with was able to tell me exactly why my SAI was higher than expected.
0 coins
Serene Snow
To directly answer your question: No, $3,000 in assets alone would not cause such a significant reduction in Pell Grant eligibility. The asset protection allowance shields a portion of assets from consideration, and even beyond that, only a small percentage (around 5.64% max) of reportable assets impacts the SAI calculation. Based on what you've shared, I suspect one of these issues: 1. The untaxed disability benefits you mentioned ($4,800) 2. The business inventory you included that might be exempt 3. Potential errors in reported household size or number in college 4. Miscategorized retirement assets Request an official SAI calculation breakdown from FSA when you can reach them. In the meantime, check with your daughter's school's financial aid office - they can often provide insights into the calculation as well.
0 coins
Maggie Martinez
•Thank you so much for this detailed explanation! I'm going to try contacting both FSA and the school's financial aid office. I'll also review our application to see if I misreported anything related to the business inventory or retirement assets.
0 coins
Issac Nightingale
everyones talking about the calculation but has anyone stopped to think that maybe its just a GLITCH?? the new fafsa has been a total disaster this year! my cousins SAI was completely wrong at first then magically fixed itself after a system update in march. maybe just wait a few weeks and check again?
0 coins
Jackie Martinez
•Omg yes!! This happened to my friend too! Her SAI was like 5000 too high at first and then randomly dropped to the right amount after like 3 weeks with no explanation. The new system is so buggy
0 coins
Maggie Martinez
•I hadn't even considered that possibility. It's been about two weeks since we submitted the FAFSA. I'll definitely keep checking to see if anything changes. Thanks for the suggestion!
0 coins
Monique Byrd
I just wanted to follow up on something important - you mentioned having a high school student as well. Make sure you correctly answered the question about the number of family members who will be in college during the 2025-2026 academic year. If you accidentally included your high school student as a college student, that would significantly impact your SAI calculation by splitting the parent contribution between two students instead of focusing it on just your daughter.
0 coins
Maggie Martinez
•I'm pretty certain I only listed my daughter as being in college, but I'll double-check that section. Thanks for pointing this out - there were so many questions, it would be easy to make a mistake like that.
0 coins
Maggie Martinez
UPDATE: I was finally able to speak with someone at Federal Student Aid! Turns out it was multiple small issues adding up. We did incorrectly report our small business inventory, included a small inherited IRA as a regular asset, AND there was a system error that doubled-counted some of our income. They're having me submit a correction form and said my daughter's Pell Grant amount should increase significantly once it's processed. Thank you all for your helpful suggestions!
0 coins
Serene Snow
•That's excellent news! This is exactly why it's so important to follow up when the SAI doesn't look right. Thanks for updating us - your experience will help others who might face similar issues.
0 coins
Alejandro Castro
•so glad u got it fixed! the fafsa is such a nightmare this year lol. good luck to ur daughter with college!!
0 coins
Brandon Parker
Wow, thank you so much for sharing this update! This is incredibly helpful for anyone else who might be dealing with similar FAFSA issues. It's crazy how multiple small errors can compound to create such a big discrepancy in the SAI calculation. The fact that there was also a system error that double-counted income just shows how buggy the new FAFSA system has been this year. I'm so glad you persisted and didn't just accept the initial calculation. This is a great reminder for everyone to carefully review each section of the FAFSA and not hesitate to question results that don't seem right. Hope the correction gets processed quickly so your daughter can get the full Pell Grant she deserves for fall semester!
0 coins
Omar Fawaz
•This is such a valuable lesson for all of us! I'm dealing with a similar situation where my FAFSA results don't match what I expected based on our income. Your experience gives me hope that it's worth fighting for the correct calculation. Can I ask how long the correction process took once you submitted the form? I'm worried about timing since some college deadlines are coming up soon.
0 coins