< Back to FAFSA

Amara Okafor

Denied Parent PLUS loan due to medical credit issues - is Sallie Mae through student a viable option?

Our family hit a rough patch when my husband's health problems forced him to stop working last year. He's now on social security, but the income gap during his illness meant we paid some car payments late, which tanked my credit score. I just applied for a Parent PLUS loan for my daughter's sophomore year and got denied because of the credit issues. Has anyone's student taken out Sallie Mae loans in their name as an alternative? My daughter has had jobs since she was 14 and currently juggles two part-time positions while maintaining her course load. She's really responsible, but I'm nervous about her taking on that much debt in her name. What are the interest rates like compared to federal loans? Are there any protections if she struggles to find work after graduation?

Yes, my son did exactly this after I was denied for Parent PLUS due to medical bankrupty. Sallie Mae approved him with me as cosigner even though my credit wasn't great. But without a cosigner, the interest rates were REALLY high - like 11-13%. With me as cosigner (even with bad credit), we got it down to about 8.5%. The big downside compared to federal loans is there's way fewer protections - basically no income-based repayment options and limited deferment if she hits hard times. You might want to appeal the PLUS denial first - sometimes they'll approve with "extenuating circumstances" if the only negative marks are related to medical issues.

0 coins

Amara Okafor

•

Thanks for this info! I didn't know appealing the PLUS denial was even possible. Do you know how I would start that process? And did your son struggle with the Sallie Mae payments after graduation?

0 coins

I strongly recommend appealing the Parent PLUS denial before going to private loans like Sallie Mae. Call Federal Student Aid and explain the medical circumstances that led to the credit issues. Medical-related credit problems often qualify for an exception. If that doesn't work, your daughter becomes eligible for additional unsubsidized federal loans (usually $4,000-$5,000 more per year) when a parent is denied PLUS. Those federal loans have MUCH better terms than Sallie Mae or other private options.

0 coins

This is rly important point - most ppl dont realize the PLUS denial actually HELPS the student get more federal loans automatically! My mom got denied and I got an extra $4k in unsub loans right away. Still had to get some private loans but way less than if I didn't get that bump in federal.

0 coins

Dylan Cooper

•

My daughter got sallie mae and I DEEPLY regret it. Interest started acrueing IMMEDIATELY while she was still in school!!! Fed loans don't do that! And the rates keep going up, shes been out of scool for 2 years and already owes like 40% more than she borrowed. Find ANY other option!!!

0 coins

Amara Okafor

•

Oh no, that sounds terrible! I had no idea the interest would start while she's still in school. That's definitely making me reconsider. Did you try appealing the PLUS loan denial first?

0 coins

Sofia Ramirez

•

Financial aid counselor here. When a parent is denied for PLUS, students automatically become eligible for additional unsubsidized federal loans - usually $4,000/year for sophomores. This won't cover the full amount a PLUS loan would, but it's a much better option than private loans for the portion it does cover. For appealing the PLUS denial, you'll need to document that the credit issues were directly related to your husband's medical situation. Call 1-800-433-3243 and ask specifically about a "PLUS loan adverse credit appeal." Having documentation ready showing the timeline of medical issues corresponding to the late payments will strengthen your case. If the appeal fails and you need more than the additional unsubsidized amount, then yes, private loans like Sallie Mae are an option, but as others have mentioned, they lack the protections of federal loans and often have higher rates.

0 coins

Amara Okafor

•

Thank you, this is incredibly helpful! I didn't realize she'd automatically qualify for additional unsubsidized loans with my denial. I'll definitely start with the appeal process first, and we'll look at covering as much as possible with the extra federal loans before considering Sallie Mae.

0 coins

Dmitry Volkov

•

Got denied for PLUS too because of a short sale on our house four years ago. Been calling FSA for WEEKS trying to get through to someone about appealing it and keep getting disconnected or waiting 2+ hours. Finally used this service called Claimyr (claimyr.com) that holds your place in line and calls you back when an agent is available. Got through in 40 minutes instead of endless waiting! Managed to file my appeal and got approved because the short sale was our only negative mark. They have a video showing how it works: https://youtu.be/TbC8dZQWYNQ

0 coins

Dylan Cooper

•

How much does that service cost tho?? Seems weird to pay money just to talk to someone at FSA when its our tax $ funding them anyway!!

0 coins

Dmitry Volkov

•

It was worth it for me because I'd already wasted HOURS trying to get through. I was about to give up on the appeal entirely. The time saved made it worthwhile - especially since the appeal got approved and saved us from having to use private loans with much higher interest rates.

0 coins

StarSeeker

•

just remember whatever ur daughter picks now shes stuck with FOREVER. my sister got sallie mae and 15 years later shes STILL paying and owes more than she borrowed originally! its CRIMINAL!!!!

0 coins

This is unfortunately very true. The private loans don't have the forgiveness options or income-based plans that federal loans do. I've seen so many stories of people with crushing private loan debt decades later.

0 coins

have u looked into scholarships?? my daughter worked at starbucks and they have this college achievement plan thing. lots of big companies have tuition help now bc they cant find workers. worth looking into before more loans!

0 coins

Amara Okafor

•

That's a great point! She currently works at a local coffee shop and a retail store on weekends, but maybe she could look into transferring to a company with tuition benefits. I'll have her research that option too.

0 coins

Sofia Ramirez

•

One more thing to consider - if you're denied the PLUS loan due to adverse credit history, your daughter becomes eligible for the additional unsubsidized loan amount, but you could also find someone else (like a grandparent or other relative with good credit) to endorse your PLUS loan application. This is similar to having a co-signer and could allow you to still get the PLUS loan with the federal protections and generally lower interest rates.

0 coins

Amara Okafor

•

I hadn't thought about asking a relative to endorse the PLUS loan. My sister might be willing to help. Would the endorser be responsible for the entire loan if we couldn't pay, or just for the missed payments? I don't want to put her in a difficult position.

0 coins

Sofia Ramirez

•

The endorser would be legally responsible for the entire loan if you couldn't pay, similar to a co-signer. It's a significant responsibility, so be very transparent about this with anyone you ask. Make sure they understand they're essentially agreeing to pay the loan if you cannot.

0 coins

I went through something very similar when my husband had a heart attack and we fell behind on bills. Here's what I learned: definitely start with the PLUS appeal first - medical hardship is one of the strongest grounds for reversal. When you call FSA, have all your medical documentation ready (hospital records, disability paperwork, etc.) and a timeline showing how the medical issues directly caused the late payments. If the appeal fails, your daughter automatically gets about $4,000 more in federal unsubsidized loans, which should cover a good chunk of what you need. Only consider Sallie Mae or other private loans for whatever gap remains after maxing out all federal options. The interest rates and lack of protections on private loans are brutal - my neighbor's son is still paying 12% interest on his Sallie Mae loan from 2018! Also check if your daughter's current employers offer any tuition assistance - even small amounts help reduce how much you need to borrow.

0 coins

Vince Eh

•

Thank you so much for sharing your experience! It's reassuring to hear from someone who went through something similar. I'll definitely gather all the medical documentation and create that timeline before calling FSA. Your point about the 12% interest rate on private loans is eye-opening - that's exactly the kind of long-term impact I'm worried about for my daughter. I really appreciate the practical advice about maximizing federal options first.

0 coins

FAFSA AI

Expert Assistant
Secure

Powered by Claimyr AI

T
I
+
20,087 users helped today