


Ask the community...
To answer your original question more directly - an SAI in the 24797-25865 range typically means: 1. No Pell Grant eligibility (cutoff is much lower) 2. Eligible for subsidized federal loans 3. Eligible for unsubsidized federal loans 4. Might qualify for work-study depending on the school 5. Will likely need to cover about $25K/year through some combination of personal funds, PLUS loans, or private loans 6. Will be considered for merit scholarships separately from need-based aid 7. Twins/multiple students situation should help your case in appeals Remember the SAI is just a starting point. Each school's final offer depends on their total cost, available funds, and how much they want your students.
Just want to add that you should also look into state-specific aid programs! Many states have grant programs that consider different income thresholds than federal aid. With your SAI range, you might still qualify for state grants depending on where you live. Also, don't forget about smaller local scholarships - community organizations, employers, religious institutions, etc. These often have less competition and can really add up. My neighbor's twins each got several $500-2000 local scholarships that made a real difference in their final costs.
This is great advice! I hadn't even thought about state grants - I assumed if we didn't qualify for federal Pell grants, we wouldn't qualify for anything at the state level either. Do you know if there's a good resource to find out what's available in each state? Also love the local scholarship idea - with twins, every little bit definitely helps!
This is incredibly helpful! I'll mark my calendar to follow up with the schools in about 2 weeks. Thank you for such detailed information - this whole process is so much clearer now!
Just wanted to add my experience as another first-time FAFSA filer - I was also confused about the asset questions being skipped! My family has a similar situation with Medicaid coverage, and we ended up with a -1800 SAI. Reading through all these responses has been so reassuring. One thing I discovered is that you can actually check the status of your FAFSA transmission to schools by logging back into your StudentAid.gov account and looking at the "My Activity" section. It shows when each school received your information, which helped ease my anxiety about whether everything went through properly. Good luck with your financial aid packages! Sounds like you're in great shape with that negative SAI.
To follow up on your question about private vs. state schools - YES, definitely have her look at private schools now! With an SAI that low, many selective private colleges will offer incredibly generous financial aid packages that can make them cheaper than state universities. Schools with large endowments often have institutional funds they can use to cover most or all of the cost beyond what federal aid provides. The key term to research is "schools that meet 100% of demonstrated financial need" - these institutions will use your SAI to determine your need and then build aid packages to cover the full cost of attendance minus your SAI amount. With a 92 SAI, your daughter could potentially get packages that cover almost the entire cost at these schools.
This is incredibly helpful information. I just did some quick research and found a list of schools that meet 100% of demonstrated need. Some are schools we never would have considered due to the sticker price. I'm cautiously optimistic now - we'll wait for verification from FSA but start exploring these options too. Thank you all for the guidance!
As someone who just went through this process with my son last year, I wanted to share that the new FAFSA formula can definitely produce surprisingly low SAI numbers for middle-class families! We had a similar income level and were shocked by our low SAI too. A few things that might have contributed to your daughter's SAI of 92: - The new formula has higher income protection allowances - State tax allowances vary significantly by where you live - Asset protection has changed under the new system - Even small medical expenses or other deductions can have bigger impacts now My advice: Screenshot everything and keep detailed records, but don't panic! We were worried it was an error too, but it turned out to be legitimate. The financial aid packages my son received were incredible - schools that would have cost $50k+ ended up costing us less than our state university would have. Start researching schools that meet full demonstrated need NOW. With an SAI that low, your daughter could potentially attend some amazing private colleges for less than you'd pay at a state school. It really opened up opportunities we never thought were financially possible!
This is so reassuring to hear from someone who went through the same thing! I've been losing sleep over whether this could be real. Your point about keeping detailed records is smart - I'm definitely going to screenshot everything just in case. I'm starting to get excited about the possibility that this could actually open doors we never imagined. We had already mentally prepared ourselves for significant debt or limiting her to in-state options. If she could potentially attend a top-tier private school for less than our state university, that would be absolutely life-changing for her future. Thank you for sharing your experience - it gives me hope that this isn't too good to be true!
If the laptop is owned by your business and reported as a business asset on your tax forms, then it would be considered part of your excluded business assets. The key is consistency between tax reporting and FAFSA reporting. If you're depreciating it as a business expense on your Schedule C, then it's a business asset and covered by the exclusion.
why does everythng have to be so complicated with fafsa??? last year I spent 3 days trying to figure out how to report my husbands tool chest for his side business. ended up just leaving it off and nothing happened lol
EXACTLY!! The system is designed to be confusing on purpose. They want us to make mistakes so they can deny aid. It's all about keeping people out of college unless they're already rich.
I get the frustration, but for anyone reading this - please don't just leave things off your FAFSA! If you get selected for verification (which happens to about 1 in 3 applications), discrepancies between your tax returns and FAFSA can delay your aid or even disqualify you. The small business exclusion we've been discussing is actually designed to help families like yours avoid having to value every tool and piece of equipment. It's worth taking the time to understand the rules rather than risk your financial aid package.
Taylor Chen
***UPDATE***. It was processed and then we went in and made the change. It was SOOOO easy to fix!!! Just wanted to update everyone who replied. Our SAI dropped by over 11,000 points after removing the retirement accounts. HUGE difference in our aid eligibility. Thanks to everyone who helped!!!
0 coins
Ana Erdoğan
•YAAAAY!!! so happy 4 u!! isn't it crazy how one little mistake can change everything?? glad u got it fixed!!
0 coins
Ezra Bates
•That's excellent news! An 11,000 point SAI reduction is significant and will definitely impact your aid eligibility. Thanks for updating us - this will help others who find themselves in the same situation.
0 coins
Andre Dubois
Wow, what a relief that you were able to fix it so easily! That 11,000 point SAI drop is absolutely massive - it really shows how important it is to get the asset reporting right. This whole thread has been super educational for someone like me who's new to the FAFSA process. I had no idea retirement accounts weren't supposed to be included, and honestly the way the questions are worded it's no wonder so many people make this mistake. Thanks to everyone who shared the step-by-step correction process - I'm bookmarking this thread in case I run into similar issues when I fill out my FAFSA next year!
0 coins
Drake
•Same here! I'm planning to fill out my FAFSA for the first time next year and this whole thread has been incredibly helpful. It's honestly scary how easy it would be to make a mistake like this - the FAFSA really should have clearer instructions about what counts as assets and what doesn't. I'm definitely going to reference that comprehensive list Jay posted when I get to the asset questions. Really glad everything worked out for you, Taylor!
0 coins