


Ask the community...
One thing I learned the hard way: don't just look at the bottom line number on financial aid offers. Some schools front-load grants in the first year then switch to more loans in later years. Others include work-study in the package which isn't guaranteed money. And watch out for Parent PLUS loans being included as if they're aid - they're just loans with higher interest rates that YOU have to pay back, not reduced costs.
Your SAI of 598 is excellent news! As someone who just went through this process with my own kid, I can tell you that score puts your daughter in a really good position. We had a similar family income and our SAI was around 750, and my son still received substantial aid at most schools he applied to. A few practical tips from our experience: - Don't be surprised if private schools sometimes offer better net prices than state schools due to their larger endowments - Keep all your financial documents organized - schools often request verification - Consider having your daughter apply to a financial safety school where her stats are well above average (they might offer merit aid on top of need-based aid) - Start looking at outside scholarship opportunities now while you're waiting for school decisions The waiting is the hardest part, but with that SAI, you should have some good options come spring!
update: I finally got it fixed!!!! turns out the emails were because my dad needed to resubmit HIS part even tho it showed completed on my end! check with your parents maybe?
I just got off the phone with FSA after a 35-minute wait. Turns out my situation was different - they confirmed the emails were sent in error due to a system flag on my account. They manually cleared it and said to ignore any more emails about this for the next 48 hours while their system updates. Such a relief! Thanks everyone for the help!
As someone who just went through the FAFSA process for the first time, this thread is so helpful! I was getting paranoid that I missed something when those automated emails started coming. It's reassuring to know this is a widespread system issue and not user error. For anyone still dealing with this - definitely save screenshots of your dashboard showing no pending actions before calling FSA. That documentation really helps the agents understand what you're seeing vs what their system is flagging.
Congrats on getting it sorted out! Your step-by-step breakdown is really helpful - I'm bookmarking this thread in case I run into similar issues with my own FAFSA. The part about waiting for FSA ID verification is especially important since I don't think most people realize that can take 1-2 days. Thanks for taking the time to post the solution that worked!
This thread has been a lifesaver! I'm dealing with the exact same issue right now and was getting so frustrated. Going to have my dad create his FSA ID first thing tomorrow morning. Really appreciate everyone sharing their experiences - it's so helpful to know this is a common problem and not just us doing something wrong!
This is such great timing! I'm having the exact same issue with my mom right now - she got the invitation yesterday and the link just shows a blank page. Based on all the advice here, I'm going to have her create her FSA ID first at studentaid.gov and then I'll resend the invitation once it's verified. It's frustrating that the system doesn't make this requirement clear upfront, but at least now I know what to do instead of wasting more time clicking the same broken link. Thanks everyone for sharing your experiences - this community is so helpful!
Yes! This thread has been amazing - I was starting to think there was something wrong with our computer or internet connection. It's such a relief to know this is a widespread issue with the new FAFSA system and not just user error. The FSA ID verification wait time is definitely something they should warn people about upfront. Hope your mom's FSA ID gets verified quickly and you can get past this roadblock soon!
One thing I'd like to add that hasn't been mentioned yet - don't forget about CSS Profile if your son is applying to private colleges! Many private schools require both FAFSA and CSS Profile for institutional aid. The CSS Profile asks for much more detailed financial information and often requires tax documents to be uploaded directly. It also costs money to submit (around $25 for the first school, $16 for each additional). The CSS Profile usually opens in early October, so you'd actually need to submit that before the FAFSA. Just wanted to make sure you're aware since it can be a surprise for families who only prepared for FAFSA!
Oh wow, I had no idea about CSS Profile! That's a huge detail that could have blindsided us. So if I'm understanding correctly, we'd need to submit CSS Profile in October 2024 (before FAFSA opens in December) for any private colleges he's considering? And it requires even more financial documentation than FAFSA? This is getting more complex than I thought, but I'm really grateful you mentioned it. Do you know if there's a list somewhere of which schools require CSS Profile, or do I need to check each college's financial aid website individually?
You can find the complete list of schools that require CSS Profile on the College Board website - they have a searchable tool where you can look up specific colleges. Most Ivy League schools, many liberal arts colleges, and quite a few private universities require it. The CSS Profile does ask for much more detailed info - things like home equity, business assets, medical expenses, and even asks about assets held in siblings' names. It's definitely more time-consuming than FAFSA, but many schools use it to award their own institutional grants which can be substantial. I'd recommend checking the financial aid requirements for each school on your son's potential list as early as possible so you can plan accordingly!
This thread has been incredibly helpful! As someone just starting to navigate this process with my daughter who's also a junior, I'm taking notes on everything you've all shared. The timeline breakdown really clarified things for me - I was also confused about the tax year timing. One quick question: for the asset information that gets reported as of the filing date, does that include things like 529 college savings plans? I know those are treated differently but want to make sure I understand what counts as "parent assets" versus "student assets" since the assessment rates are so different.
Great question about 529 plans! Yes, 529 college savings plans owned by parents or the student are reported as parent assets on the FAFSA (even if the student is the beneficiary), which means they're assessed at the lower 5.64% rate rather than the 20% student asset rate. This is actually beneficial since 529s are specifically designed for education expenses. However, 529 plans owned by grandparents or other relatives don't get reported as assets on the FAFSA, but any distributions from those accounts in the previous tax year would be reported as untaxed student income, which can have a bigger impact on aid eligibility. So if grandparents have 529s for your daughter, it's worth strategizing about when to use those funds!
Aria Park
Update: My SAI finally appeared today - took exactly 4 business days. For anyone else wondering about timing, the system didn't send me any notification; I just kept checking my account and it was there this morning. Thanks everyone for the help and reassurance!
0 coins
Noah Ali
•what's your number if u dont mind sharing? trying to see what's normal these days
0 coins
Olivia Harris
•Glad you got your number! Now begins the REAL fun of trying to figure out what kind of financial aid package you'll actually get. The whole system is so stressful!!!
0 coins
Bethany Groves
Great to hear your SAI came through! Four business days is pretty typical from what I've seen. For others still waiting, I'd recommend checking your account every morning rather than multiple times per day - the processing seems to happen overnight and you'll just stress yourself out refreshing constantly. Also make sure to screenshot your SAI once it appears, since you'll need that number for multiple applications and it's easier than logging in every time.
0 coins
PixelPioneer
•That's really smart advice about screenshotting the SAI! I'm new to all this FAFSA stuff and didn't even think about needing that number for multiple applications. Also good to know about checking once a day instead of obsessively refreshing - I can already tell I'm going to be tempted to do that when I submit mine next week!
0 coins