Can S corp owner collect unemployment benefits from NYS Department of Labor?
I've been running my small consulting business as an S corp for the past 3 years, paying myself a W-2 salary and contributing to unemployment insurance through payroll. The business has been struggling lately and I might need to shut it down temporarily. Can I actually file for unemployment benefits with NYS Department of Labor even though I'm technically the owner? I've been paying into the system but I'm not sure if business owners are eligible. Has anyone dealt with this situation before?
20 comments
Join the conversation
Marcelle Drum
This is actually more complicated than most people think. Since you're an S corp owner who receives a W-2 and pays unemployment taxes, you might be eligible depending on your ownership percentage. NYS Department of Labor generally considers owners with less than 5% ownership as employees for UI purposes. If you own more than that, it gets tricky. You'd need to show you had no control over your employment status when filing your claim.
0 coins
Collins Angel
•I own 100% of the S corp, so sounds like I'm probably out of luck then? Even though I've been paying into unemployment insurance for years?
0 coins
Tate Jensen
wait this doesn't make sense to me... if you're paying unemployment taxes why wouldn't you be able to collect?? seems like the system is rigged against small business owners
0 coins
Marcelle Drum
•The logic is that as the owner, you have control over whether you're employed or not. Regular employees don't have that control. It's about the 'involuntary' aspect of unemployment - if you can decide to hire yourself back, then technically your unemployment isn't involuntary.
0 coins
Adaline Wong
I went through something similar last year when I had to close my restaurant. NYS Department of Labor initially denied my claim because I was listed as the owner, but I was able to appeal and eventually got approved. The key was proving that external circumstances forced the closure - in my case it was losing my lease. You'll want to document everything that led to shutting down your business. The adjudication process took about 6 weeks but it was worth fighting for.
0 coins
Collins Angel
•That gives me some hope! What kind of documentation did you need for the appeal? I have emails showing client contracts being cancelled due to budget cuts on their end.
0 coins
Adaline Wong
•Exactly that kind of stuff - client cancellations, financial records showing the decline, any correspondence about circumstances beyond your control. The more you can show it wasn't just a business decision but forced by external factors, the better your chances.
0 coins
Gabriel Ruiz
If you're having trouble reaching anyone at NYS Department of Labor to get clear answers about this (which happens a lot with these complex owner situations), I used a service called Claimyr that got me through to an actual agent. They have this system where they call for you and connect you when someone picks up - way better than sitting on hold for hours. Check out their demo at https://youtu.be/qyftW-mnTNI and their site claimyr.com. Might be worth it to get official guidance on your specific S corp situation before filing.
0 coins
Misterclamation Skyblue
•sounds interesting but is it legit? seems too good to be true that they can actually get through when nobody else can
0 coins
Gabriel Ruiz
•I was skeptical too but it actually worked. They just keep calling until they get through and then conference you in. Saved me probably 20 hours of trying to call myself.
0 coins
Peyton Clarke
This whole thing is SO confusing!! I thought if you pay taxes you can collect benefits but apparently not? What's the point of paying unemployment taxes as a business owner if you can never use them??? Makes no sense to me at all.
0 coins
Marcelle Drum
•You're paying those taxes for any employees you might have, not necessarily for yourself as the owner. But there are some exceptions as others have mentioned - it's worth exploring if you can prove involuntary closure.
0 coins
Ethan Moore
From what I understand, there's actually a distinction between being an "officer" vs an "employee" for S corp owners when it comes to unemployment benefits. Even if you own 100% of the company, if you can demonstrate that you were functioning as an employee (receiving regular W-2 wages, following employment protocols, etc.) rather than just an officer making distributions, you might still have a case. The key is showing that your role was similar to any other employee, despite your ownership stake. I'd recommend getting a consultation with someone who specializes in unemployment law for S corp owners - the rules are really nuanced and a lot depends on how your specific situation is structured.
0 coins
Skylar Neal
•That's a really good point about the officer vs employee distinction! I hadn't thought about it that way. Since I've been taking a regular W-2 salary rather than just distributions, maybe that could work in my favor. Do you know if there are specific criteria NYS uses to determine if you're functioning as an employee? Like does it matter if I had set work hours, job duties documented, etc.? The consultation idea sounds smart - this is definitely more complex than I initially thought.
0 coins
Arjun Kurti
I actually went through this exact situation with my S corp in 2022. The NYS Department of Labor initially denied my claim because I owned 100% of the company, but I successfully appealed by focusing on two key points: 1) I was legitimately operating as a W-2 employee with documented job duties, set schedule, and regular salary (not just taking distributions), and 2) I could prove the business closure was due to circumstances completely beyond my control - in my case, my main client went bankrupt and owed me $40k. The appeals process took about 8 weeks but I ultimately received benefits for 20 weeks. The trick is really documenting that you were functioning as an employee AND that the closure was involuntary. Don't give up after an initial denial - the appeals process is where these complex S corp cases often get resolved in your favor.
0 coins
PrinceJoe
•This is incredibly helpful to hear from someone who actually went through the process successfully! The 8-week appeals timeline is good to know. I'm curious - when you were documenting your role as an employee, did you need formal employment agreements or job descriptions on file with the company? Or was it more about showing the pattern of W-2 wages and regular business operations? I'm trying to figure out what kind of documentation I should be gathering now before I potentially need to file. Also, did you work with an attorney during the appeals process or handle it yourself?
0 coins
Sofia Price
I'm dealing with a similar situation right now with my marketing consultancy S corp. Been paying unemployment taxes for 2 years as a 100% owner taking W-2 salary. From everything I'm reading here, it sounds like the key is really being able to prove the closure is involuntary and that you were operating as a legitimate employee. I'm keeping detailed records of all client communications, financial statements, and my employment documentation just in case. Has anyone had success with partial closures? Like if I can only keep maybe 20% of my client base due to market conditions, would that potentially qualify for partial unemployment benefits while I try to rebuild?
0 coins
Malik Thomas
•That's a great question about partial closures! From what I've seen in other cases, you might be able to qualify for partial unemployment benefits if you can demonstrate that the reduction in work/income is due to circumstances beyond your control (like widespread client losses due to market conditions) rather than a voluntary business decision. The tricky part with S corp owners is still proving that the reduced work is "involuntary" since technically you could choose to take on new clients. But if you can document that you're actively seeking new business and the market conditions are genuinely preventing you from maintaining your previous income level, it might be worth exploring. I'd definitely recommend getting that consultation with an unemployment law specialist that others mentioned - partial benefits for business owners is an even more nuanced area than complete closures.
0 coins
Miguel Hernández
Based on all these experiences shared here, it really seems like the key factors for S corp owners are: 1) proving you operated as a legitimate W-2 employee (not just taking distributions), 2) documenting that the closure/reduction was truly involuntary due to external circumstances, and 3) being prepared to go through the appeals process if initially denied. I'm in a similar boat with my consulting S corp - been paying UI taxes for years but worried about eligibility. The success stories here give me hope that it's worth pursuing if you have solid documentation. One thing I'm wondering - for those who successfully appealed, how important was it to have an employment attorney vs handling it yourself? The process sounds complex enough that professional help might be worth the investment.
0 coins
Owen Jenkins
•Great summary of the key factors! From what I've seen in other states, having an attorney can definitely help but it's not always necessary if you're organized and persistent. The appeals process is often more about presenting the right documentation than complex legal arguments. That said, if your case has any unusual circumstances or if you're not comfortable navigating the bureaucracy yourself, an attorney who specializes in unemployment law could save you time and stress. Some offer free consultations where they can assess whether your case is strong enough to pursue. Given that you've been paying into the system for years as a legitimate W-2 employee, it seems worth exploring - especially with all the success stories here showing it's definitely possible for S corp owners to qualify.
0 coins