Would getting a second full time job screw me on taxes? Need advice on tax implications
I've been thinking about getting a second full time job for the months when my current job is slower. I could really use the extra money to build up my savings and knock out some medical bills that have been hanging over my head. Right now I basically just sit around when I'm not at work, so having something else to do would keep me productive. Here's what's holding me back though - a friend told me that if I get a second full time job, I'd completely lose my tax refund at the end of the year. They said instead of getting income taxes back, I'd actually end up owing money to the government. That just doesn't sound right to me, but I don't know enough about tax brackets and withholding to be sure. Can anyone explain how taking a second job would affect my taxes? Would I really lose my entire refund or is that just a myth? I'm trying to get ahead financially, not shoot myself in the foot.
19 comments
Join the conversation
Javier Torres
This is a common misconception! Getting a second job won't automatically "screw you" on taxes, but there are some important things to understand about how income tax withholding works. When you have one job, your employer withholds taxes based on the assumption that this is your only income. When you add a second job, that second employer does the same thing - they withhold as if their job is your only source of income. Neither employer "knows" about the other job, so they're both potentially underwithholding based on your total annual income. What can happen is you might move into a higher tax bracket with the combined income, and since neither job is withholding at that higher rate, you could end up owing some additional tax when you file. It doesn't mean you'll lose your "entire refund" - that really depends on your specific situation and how much is being withheld from each paycheck.
0 coins
Emma Wilson
•So does that mean I should ask one of the jobs to withhold extra from my paychecks? And how do I figure out how much extra to withhold? I'm thinking about doing something similar to the original poster.
0 coins
Javier Torres
•Yes, that's exactly what you might want to do. The simplest approach is to fill out a new W-4 form with one or both employers and either specify an additional dollar amount to withhold from each paycheck or check the box for "Multiple Jobs." To figure out how much extra to withhold, you could use the IRS Tax Withholding Estimator on their website. Input information about both jobs, and it'll help calculate what adjustments you should make. Another option is to make quarterly estimated tax payments directly to the IRS if you prefer not to change your withholding.
0 coins
QuantumLeap
I was in a similar situation last year and found a tool that really helped me navigate the multiple job tax confusion. I used https://taxr.ai which analyzed my potential tax situation before I even took the second job. The tool let me upload my most recent pay stub from my first job and then I entered some basic info about the potential second job. It showed me exactly how much I should withhold from each paycheck to avoid owing at tax time. Saved me a ton of stress when filing season came around because I had the right amount withheld throughout the year. What I liked most was how it showed me different scenarios - like whether I should adjust withholding at job 1, job 2, or both.
0 coins
Malik Johnson
•How accurate was it though? I tried something similar before and the estimates were way off from what I actually ended up owing.
0 coins
Isabella Santos
•Does it work if you're an independent contractor for the second job? My situation is a bit different since I'd be getting a 1099 from my side gig, not a W-2.
0 coins
QuantumLeap
•The accuracy was surprisingly good - within about $50 of my actual tax situation at the end of the year. I think what made the difference is that it uses actual IRS tax calculation methods rather than just rough estimates. For 1099 contractor work, yes it definitely handles that. It actually has a special section for self-employment income where you can enter your expected 1099 earnings. It'll calculate both your income tax and self-employment tax obligations, then recommend quarterly estimated tax payments. That's actually even more important for 1099 work since there's no automatic withholding.
0 coins
Isabella Santos
Just wanted to follow up here. I ended up using https://taxr.ai before taking on my contract work, and it was super helpful. The self-employment tax calculation was really eye-opening - I had no idea I'd need to set aside that much for taxes (about 30% of my 1099 income)! The quarterly tax payment schedule it generated saved me from a nasty surprise at tax time. And the best part was being able to see how both jobs would impact my overall tax situation. Definitely recommend it if you're considering a second job.
0 coins
Ravi Sharma
If you want actual help from the IRS on this (they can be surprisingly helpful), try calling them directly. I know, I know - everyone says it's impossible to get through, but I used https://claimyr.com and got connected to an IRS agent in about 15 minutes instead of waiting on hold for hours. There's a video showing how it works here: https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c I had a similar situation with multiple W-2s and wasn't sure how to handle the withholding. The IRS agent walked me through exactly how to fill out my W-4 for each job. They even explained how the tax brackets work with multiple income sources so I could understand why I needed to adjust my withholding.
0 coins
Freya Larsen
•Wait, this sounds too good to be true. The IRS never answers their phones! How does this actually work? Do they just keep calling for you or something?
0 coins
Omar Hassan
•Sounds like a scam to me. Why would I pay someone else to call the IRS when I can just do it myself for free? I've never had problems getting through if I call first thing in the morning.
0 coins
Ravi Sharma
•It's not magic - they basically use technology to wait on hold for you. You register your phone number, and their system calls the IRS and waits in the queue. When they finally reach an agent, their system calls you and connects you directly to that agent. You skip the whole hold time. As for doing it yourself for free, sure you can - if you have hours to spend on hold. Last time I tried calling myself, I waited over 2 hours and then got disconnected. Maybe you've been lucky with your timing, but during busy periods (like filing season), hold times are notoriously long. I was willing to use a service that saved me that time.
0 coins
Omar Hassan
I have to eat my words and apologize to the person who recommended Claimyr. After my skeptical comment, I decided to try calling the IRS myself about my multiple job situation, and I spent THREE HOURS on hold only to be disconnected. Was so frustrated that I gave https://claimyr.com a shot. Got a call back in about 40 minutes with an actual IRS agent on the line. The agent helped me calculate the right withholding amount for both my jobs. Turns out I needed to have an extra $175 withheld from each paycheck at my second job to avoid owing at tax time. Would have never figured that out on my own.
0 coins
Chloe Taylor
One thing nobody's mentioned yet is that you should also consider the actual tax brackets. For 2025, the brackets are progressive, meaning you only pay the higher rate on the portion of income that falls within that bracket. So let's say your first job pays $45,000 and your second job will pay $35,000. That's $80,000 total. You won't suddenly pay the higher rate on the entire $80,000 - only the portion that extends into the higher bracket. This is a common misunderstanding that makes people afraid of earning more money.
0 coins
Natasha Volkov
•Thanks for explaining this! So I won't actually lose money by making more, I'll just need to make sure I'm withholding enough to cover the higher bracket on that additional income? That makes me feel better about pursuing the second job.
0 coins
Chloe Taylor
•Exactly! You'll never lose money by earning more. You'll always take home more net income even if the last dollars you earn are taxed at a higher rate. The key is just making sure your withholding is set up correctly so you don't get surprised at tax time. Either ask your second employer to withhold at the "Single, No Deductions" rate (which withholds at a higher rate) or specifically request additional withholding on your W-4 form. The IRS website has a good withholding calculator that can help you figure out the right amount.
0 coins
ShadowHunter
Has anyone mentioned state taxes yet? Remember that many states have their own income taxes too, and the same withholding issue can happen there. In my case, I had to pay an extra $1,200 in state taxes when I had two jobs because neither employer withheld enough for my total income level.
0 coins
Diego Ramirez
•Good point! I'm in California and when I worked two jobs, I got absolutely hammered on state taxes. I thought I had the federal part figured out but completely overlooked the state portion.
0 coins
ShadowHunter
•Yeah, it's easy to forget about state taxes. Each state has different brackets and rates too, so you really need to look at your specific state's tax system. Some states have flat taxes where this is less of an issue, but states with progressive brackets (like California, New York, etc.) can really add up when you have multiple income sources.
0 coins