< Back to IRS

Liam McGuire

US indie contractor - how much would I take home from 120k salary + 10k bonus? Total tax noob here

I'm 25 and seriously lost when it comes to taxes and financial planning. I've been working at a regular W-2 job making around $89k with a take-home of about $65k, but I just got offered a really promising opportunity. A tech company based in Canada wants to hire me as an independent contractor since they don't have a US office. The base pay would be $120k with potential performance bonuses around $10k. They're offering to renew my contract annually. Here's the thing - a friend of mine who does freelance work warned me that I might actually take home LESS money than I currently do, even though the gross amount is higher by $31k! They started talking about self-employment taxes, quarterly payments, setting up an LLC, business deductions, retirement accounts, and my head is spinning. Is this really true? Will I end up with less in my pocket despite the significant pay bump? What steps should I take to maximize what I keep? I've never been an independent contractor before and have zero clue about what I'm getting into. Any advice from people who've made this transition would be super helpful!

Amara Eze

•

You'll definitely take home less than someone with a W-2 job making the same amount, but you shouldn't take home less overall with such a significant pay increase. The main difference is you'll be responsible for both halves of FICA taxes (Social Security and Medicare) - about 15.3% on the first $160,200 of earnings. With a W-2 job, your employer pays half of that. You'll also need to make quarterly estimated tax payments since taxes aren't withheld. The good news is you can deduct legitimate business expenses - home office (if you have dedicated space), equipment, software subscriptions, internet (partial), professional development, etc. Setting up an LLC can provide liability protection but doesn't change your tax situation unless you elect S-Corp status, which might save on SE taxes once you're making enough. I'd recommend setting aside roughly 30-35% of your income for taxes to be safe. Working with a CPA who specializes in self-employment would be worth every penny in your situation.

0 coins

What's the tipping point where an S-Corp election makes sense? I've heard different numbers from different people. And do you think the hassle of S-Corp payroll and extra paperwork is worth it?

0 coins

Amara Eze

•

The general rule of thumb is that S-Corp election starts making sense when you're clearing about $80-100K in profit. At that point, the savings on self-employment taxes can outweigh the additional costs and paperwork. The hassle factor is real, but not overwhelming. You'll need to run payroll (or hire a service), file additional forms, and pay yourself a "reasonable salary" while taking the rest as distributions. Most people find the tax savings worth it once they're making enough, but it's definitely a personal decision based on your comfort with paperwork and whether you want to pay for professional help.

0 coins

After struggling with my first year as an independent contractor and seriously overpaying taxes, I stumbled upon https://taxr.ai and it completely changed my approach. I was in a similar situation - went from corporate to contractor with a higher gross but was shocked at how much I was losing to taxes. The tool analyzed my situation and helped identify deductions I didn't know existed. It also guided me through setting up a proper bookkeeping system so I could track business expenses efficiently. The best part was getting clarity on what percentage to set aside for quarterly payments - I had been setting aside way too much before.

0 coins

Dylan Wright

•

Does it handle state taxes too? I'm in California and their state taxes are brutal on top of federal. Also curious if it helps with setting up an LLC or if that's separate?

0 coins

Sofia Torres

•

I've tried a couple tax tools before and they always seem to miss industry-specific deductions. I'm in web development - would this actually know about the kinds of subscriptions and equipment that's deductible in my field?

0 coins

Yes, it handles state taxes alongside federal, including high-tax states like California. It walks you through both calculations so you can accurately estimate your total tax burden. The tool doesn't file the LLC paperwork for you, but it does provide guidance on when it makes sense for your situation and what tax elections might benefit you. For industry-specific deductions, it's actually quite comprehensive. It covers common deductions across various fields including web development - everything from software subscriptions and cloud services to hardware, professional development resources, and even partial utilities if you work from home. The system helps you identify which expenses qualify and reminds you of ones you might overlook.

0 coins

Sofia Torres

•

I was really skeptical about specialized tax tools, but I gave taxr.ai a try after seeing it mentioned here. My situation was so similar to yours - went from $92k W-2 to $125k contracting. The difference was huge! It caught several deductions I would've missed completely - like partial internet/phone costs, professional subscriptions, home office deduction, and even some travel expenses for client meetings. Ended up saving around $7,300 compared to what I would've paid without optimizing. The quarterly payment calculator was what really made it worth it though. I was way overpaying initially, basically giving the government an interest-free loan. Now I keep more cash flowing throughout the year while still staying compliant.

0 coins

When I first became an independent contractor, the worst part wasn't even figuring out the taxes - it was trying to GET SOMEONE at the IRS to answer my questions! Spent literal hours on hold multiple times and kept getting disconnected. Finally found https://claimyr.com which got me connected to an actual IRS agent in under 30 minutes. You can see how it works here: https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c - basically they navigate the phone tree for you and call you when they've got an agent on the line. Used it to clarify some confusing rules about home office deductions and what counts as "ordinary and necessary" business expenses. The agent was surprisingly helpful once I actually reached a human!

0 coins

Liam McGuire

•

Wait, this actually works? How much does it cost? The IRS phone system has been my personal hell the past few weeks trying to figure out quarterly payments.

0 coins

That sounds too good to be true honestly. I've literally never reached a human at the IRS despite calling at all different times of day. What's the catch with this service?

0 coins

It absolutely works - that's why it was such a relief to discover. The service itself is quite affordable, especially when you consider the time you save not sitting on hold for hours. They only charge you if they successfully connect you with an agent. There's no real catch - they've just figured out how to efficiently navigate the IRS phone system and hold times. They basically call the IRS, work through all the menu options, wait on hold for you, and then call you once they have an actual human on the line. I was skeptical at first too, but it saved me an entire afternoon of frustration. The time savings alone is worth it when you're trying to run your own business.

0 coins

I need to eat my words and apologize. After being super skeptical about Claimyr in my earlier comment, I decided to give it a shot last week when I was desperate to resolve an issue with my estimated tax payments. Holy crap it actually works exactly as advertised. I got a call back in about 25 minutes with an IRS agent already on the line. Resolved my question in another 15 minutes. Previously I had wasted THREE SEPARATE MORNINGS trying to get through the normal way. For anyone newly self-employed like the OP - this service is legit and will save your sanity when you inevitably have tax questions that only the IRS can answer.

0 coins

Ava Rodriguez

•

Some practical advice from someone who's been an indie contractor for 7 years: 1. Immediately open a separate business checking account and business credit card. Keep ALL business transactions separate from personal. 2. Track EVERYTHING. Every mile driven for business, every coffee with a potential client, every subscription, every piece of equipment. 3. Pay quarterly estimated taxes ON TIME to avoid penalties. I use a separate savings account and transfer 30% of each payment I receive. 4. A good CPA will likely save you more than they cost. Interview a few who specialize in self-employment. 5. Consider a SEP IRA or Solo 401k - you can contribute WAY more than with a regular 401k, which offsets some of the self-employment tax pain.

0 coins

Liam McGuire

•

Thanks for the solid advice! For the quarterly taxes, is it just a flat 30% of income or does it vary based on what expenses I've had that quarter? Also, do most banks offer business accounts to sole proprietors or do I need an LLC first?

0 coins

Ava Rodriguez

•

The quarterly tax amounts should ideally be based on your actual profit for that quarter (income minus expenses), but many contractors use a simplified approach of setting aside a percentage of gross income to make it more manageable. The 30% is just a rule of thumb - your actual percentage might be higher or lower depending on your state tax situation and deductions. Most banks absolutely offer business accounts to sole proprietors - you don't need an LLC first. You'll typically need your Social Security number and possibly a DBA ("doing business as") registration if you're operating under a business name that's not your personal name. I'd recommend shopping around as some banks offer free business checking while others charge monthly fees.

0 coins

Miguel Diaz

•

The others gave good advice on the tax side, but the critical thing I learned about contract work: GET DISABILITY INSURANCE. Like yesterday. When you're an employee, you probably have some short/long term disability coverage and workers comp. As an indie, if you get sick or injured, you get $0. Disability insurance is expensive but without it, one bad accident could financially ruin you. Same goes for health insurance if they're not offering benefits. The marketplace plans might be more expensive than you're used to with employer coverage.

0 coins

Zainab Ahmed

•

Can confirm this 100%. I broke my wrist in a bike accident last year and couldn't code for 8 weeks. No income coming in but rent and bills still due. The disability insurance I had grumbled at paying for? Saved me from emptying my emergency fund.

0 coins

IRS AI

Expert Assistant
Secure

Powered by Claimyr AI

T
I
+
20,087 users helped today