FAFSA didn't ask about 529 plans or investments - will this affect my child's SAI?
Just submitted my daughter's FAFSA for her freshman year and I'm freaking out that I might have done something wrong. When I completed the application, it pulled our tax info directly from the IRS (which was super convenient), but I never got asked about our 529 college savings plan, investment accounts, or checking/savings balances. These sections only appeared in the review stage before submission, but they were greyed out and I couldn't add any information. We submitted anyway and received an SAI score, but now I'm worried the calculation is wrong. For experienced FAFSA parents: 1) Is the system supposed to skip asking about 529 plans and investments? Was this intentional with the new FAFSA? 2) If I'm actually required to report these assets, how do I add them after submission? 3) Will our SAI increase once this information is included? My daughter got into her dream school but the aid package will determine if we can afford it. I don't want to mess this up. Thanks in advance!
22 comments


Emma Olsen
Don't panic! The new simplified FAFSA intentionally eliminated questions about many assets that used to be included. If your family's AGI is under $60,000, OR if you received certain means-tested federal benefits, OR if your student is an independent with dependents, the system automatically excludes asset questions. The IRS Data Retrieval Tool takes care of the income reporting, and for many families, that's now all that's required. If you weren't asked those questions, it likely means you qualified for this simplification, and your SAI calculation is correct based on the current formula. The system is working as designed.
0 coins
Christian Bierman
•Thank you so much for explaining! Our AGI is actually around $78,000 so I don't think we fall under that $60k threshold. We definitely didn't receive any federal benefits either. Could there be another reason they skipped those questions? I'm so nervous about getting this right.
0 coins
Lucas Lindsey
same thing happend to me!! i submitted last week and it never asked about my wifes 401k or our savings account. the number they gave us for SAI seems really low compared to what the old EFC calculator estimated. not complainin tho lol
0 coins
Emma Olsen
•The simplified formula doesn't consider retirement accounts like 401ks anyway (those were always protected), but there definitely should have been questions about savings if your income was above certain thresholds. You might want to double-check if there were other factors that qualified you for the simplified needs analysis.
0 coins
Sophie Duck
This is actually a known issue with the new FAFSA system that rolled out. The asset questions should have appeared for families with income above the simplified needs threshold (generally $60,000 AGI). If your AGI is above that amount and you weren't presented with asset questions, you should contact Federal Student Aid to report the issue. You might need to submit a correction once they resolve it. And yes, your SAI will likely increase if they end up including your assets in the calculation. The general formula counts about 5.64% of parent assets above a protection allowance toward the SAI. So for example, if you have $50,000 in reportable assets after the protection allowance, your SAI might increase by about $2,820.
0 coins
Christian Bierman
•Oh no, that's what I was afraid of! I've been trying to call Federal Student Aid for days but can't get through. The phone system just disconnects after 20+ minutes on hold. This is so stressful since financial aid packages are being calculated right now.
0 coins
Austin Leonard
I had the same problem trying to reach FSA about a verification issue. After wasting hours on hold, I found a service called Claimyr (claimyr.com) that actually got me through to a live agent in about 10 minutes. They have a video showing how it works: https://youtu.be/TbC8dZQWYNQ Their system holds your place in line so you don't have to stay on the phone yourself. When I finally got through, the agent confirmed there's a known issue with asset questions not displaying properly for some applicants, and they could note it in my file.
0 coins
Christian Bierman
•Thank you! I'll check this out today. Did they tell you if this would affect your SAI or if they're going to fix the issue soon? I'm worried my daughter's financial aid package will be calculated with incorrect information.
0 coins
Anita George
anyone know how much the sai goes up if u add assets? we have like $25k in savings and my kid got a 12000 sai with just the income stuff. will it completely mess everything up if they add assets later??
0 coins
Sophie Duck
•Parent assets are assessed at a maximum rate of 5.64% after protection allowances. The protection allowance varies based on your family situation, but is typically $10,000+ for most families. So if you have $25,000 in savings and qualify for a $10,000 protection allowance, only $15,000 would be counted. At 5.64%, that would increase your SAI by about $846. Not insignificant but not catastrophic for most aid packages.
0 coins
Abigail Spencer
The new FAFSA is a DISASTER!!! I work in a financial aid office and we're seeing this CONSTANTLY. The Dept of Education rushed out a half-broken system and now students are paying the price. The asset questions SHOULD appear for families above the simplified needs threshold, but the system is glitchy and unpredictable. Some families get the questions, others don't. Sometimes it depends on which browser you're using! And here's the worst part - some schools are holding aid packages until issues are resolved while others are just going ahead with whatever SAI they received, right or wrong. It's a MESS!
0 coins
Christian Bierman
•That's terrifying! Do you think I should reach out directly to my daughter's college financial aid office to explain the situation? Would they be able to help or should I keep trying to get through to FSA?
0 coins
Sophie Duck
To answer your questions directly: 1) You ARE supposed to report assets like 529 plans, investments, and bank accounts if your income is above ~$60,000. The fact that you weren't asked is a system error. 2) You'll need to submit a correction once you reach FSA. Currently, there's no self-service way to add asset information if the questions weren't displayed initially. 3) Yes, your SAI will increase once assets are included, but the impact is fairly modest. Parent assets are assessed at 5.64% after protection allowances. For 529 plans specifically, they count as parent assets (which is better than being counted as student assets). If the 529 is owned by a grandparent, it's not reported as an asset but distributions will count as student income on future FAFSAs.
0 coins
Christian Bierman
•Thank you for the clear explanation! We have about $45k in the 529 and maybe $30k in other investments/savings. So it sounds like our SAI might increase by a few thousand dollars. I finally got through to FSA and they confirmed I need to submit a correction once they fix the asset question bug in their system.
0 coins
Logan Chiang
Just adding - dont forget that with the new FAFSA, they increased the income protection allowance which means less of your income counts toward the SAI. So even tho assets might add some $$ to ur SAI, overall many families are getting lower SAIs than with the old system. My sons SAI came in 4k lower than what the old EFC calculator estimated last year!
0 coins
Emma Olsen
•That's a great point! The income protection allowance increases are substantial in the new formula. For a family of four with one college student, the protection allowance increased from about $30,000 to nearly $50,000. This means less of your income counts toward the SAI, which can offset some or all of the asset contribution.
0 coins
Christian Bierman
Update: I finally got through to someone at Federal Student Aid! They confirmed there's a known issue with asset questions not displaying for some applicants. They said I should contact my daughter's school's financial aid office directly to let them know about the issue. They're planning to release a fix soon that will allow affected applicants to submit corrections and add asset information. In the meantime, they're notifying schools about the issue so they can take it into account when preparing aid packages. Thanks everyone for your help! This community has been amazing.
0 coins
Abigail Spencer
•Glad you got through! Just so you know, most schools are AWARE of the issue but their response varies wildly. Some will hold your aid package until the correction is processed, others will estimate what your assets might be, and some will just use whatever SAI the system gave them. DEFINITELY contact your specific school to see how they're handling it!
0 coins
CosmicVoyager
•Thanks for posting the update! This is really helpful for other parents dealing with the same issue. I'm a newcomer here but have been lurking and learning so much from everyone's experiences. My son is a junior so I'll be dealing with FAFSA next year - posts like this are invaluable for understanding what to expect. Really glad you got some answers and that the schools are being notified about the bug!
0 coins
AstroAdventurer
As someone new to this community but currently navigating the FAFSA maze with my own family, this thread has been incredibly enlightening! We're dealing with a similar situation where the asset questions never appeared despite our income being well above the simplified needs threshold. It's both reassuring and frustrating to know this is a widespread system issue rather than user error. I've been beating myself up thinking I somehow missed or skipped important sections. The information about the 5.64% assessment rate for parent assets and the increased income protection allowances in the new formula is really helpful for setting expectations. Thanks to everyone who shared their experiences and solutions - especially the tip about Claimyr for getting through to FSA! This community is such a valuable resource for confused parents trying to navigate financial aid.
0 coins
Levi Parker
•Welcome to the community! I'm also new here and going through this exact same situation. It's such a relief to find out this isn't something we did wrong - the new FAFSA system really seems to have some serious bugs. I've been following this thread closely since my family has about $35k in assets that weren't reported either. The math examples everyone provided about the 5.64% assessment rate really help put things in perspective. Even if our SAI goes up by $1,000-2,000 when they fix this, it sounds like the overall changes to the formula might still leave us better off than the old system. Thanks for sharing your experience too - it helps to know we're all figuring this out together!
0 coins
Lauren Wood
Just wanted to add my perspective as another newcomer dealing with this exact issue! My family's FAFSA also skipped the asset questions despite our AGI being around $85k. We have a decent amount in 529 plans and savings that should have been reported. What's been most helpful from this thread is understanding that this is a known system bug, not something we did wrong. I was panicking that I somehow missed critical sections or filled something out incorrectly. The detailed explanations about how parent assets are assessed (5.64% after protection allowances) and the examples of how much SAI might increase have really helped manage my expectations. I'm planning to try the Claimyr service mentioned earlier to get through to FSA, and I'll definitely reach out to my daughter's financial aid office proactively to let them know about the situation. Thanks to everyone for sharing their experiences and solutions - this community has been invaluable for a stressed parent trying to navigate this broken system!
0 coins