FAFSA Parent PLUS Loan denied - success with appeals or alternatives?
Just found out my Parent PLUS loan application was denied due to 'adverse credit history' (which is ridiculous because I only had one late payment last year on my car). My daughter is starting her junior year and now we're panicking about how to cover the $11,500 gap in her tuition. The financial aid office just handed her a sheet about private loans, but she has zero credit history and no family members who could cosign. Has anyone successfully appealed a Parent PLUS loan denial? What documentation did you need to provide? Or if you couldn't get the appeal approved, what alternatives did you find? Her school says she might qualify for some additional unsubsidized loans because of the PLUS denial, but it's nowhere near enough to cover everything. Any advice appreciated - orientation is in 3 weeks and we're desperate!
23 comments


Olivia Harris
Yes, I successfully appealed a Parent PLUS loan denial last year! The key is understanding that the Department of Education considers very specific things as 'adverse credit history.' In my case, I had a medical collection I didn't even know about that was causing the denial. For a successful appeal, you need to: 1. Request your credit report to identify the exact issue 2. Document the extenuating circumstances (one-time event, medical emergency, etc.) 3. Get a letter from your employer confirming stable income 4. Submit the appeal through studentaid.gov with all supporting documentation Alternatively, your daughter automatically qualifies for increased unsubsidized loan amounts due to the PLUS denial. The increase isn't huge (usually about $4,000-$5,000 per year for juniors), but it helps.
0 coins
James Martinez
•Thank you so much for this detailed answer! I hadn't thought about getting a letter from my employer - that's brilliant. Do you remember how long your appeal process took? I'm worried because classes start soon and I don't know if we'll have enough time.
0 coins
Alexander Zeus
my sons plus loan was denied to. we tryed appealing it but got nowhere. the financial aid office was useless kept telling us to try private loans but who the heck is going to give a 19 yr old a loan with no credit??? ended up having to take a semester off and work full time. so frustrating
0 coins
Alicia Stern
•This happens WAY more than people realize! The whole system is set up to trap families in impossible situations. Either take on crushing debt or drop out. It's disgusting.
0 coins
Gabriel Graham
Contact your daughter's financial aid office IMMEDIATELY and ask about these options: 1. Additional unsubsidized loans (which you mentioned) - this is automatic with a PLUS denial 2. Emergency institutional grants - many schools have emergency funds for students in your situation 3. Payment plans - might be able to spread remaining costs over monthly payments 4. Professional judgment review - if your financial situation has changed since filing FAFSA Also, one late car payment shouldn't trigger a PLUS denial unless it was 90+ days late or sent to collections. Request your credit report right away to see what's actually causing the denial. Something else might be on there you don't know about.
0 coins
James Martinez
•We did ask about emergency grants but they said those are only for students already enrolled who face unexpected expenses during the semester. The payment plan option might work for part of it though - they offer a 5-month plan each semester. I'll definitely check my credit report this afternoon.
0 coins
Drake
I've been trying to reach someone at FSA about our PLUS loan denial for WEEKS with no luck. Always disconnected or on hold forever. Finally used Claimyr (claimyr.com) yesterday and got through to an actual human in 20 minutes who explained exactly why our PLUS was denied and what documentation we needed for appeal. They have a video showing how it works: https://youtu.be/TbC8dZQWYNQ Turns out our denial was due to a tax lien from 2019 that was already resolved but still showing on my credit. The FSA agent walked me through the exact appeal documentation needed.
0 coins
Alexander Zeus
•does this actully work? ive spent hours on hold with fsa and never get through to anyone
0 coins
Drake
•Yes, it actually did work for me. I was super skeptical too, but I was desperate after trying for days on my own. The service basically holds your place in line so you don't have to stay on hold yourself.
0 coins
Sarah Jones
Here's something many don't realize: if your Parent PLUS loan is denied, your daughter automatically becomes eligible for increased unsubsidized loan limits - the same higher limits that independent students get! For a junior, that's an additional $5,000 per year beyond the standard dependent student limits. For any remaining gap, look into these options: - School payment plans (usually interest-free) - Part-time campus employment - many roles pay above minimum wage - Local credit union private loans - sometimes have better terms for students - Scholarship search - even mid-year, there are opportunities DON'T panic and pull out high-interest credit cards or predatory private loans. A gap year is better than crushing debt.
0 coins
James Martinez
•Thank you! Yes, the financial aid office mentioned she'd qualify for an additional $5,000 in unsubsidized loans, but that still leaves us about $6,500 short for the year. I hadn't thought about credit unions - that's a great idea. Do you know if they typically require cosigners too?
0 coins
Sarah Jones
•Most credit unions will still require a cosigner for student loans, unfortunately. However, they often have more flexible credit requirements for cosigners than big banks or online lenders. Some also offer emergency loans with smaller amounts ($2,000-$3,000) that might be easier to qualify for. Definitely worth checking with 2-3 local ones.
0 coins
Sebastian Scott
My daughter had same problem last yr. What worked for us was getting the extra unsubsidized loan then doing a combo of payment plan + she got an on-campus job. The office also found her some small scholarship that had gone unclaimed for $1200. Every little bit helped!
0 coins
James Martinez
•That's encouraging to hear! I'll definitely ask about unclaimed scholarships - that never occurred to me. Thank you!
0 coins
Alicia Stern
THE WHOLE PARENT PLUS SYSTEM IS A SCAM!!! They KNOW parents will get denied then what?? Your kid just doesn't get an education? Or you take out PREDATORY private loans?? And the schools just keep raising tuition because they know the govt keeps handing out loans. It's all a racket designed to trap families in debt!!
0 coins
Alexander Zeus
•EXACTLY!!! my son had to drop out because of this exact reason and now works at walmart instead of getting his engineering degree. the system is totally rigged against middle class families
0 coins
Gabriel Graham
Quick update on timelines since you mentioned classes starting soon: A Parent PLUS loan appeal typically takes 2-3 weeks to process. However, most schools will allow students to start classes with a pending appeal if you've submitted all documentation and have a payment plan in place for the remaining balance. I recommend: 1. Call financial aid office tomorrow and explain the situation 2. Ask about a temporary "registration hold waiver" while the appeal is processing 3. Get written confirmation of what happens if the appeal is denied 4. Submit a payment plan application for at least part of the balance This prevents your daughter from missing the start of classes while you're sorting out the funding.
0 coins
James Martinez
•This is SO helpful! I didn't know about registration hold waivers. We have an appointment with financial aid tomorrow morning and I'll definitely bring this up. Thank you!
0 coins
Sarah Jones
After reading through this thread, I want to mention one more option that hasn't been discussed. Some schools have Parent PLUS Loan alternative programs designed specifically for families who get denied. These institutional loans often have more flexible credit requirements and sometimes lower interest rates than private loans. They're not widely advertised because schools don't want everyone choosing them over PLUS loans, but they exist at many institutions. Ask specifically: "Does the university offer any institutional loan alternatives for families denied for Parent PLUS loans?" Sometimes they're called "bridge loans" or "gap funding programs.
0 coins
James Martinez
•I had no idea this was even a possibility! Will definitely ask about this tomorrow. I've been so stressed about this situation that I haven't been sleeping - feeling a little more hopeful now with all these suggestions. Thank you everyone.
0 coins
Diez Ellis
I'm a financial aid counselor and want to add a few important points that might help your situation: First, regarding the appeal - you mentioned only one late car payment, but PLUS loan denials are typically triggered by delinquencies 90+ days past due, bankruptcies, foreclosures, or tax liens. Check your credit report from all three bureaus (Experian, Equifax, TransUnion) as there might be something else you're not aware of. Second, here's a strategy many families miss: If your appeal is denied, consider having your daughter's other parent (if applicable) apply for the PLUS loan instead. Each parent can apply separately, and one denial doesn't affect the other parent's eligibility. Third, contact your state's higher education agency - many states have emergency grant programs for students facing funding gaps. These are often overlooked but can provide $1,000-$3,000 in additional aid. Finally, if you're truly stuck, consider having your daughter take just 3/4 time enrollment (9-11 credits instead of 12+) for one semester. This reduces costs while maintaining financial aid eligibility, and she can make up credits during summer or winter sessions when costs are often lower. Don't give up - there are usually more options than initially apparent!
0 coins
Marina Hendrix
•This is incredibly helpful advice from a professional perspective! I never thought about having my wife apply for the PLUS loan separately - we just assumed since I was denied, that was it. She has better credit than me anyway. The 3/4 time enrollment idea is also brilliant. My daughter could take 9 credits in fall and make up the difference with a winter intersession course, which would spread out the costs and give us more time to figure out funding for spring semester. I'm definitely going to look into our state's emergency grant programs too. We're in Ohio - do you happen to know if they have anything like that here? Either way, you've given me a much clearer action plan. Thank you so much!
0 coins
Amina Sow
I'm dealing with a similar situation right now - got my PLUS loan denial letter two weeks ago and have been scrambling ever since. Reading through all these responses has been incredibly helpful, especially learning about institutional loan alternatives and the possibility of having my spouse apply separately. One thing I discovered that might help others: if you're working with a financial aid office that seems unhelpful, try calling the main financial aid number and asking to speak with a senior counselor or supervisor. Sometimes the front-line staff don't know about all available options, but the supervisors have access to emergency funds and alternative programs that aren't widely advertised. Also, I found out that some schools will allow you to audit a class (sit in without credit) for a much lower fee if you're just one or two credits short of full-time status due to financial constraints. It's not ideal, but it can help maintain enrollment status while you work out the funding issues. Hang in there - this process is incredibly stressful but there really are more options than it initially seems!
0 coins