


Ask the community...
So glad to see this thread - I'm going through the exact same thing with my twin daughters! It's reassuring to know this confusion is normal. One thing I learned from our school counselor is that you can also check each college's financial aid portal online if they have one. Sometimes the aid packages are posted there before they mail them out. Also, if you haven't already, make sure to check that all your FAFSA information was received correctly by each school - sometimes there are little technical glitches that delay processing. Wishing you and your daughter the best with this process! It's stressful but you're asking all the right questions.
This is such great advice about checking the online portals! I didn't even think to look there. Twin daughters applying to college - wow, that must be twice the stress and paperwork! Thanks for mentioning the technical glitches too. I'm definitely going to double-check that all the schools properly received our FAFSA info. It's so reassuring to know other families are navigating this same confusing process. Good luck with your twins' applications!
As someone who just went through this process with my son last year, I want to emphasize what others have said - you are 100% in the right to demand financial aid packages before committing! We had a similar situation where one school was pressuring us for an early deposit. I called the dean of admissions directly (not just financial aid) and explained that we needed the aid package to make an informed decision. They not only provided it within 48 hours but also apologized for the confusion. One tip that saved us: create a simple spreadsheet to compare all the offers side by side. Look at total cost of attendance minus grants/scholarships to get your real out-of-pocket cost. Some schools pad their packages with loans and work-study to make them look more generous than they actually are. Also, don't be afraid to mention to schools that you're still waiting on other aid packages. Sometimes this motivates them to prioritize your file. The financial aid process is definitely confusing, but you're advocating for your daughter exactly as you should be!
As someone who went through this exact situation with my twins two years ago, I want to offer some hope and practical advice. Both kids had high SAIs and initially received minimal aid from their top choices. Here's what actually worked for us: 1) We created a detailed spreadsheet showing the 4-year total cost difference between schools and presented it during an in-person meeting with financial aid - this visual really helped them understand our position. 2) We discovered that one school had a "President's Emergency Fund" for students who demonstrated exceptional need after enrollment - my daughter received $4,000 her sophomore year from this fund. 3) Most importantly, we negotiated a payment plan that allowed us to spread costs over 12 months instead of per semester, which significantly improved our cash flow. Don't give up! The key is being respectful but persistent, and timing your follow-ups strategically. Also, make sure your son applies for departmental scholarships every year - we found that upperclassman scholarships are often less competitive than freshman awards.
This is exactly the kind of detailed, actionable advice I was hoping for! The spreadsheet idea is brilliant - presenting the visual comparison of 4-year total costs probably carries much more weight than just talking about it. I'm definitely going to put that together before scheduling meetings. The President's Emergency Fund sounds like something I should specifically ask about - these hidden funding sources seem to be everywhere once you know to look for them. And the 12-month payment plan could be a game-changer for cash flow management. Thank you for sharing what actually worked in practice rather than just theory. It gives me real confidence that persistence can pay off. I'll make sure to bookmark this thread and come back with updates on how our approach goes!
I'm dealing with this exact situation right now! My daughter got into her dream school but with zero merit aid despite a 3.9 GPA and strong test scores. Meanwhile, she got generous packages from three other schools. After reading through all these responses, I'm realizing I've been way too passive about this process. I had assumed the initial financial aid package was final, but clearly there are more options to explore. I'm particularly intrigued by the suggestions about departmental scholarships and the timing around May 1st when funding might become available. Has anyone had success with presenting multiple competing offers at once, or is it better to focus on just the best alternative? Also, for those who scheduled in-person meetings - did you meet with a specific person or just request a general appointment with financial aid? I want to make sure I'm approaching this strategically rather than just showing up unprepared. This thread has been a lifesaver - thank you all for sharing your experiences!
Just wanted to follow up - were you able to resolve this? I had a thought that might help. If you go into your student's account (not the parent's FSA ID), then navigate to the application, sometimes more options appear that aren't visible from the parent login. Also, try using a different browser completely - I've found Chrome works better than Safari for the FAFSA site.
We actually tried using Claimyr like someone suggested above, and it worked great! Got through to an agent after about 45 minutes (instead of the 3+ hours we were expecting). The agent confirmed it was a glitch and manually added the second contributor while we were on the phone. Our application is finally complete! Now just waiting for the SAI calculation. Thanks everyone for your help and suggestions!
That's great news that you got it resolved! For anyone else reading this thread who might be dealing with similar FAFSA contributor issues, here are a few additional tips that have helped other families: 1. Try accessing the FAFSA from different devices - sometimes mobile vs desktop shows different options 2. If you're still stuck, document everything with screenshots before calling FSA support - it helps them understand the issue faster 3. Consider calling early in the morning (around 8 AM EST) when wait times tend to be shorter 4. Have all your tax documents and FSA IDs ready before calling so they can fix everything in one session The 2025-2026 FAFSA definitely has more bugs than previous years, but most issues can be resolved with persistence. Don't give up - your daughter's financial aid is worth the hassle!
Thank you for these additional tips! I'm actually dealing with a similar issue right now with my son's FAFSA application. The mobile vs desktop suggestion is really helpful - I hadn't thought to try that. It's reassuring to know that these problems are being resolved even though the process is frustrating. I'll definitely try calling early in the morning before the lines get too busy. Has anyone had success with the live chat feature, or is calling still the best option?
As a newcomer to this whole financial aid process, this thread has been incredibly enlightening! I'm in a similar situation with my son applying for Fall 2025, and I was completely unaware that the CSS Profile even existed until I started researching. One thing I'm still confused about - if a school uses both FAFSA and CSS Profile, do they create one combined financial aid package, or do you get separate offers based on each form? Also, has anyone found any good resources or websites that clearly list which schools require the CSS Profile? I'm trying to avoid having to check each individual college website if there's a comprehensive list somewhere. Thank you all for sharing your experiences - it's really helping those of us just starting this journey!
Welcome to the process! To answer your questions: schools that use both forms create one combined financial aid package - they don't give you separate offers. The CSS Profile just gives them more detailed information to work with when calculating your institutional aid. For finding which schools require CSS Profile, the College Board has a search tool on their website where you can look up participating schools. You can also use sites like BigFuture or just search "[school name] CSS Profile required" to quickly check. Most private colleges and some scholarship programs use it, while public universities typically stick to FAFSA only. One tip: when you're on college websites, look for their "Financial Aid Requirements" or "How to Apply for Aid" pages - they'll clearly state if CSS Profile is required and what their deadlines are. Good luck with your son's applications!
This thread has been so helpful! I'm also navigating this for the first time with my daughter. One thing I'm curious about - for families who own small businesses or have rental properties, how much more complicated does the CSS Profile get compared to FAFSA? I keep seeing mentions that it asks for "detailed business information" but I'm not sure what that actually means in practice. Does anyone have experience with this specific situation? I'm worried we might need to hire someone to help us fill it out correctly if it's too complex.
Mateo Silva
I'm so glad I found this thread! I'm in the exact same boat - filed my 2024 taxes about a month ago and the IRS website still just says "being processed." I was getting really anxious about my FAFSA deadlines coming up next week. Reading everyone's experiences here has been such a relief. It sounds like the universal advice is to submit the FAFSA now with my best estimates from what I actually filed, check that IRS consent box, and then come back later to use the Data Retrieval Tool once processing is complete. I love the tip about taking screenshots before submitting and adding a note in the additional information section explaining the tax processing delay. Those are details I never would have thought of but make total sense. One quick question - for those who went through this, about how long after the IRS website changed from "being processed" to "processed" did you wait before trying the Data Retrieval Tool? I want to make sure I don't try too early and run into issues. Thanks everyone for sharing your experiences - this has been incredibly helpful for a stressed out student! 😅
0 coins
Savannah Weiner
•Hey Mateo! I waited about a week after my IRS status changed to "processed" before trying the Data Retrieval Tool, and that worked perfectly for me. Some people say you can try right away once it shows processed, but I wanted to be safe since I'd heard sometimes there can be a small delay between when IRS shows "processed" and when the data is actually available for FAFSA to pull. The screenshot tip really is a game changer - it saved me so much time when I was double-checking everything after the data import! And honestly, adding that note about the processing delay in the additional info section just felt like good communication with the schools. It shows you're being proactive about the situation rather than just hoping they figure it out. Don't stress too much about the timing - sounds like you're handling this exactly right by submitting with estimates now rather than missing those deadlines. The whole process ended up being way less scary than I thought it would be! 😊
0 coins
Oliver Weber
I just went through this exact same situation for my 2025-2026 FAFSA! Filed my taxes in mid-February but the IRS took almost 7 weeks to process them. I was so stressed about missing priority deadlines, but everything worked out perfectly. Here's what I learned: definitely submit your FAFSA NOW with your best estimates based on what you filed. Don't wait for IRS processing to complete - that could take weeks longer and you'll miss those crucial priority deadlines. When you check the consent box, you're just giving permission for future data retrieval, not requiring it to work immediately. The process was actually really smooth once I stopped overthinking it. I submitted in early March with estimates, then went back in late April after my taxes were fully processed. The IRS Data Retrieval Tool was easy to find in my studentaid.gov account - just look for "Transfer Tax Information from the IRS" under the update section. My SAI ended up changing by less than 50 points, and all my schools automatically received the updated information. No verification issues, no delays in aid processing. The financial aid offices I spoke with said this timing issue is super common and they're totally prepared for it. Bottom line: submit with estimates today rather than risk missing priority consideration. You can always perfect the numbers later with official tax data!
0 coins
KingKongZilla
•This is exactly the reassurance I needed to hear! Your timeline is really helpful - 7 weeks for IRS processing is longer than I expected, so it's great to know that even with that delay, everything worked out smoothly for you. The fact that your SAI only changed by less than 50 points after the official data came through is really encouraging too. I think I was getting too caught up in trying to make everything perfect instead of just getting the application submitted. Reading through everyone's experiences in this thread has made it clear that schools really do expect and plan for this timing issue. I'm definitely going to follow your advice and submit with my best estimates today rather than risk missing those priority deadlines. Thanks for sharing the specific details about the Data Retrieval Tool location in the studentaid.gov account - that's going to save me time when I need to go back and update everything later. It's such a relief to know this is a common situation and not something I messed up by not filing my taxes earlier!
0 coins