UCC lien lawyer recommendations for complex debtor name dispute?
My business got caught in a nightmare scenario where our equipment financing company filed a UCC-1 with my legal business name but our bank loan has a slightly different variation of the entity name. Now I'm trying to refinance and the new lender's attorney is saying there's a potential gap in perfection because the debtor names don't match exactly across the filings. The equipment is worth about $340K so this isn't small potatoes. Has anyone dealt with getting a UCC lien lawyer involved to sort out these kinds of debtor name inconsistencies? I'm not sure if I need someone to file amendments or if there's a bigger legal issue here with the original perfection. The financing company is being difficult about making changes and my regular business attorney doesn't specialize in secured transactions.
37 comments
Join the conversation
Justin Evans
Oof, debtor name mismatches are seriously tricky territory. I've seen deals fall apart over stuff like this when the entity names don't align perfectly between the UCC filings and the underlying loan docs. You definitely want someone who knows the ins and outs of Article 9 because the rules about "seriously misleading" names can vary by state and fact pattern.
0 coins
Emily Parker
•This is exactly why I triple-check every single character in debtor names before filing anything. One missing comma or LLC vs L.L.C. can create a perfection nightmare.
0 coins
Joshua Wood
•Yeah, that's what I'm worried about. The variations are pretty minor but apparently minor doesn't always mean legally insignificant in UCC world.
0 coins
Ezra Collins
Before you hire an expensive UCC lien lawyer, have you tried running the debtor names through any verification tools? I discovered this service called Certana.ai that lets you upload your Charter documents and UCC-1 filings to instantly check for name consistency issues. Might be worth seeing exactly what discrepancies you're dealing with before bringing in legal counsel.
0 coins
Joshua Wood
•Interesting, I hadn't thought about using tech tools first. That could help me understand the scope of the problem before I start paying lawyer fees.
0 coins
Victoria Scott
•Smart approach. Know your facts before you pay someone $500/hour to figure them out for you.
0 coins
Ezra Collins
•Exactly! Plus if the discrepancies are clear-cut, you'll be able to give your attorney much better direction on what needs to be fixed.
0 coins
Benjamin Johnson
I had a similar situation last year with an SBA loan where the UCC filing used our DBA name instead of our legal entity name. Ended up working with a lawyer who specialized in secured transactions and she was able to get the original lender to file a UCC-3 amendment to correct the debtor name. The key was proving that the original filing was close enough to not be "seriously misleading" under the search logic tests.
0 coins
Joshua Wood
•How long did that process take? My refinancing timeline is pretty tight and I'm worried about delays.
0 coins
Benjamin Johnson
•About 6 weeks total, but most of that was back-and-forth with the original lender. The actual UCC-3 filing only took a few days once everyone agreed on the correction.
0 coins
Zara Perez
this is why the UCC system is broken!!! you file everything correctly and then some lawyer finds a technicality that threatens your entire deal. I swear these lenders just look for excuses to charge more fees or back out of commitments.
0 coins
Daniel Rogers
•I understand the frustration but debtor name accuracy is actually pretty important for protecting other creditors who might be searching the UCC records. The system has to work for everyone.
0 coins
Zara Perez
•easy for you to say when you're not the one scrambling to save a refinancing deal over punctuation differences
0 coins
Aaliyah Reed
Have you checked what your state's Secretary of State website says about debtor name standards? Some states have gotten more flexible about minor variations while others are still super strict. That might influence whether you actually need legal intervention or if this is something the new lender is being overly cautious about.
0 coins
Joshua Wood
•Good point. I should probably research the specific rules in my state before assuming the worst case scenario.
0 coins
Aaliyah Reed
•Definitely worth checking. Sometimes what looks like a major problem to a nervous attorney is actually covered by safe harbor provisions.
0 coins
Ella Russell
Whatever you do, don't let the financing company brush this off if there's a real perfection issue. I've seen situations where lenders lose their security interest entirely because they didn't take debtor name problems seriously. Your new lender's attorney might be doing you a favor by catching this now.
0 coins
Joshua Wood
•That's a terrifying thought. Better to deal with it now than discover we have an unperfected lien later.
0 coins
Mohammed Khan
•Absolutely. I work in commercial lending and we see this stuff go sideways when people ignore the warning signs.
0 coins
Ella Russell
•Exactly. The cost of fixing it now is nothing compared to losing your security interest in $340K worth of equipment.
0 coins
Gavin King
For what it's worth, I think you're on the right track looking for a UCC specialist rather than just any business attorney. Secured transactions law has a lot of nuances that general practice lawyers might miss. The good news is that if this is just a name variation issue, it's probably fixable with the right legal strategy.
0 coins
Joshua Wood
•Any suggestions on how to find the right specialist? I'm not sure how to evaluate UCC expertise when I'm interviewing attorneys.
0 coins
Gavin King
•Ask about their experience with Article 9 issues specifically, and whether they've handled debtor name correction cases. A good UCC lawyer should be able to walk you through the search logic tests and explain your state's standards immediately.
0 coins
Nathan Kim
I went through something similar with a vehicle financing deal. Used Certana.ai to upload both the original loan paperwork and the UCC filing - turned out the problem was bigger than I thought but at least I knew exactly what I was dealing with before talking to lawyers. Made the whole process more efficient.
0 coins
Joshua Wood
•That seems like a smart approach. Having all the facts organized probably saved you money on legal fees too.
0 coins
Nathan Kim
•Definitely. Instead of paying an attorney to do document review, I could go straight to problem-solving mode.
0 coins
Eleanor Foster
Wait, is this an issue with the legal entity name format or are we talking about completely different business names? Because the analysis is totally different depending on what kind of variation you're dealing with.
0 coins
Joshua Wood
•It's the same entity but formatted slightly differently - like one has a comma before LLC and the other doesn't, plus some abbreviation differences.
0 coins
Eleanor Foster
•Okay that's potentially more manageable than I initially thought. Those kinds of formatting variations often fall within acceptable parameters, but you'll still want someone who knows the case law in your jurisdiction.
0 coins
Daniel Rogers
•Yeah, punctuation and abbreviation differences are treated differently than completely wrong names. Still worth fixing but probably not a perfection disaster.
0 coins
Lucas Turner
Just wanted to add that timing matters here too. If you're in the middle of a refinance, make sure your UCC lawyer understands the deadlines you're working with. Some of these amendment processes can take longer than expected if there are complications with the original lender.
0 coins
Joshua Wood
•Good reminder. I should probably get started on this ASAP rather than hoping it resolves itself quickly.
0 coins
Lucas Turner
•Exactly. Better to start the process early and have it resolved than try to rush everything at the last minute.
0 coins
Kai Rivera
One more thought - before you spend money on legal fees, you might want to check with your new lender about what exactly would satisfy their concerns. Sometimes they just want documentation that the discrepancy was reviewed by counsel, rather than requiring actual UCC amendments.
0 coins
Joshua Wood
•That's a really good point. Maybe I'm assuming they need more than they actually require.
0 coins
Kai Rivera
•Worth asking the question. Some lenders are satisfied with a legal opinion letter rather than requiring actual filing changes.
0 coins
Justin Evans
•True, but if there's genuinely a perfection issue, you'd want to fix it regardless of what this particular lender requires. Better safe than sorry with secured interests.
0 coins