Our SAI score finally came in at 6254 - better than expected with new FAFSA calculation
After months of waiting and stressing, we FINALLY got our Student Aid Index (SAI) score today - 6254! I honestly expected worse with all the horror stories about the new FAFSA system. For those curious, our household income is around $78K with two parents working, and we've got a daughter starting college this fall and another kid still in high school. This is our first time through the process, and I was expecting an SAI above 8000 based on what I've read online. Our daughter's top choice school uses both FAFSA and CSS Profile for financial aid decisions, so I'm hoping this relatively low SAI translates to a decent aid package. Anyone know how colleges typically interpret an SAI in the 6000 range? Now begins the scholarship hunt to cover whatever gaps we'll have! This whole FAFSA system has been so unnecessarily stressful with the delays and website glitches.
20 comments


CosmicCommander
Congratulations on getting your SAI! A 6254 is actually pretty good in the new system - definitely on the lower side of middle income. Most schools will view that favorably for need-based aid consideration. For reference, 0 is the lowest possible SAI (maximum need) and anything above 15000-20000 starts to limit your federal aid options significantly. Make sure to contact each financial aid office directly - they often have institutional funds they can offer beyond what the federal methodology calculates. Have your daughter look into merit scholarships too, as those aren't based on your FAFSA results at all!
0 coins
Amara Okafor
•Thank you so much for that context! That makes me feel better about our situation. I wasn't sure where 6254 fell on the spectrum. Do you know if schools that use both FAFSA and CSS Profile tend to offer better packages when the SAI is in this range? Her top choice is pretty expensive (around $58K/year for tuition and housing).
0 coins
Giovanni Colombo
thats awesome!! my family got 11,689 and we were so disappointed. thought we would qualify for more with the new formula since were single income household but i guess not lol. good luck with scholarships!!
0 coins
Fatima Al-Qasimi
•SAME. Our SAI came back at 9,842 with similar income ($81K) but we have 3 kids. Makes absolutely NO sense. The old EFC system was way more predictable. Definitely recommend everyone appeal their aid packages once they come in - the colleges have more flexibility than most people realize.
0 coins
Dylan Cooper
Your SAI of 6254 is definitely on the lower end compared to what many families are seeing this year. The new FAFSA formula has been a mixed bag - some families are seeing better results while others are facing higher SAIs than with the old EFC system. For school-specific financial aid, I'd recommend contacting each financial aid office directly once you receive their aid packages. For many schools, an SAI in the 6000 range should qualify for decent need-based aid, though the exact amount varies widely between institutions. Private schools with larger endowments often can offer more generous packages than state schools. For scholarships, look into: - School-specific merit scholarships (often automatic based on GPA/test scores) - Your local community foundation - Parents' employers - Professional associations in your daughter's intended field - Fastweb.com and scholarships.com Finally, don't hesitate to appeal any aid offer that seems insufficient. Many schools have additional institutional funds they can allocate, especially if you can document any special circumstances.
0 coins
Amara Okafor
•Thank you for the detailed response! I've already started making a spreadsheet of scholarship opportunities. Do you know how much the CSS Profile might change things? Her top school requires both FAFSA and CSS, and I've heard the Profile looks at more assets than FAFSA does.
0 coins
Sofia Ramirez
The FAFSA system this year is a COMPLETE DISASTER! I've filed FAFSAs for my kids since 2016 and have NEVER seen such a poorly executed rollout. They delayed the form release, then released a buggy system, then took MONTHS to process applications. And now we're all scrambling for remaining scholarship money because everything is so late in the cycle! But congrats on your SAI - that's actually pretty good. My daughter's came back at 12,890 which is way higher than our old EFC was last year. Makes absolutely no sense since they claimed the new formula would help more families qualify for aid. What a joke!
0 coins
Dmitry Volkov
•Yep, they really messed this up. I've been trying to reach someone at Federal Student Aid for weeks to fix an error on our application (my husband's income somehow got doubled). I was getting disconnected or waiting 3+ hours. Finally used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through - they handle the hold time and call you when an agent picks up. Saw their video demo (https://youtu.be/TbC8dZQWYNQ) and it saved me so much time. Got the issue fixed in 10 minutes once I actually reached someone.
0 coins
StarSeeker
Anyone know how a 6254 SAI translates to actual aid? My daughter got accepted to three schools, but we're still waiting on financial aid packages because of all the FAFSA delays. I know Pell Grants go to students with SAIs under 3000 (I think), but what other federal aid would typically be available for an SAI in the 6000 range? Just trying to prepare ourselves for what to expect.
0 coins
CosmicCommander
•With an SAI of 6254, you'll likely qualify for: - Subsidized Direct Loans (the government pays interest while in school) - Possibly some federal work-study depending on the school - Institutional aid varies widely by school - private colleges often offer more need-based aid You're correct that Pell Grants currently have a cutoff around 3000 SAI for maximum amounts, with partial grants available up to about 6000 SAI. Your daughter might receive a small Pell Grant, but it won't be the maximum amount. The most significant aid will likely come from the schools themselves - their institutional funds often far exceed federal aid options for middle-income families.
0 coins
Fatima Al-Qasimi
Does anyone know if the SAI varies for different kids in the same family? We have twins and I'm wondering if they'll get the same SAI or if it could be different somehow. Also waiting on our number but getting nervous seeing everyone else's starting to come in.
0 coins
Dylan Cooper
•For the 2024-2025 FAFSA, multiple students from the same household should receive identical SAI calculations, since the new FAFSA no longer adjusts for multiple college students in the same family. However, schools may adjust their institutional aid to account for multiple children in college simultaneously. This is a significant change from the old system, which automatically reduced each student's EFC when multiple siblings attended college at the same time.
0 coins
Dmitry Volkov
I must have submitted our FAFSA 10 different times because of glitches and errors this year. The whole rollout has been a nightmare! Glad you got a decent SAI though. We're still waiting... application status has been stuck on "processing" for almost 3 months. Did you have to call FSA to get your results or did they just show up?
0 coins
Amara Okafor
•They just showed up! I checked the portal yesterday morning and still nothing, then checked again after dinner and there it was. No email notification or anything. Maybe try logging in to studentaid.gov again? The system is so glitchy that sometimes the information appears without any notification.
0 coins
Sofia Ramirez
6254 is definitely on the lower side for an SAI! That should translate to decent institutional aid at most schools. Just be prepared for the CSS Profile schools to potentially calculate a higher family contribution - they count home equity and other assets that FAFSA ignores. Also, don't forget to appeal your aid packages once they arrive! With all the FAFSA chaos this year, financial aid offices have more flexibility than usual to adjust packages.
0 coins
Amara Okafor
•Thanks for the CSS Profile insight - that's what I'm worried about. We've lived in our house for 20 years so there's substantial equity, but it's not like we can access that money for college! I'll definitely plan to appeal if the packages seem insufficient.
0 coins
Tami Morgan
Congratulations on getting your SAI! 6254 is actually really encouraging - you're in a good spot for need-based aid. I'm also navigating this process for the first time with my son, and the stress has been unreal with all the delays and system issues. One thing I learned from our college financial aid workshop is that schools using both FAFSA and CSS Profile often have more institutional aid available, especially for families in your SAI range. The CSS Profile might bump up your expected contribution some due to home equity and other assets, but many private schools also have larger endowments to help bridge those gaps. Definitely start that scholarship search now - even small local scholarships add up! Our guidance counselor recommended checking with local Rotary clubs, credit unions, and community foundations. Good luck with everything!
0 coins
Amara Eze
•Thank you for the encouragement! It's such a relief to hear from other parents going through this for the first time. The stress has been incredible, especially with all the uncertainty around the new system. I really appreciate the tip about local organizations - I hadn't thought about credit unions and community foundations. Our school's guidance department has been pretty overwhelmed this year with all the FAFSA issues, so getting advice from other parents like you has been invaluable. Fingers crossed that the CSS Profile doesn't hurt us too much with the home equity situation!
0 coins
Fatima Al-Qasimi
Just wanted to chime in as another newcomer to this whole process! Your SAI of 6254 gives me hope - we're still waiting on ours but have similar household income. I've been lurking in this community for weeks trying to understand how the new FAFSA system works, and honestly all the horror stories had me convinced we'd get stuck with some astronomical number. Quick question for everyone - I keep seeing mentions of appealing aid packages. Is that something most families do, or only in special circumstances? This is all so new to me and I don't want to miss any opportunities to help my daughter afford college. The whole system seems so much more complicated than when I went to school!
0 coins
Emma Johnson
•Welcome to the community! I'm pretty new here too, and everyone has been so helpful. From what I've learned, appealing aid packages is actually pretty common - not just for special circumstances. Many schools have additional institutional funds they can allocate beyond their initial offer, especially this year with all the FAFSA delays causing chaos. The key is to be polite but persistent, and provide any documentation of changed circumstances (job loss, medical expenses, etc.) if applicable. Even without special circumstances, you can often ask them to reconsider based on competing offers from other schools. Don't be afraid to advocate for your daughter - the worst they can say is no!
0 coins